There are at least two things going on with gear boxes.
The resonant issue which we have discussed at length
and the shock issue. To illustrate I will choose an
example that everyone is familiar with.
If you take a cold chisel and place it on a piece of
steel and hit it with a steel hammer what happens? It damages
the steel of course. Now if you hit it with a rubber hammer
the damage is much less.
That is the principle of the rubber coupling or fluid coupling.
It is better than a direct hard drive to a gear box. Direct drive
will change the resonant frequency of the over all system
but that is not the only thing we need. We need a way of smoothing
out those torque pulses so we can make smaller and lighter gear boxes.
Tracy uses Neoprene rubber. So far that has worked for hundreds
of hours in dozens of geared rotary powered airplanes.
If one is
concerned with the heat deterioration of Neoprene one can always
go with silicone. So far that has not been necessary and a cheap
$100 set of Ford planetary gears has been perfectly adequate
along with Tracy's torque pulse mitigation plate.
Here is a direct drive gear box (no rubber coupling) for a big
block Chevy V8. Notice the huge size and weight. V8 engines have
a much less severe torque pulse variation than a 4 cylinder piston
engine. A two cylinder rotary has a even less severe torque pulse
variation than a four cylinder piston engine.
Rolls Royce worked for ten years on the geared V12 Merlin to overcome
crankshaft resonant issues. They finally got the TBO up to 1000
hours by placing a hollow quill shaft in the gear box drive and
other changes. A quill shaft is designed to wind or twist
a bit when the torque pulse occurs and store the pulse energy
and give it back before the next pulse comes along. That
smooths out the torque delivery to the gears reducing the stress.
Since the e-shaft is straight through it would be possible to
drill a long hole from the flywheel end and insert a quill shaft
into the end of the e-shaft, anchor it about in the middle
and drive the sun gear with that. A very elegant and light
weight solution.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.