Subject: Liquid cooled verses air cooled
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/20/2009, 9:11 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box




Re Liquid cooling:It's interesting to note that various models of
motorcycles continue to transition from air/oil cooled to coolant/oil
cooled.And, those same models continue to get lighter.That says to
me that liquid cooling, while somewhat more complex in some ways
(though less so in others), isn't heavier.Maybe someone knows of a
counter example..

Regards,

Matt-

Matt,
much of going to liquid cooling isn't about the weight. It's about
combustion control. Liquid cooling controls the temperature of the cylinder
head much better than an air cooled head. This allows making more hp for the
same displacement. When an air cooled cylinder head gets hot, the combustion
chamber becomes very prone to detonation, with this being the hp limiting
factor on many air cooled applications.
Larry

Right.. For a given displacement, more horsepower can be had from a
liquid cooled engine.. Countering the added weight of the liquid
cooling system.

Also, people might point out that liquid cooling is for emissions.
While I agree with that, I would say that an engine that produces
fewer emissions often will run cleaner and fewer service difficulties.

Matt-

Matt,
With modern heat exchangers it is veryhard for an air cooled engine to get anywhere close to a water-cooled engine in hp/cu.in.When you consider all factors I believe the flexibility of configuration isimpossible for an air-cooled engine to match.The switch to water cooling in modern motorcycles WAS NOT caused by emissions requirements. The change was well underway before those requirements became very stringent. Packaging was the reason.With water cooling you can make an inline four cylinder short enough to be anacceptable power plant for transverse mounting in a motorcycle.VariousV configurations are also possible that wouldn't be able to be cooledif air cooling was chosen. Getting back on the proper rotary track, air cooling of the rotary while possible, just isn't the way to go. The liquid cooled version will always be a more flexible package.
Bill Jepson



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.