I know of two RVs that are rotary powered and have broken powersport
redives. More hours than the dumb planetary but still gone. Cross
country takes them all out.
Skip Gorman
Many people have flown many hours cross country in Ford C6 based
planetaries. Some have over 1000 hours.
Some have failed yes but it was traced to incorrect machining.
Early Ross versions did not have sun gear thrust bearings but that
was corrected years ago in Ross and Tracy Crook designs.
Paul Lamar
Skip, do you have specifics about failure of any production Powersport
reduction gears?
Steve Beckham
Well Skip what is the answer?
Paul Lamar
It was just after Oshkosh on the way home. What they did about it
I don't know. But I will find out for you. It is my opinion that
the redrive has kept the aviation application from growing the way
it should. The people working on such units have no rotary back
ground in application. Gears are not the way to go. I have lots
more to say if you would like to talk privately. Bye
Skip Gorman
Everybody is entitledto his opinion but I am not going to allow
you to make a statement like that on here without backing it up
with the facts. Who, what, when and where.
It is a simple fact of physics that 160 cubic inch Mazda rotary is
not
going
to compete with a 320 cubic inch engine unless it can run twice as
fast.
It is also a simple fact of physics that a 70 inch propeller is
not going to rotateat 6000 RPM.
Paul Lamar
Skip Gorman says
"It is my opinion that
the redrive has kept the aviation application from growing the way
it should. The people working on such units have no rotary back
ground in application. Gears are not the way to go. I have lots
more to say if you would like to talk privately. Bye
Skip Gorman"
Skip, what has made this list-thread connection so good is that
nearly everything stated has been backed up by facts and drawings...
Then your statement comes along... Now it would appear that you have
things figured out (or think you do), and that you think it is better
than what any of us are presently doing or hoping for on the
redrive--Is that true? If so, I would be delighted in learning a
new and better way (yours) Who knows some of may be able to
contribute toyour ideas to make them bullet proof if not already.
Please do tell.
Scott W.
Paul,
IMHO a mistake of any gear box design is the omission of a
damper. If you don't run one between the shaft and the gear box, you
at
least need a harmonic balancer style one to help kill the resonance.
Everyone also has the wrong idea on lubrication. All gear boxes
should have
their own lube system and use a synthetic gear lube.... like the shell
aircraft turbine gear box lube. Turbo prop engine gear boxes have
used it
for many years.... using engine oil in the gear box is a mistake IMHO.
Larry
Self contained lub works with splash systems such as chain drives. If
pressure is needed it gets a lot more complicated. If the gear box
oil needs to be cooled a tranny cooler will have to fitted, somehow,
someplace. I doubt it can be done in the space we have. These
problems go away when the engine oil system is used. Jerry
Well damper equipped Ross and Tracy gear boxes, with engine oil, have been
successfully used for nearly 30 years. Every car in the world has a damper
between engine and gear box. Keep it simple.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.