Subject: I want to make a rotary engine
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/21/2009, 3:42 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

   Well as long as you start with 50 million dollars building
   your own Wankel should be no problem. You know what they say
   about aviation. "If you want to make a small fortune
 start with a
   large one" :)

   Paul Lamar


      Oh yes, that is one very famous quote
 in auto racing. My personal
   favorite is "I know there's money in racing, I put it
 there."  Back to
   the subject, $50 million we do not have, and if we did,
 that large sum
   would be going into certification. Granted, we may be
 fools for putting
   so much time and money into a project with such a poor
 history, however,
   we are still willing to go forward with our plans of
 making an aviation
   rotary engine despite the great opposition involved with
 such an
   undertaking.
   I am not here to start an argument about what we can or
 cannot do,
   merely collecting advice and opinions of other aviators
 to help
   increase our chances of success.

      Vladimir

   You will forgive us because we have seen it all before.
   Keep quiet and produce the goods.
   Just hang in here awhile and you will learn all you need
 to know.

   Paul Lamar

 Vlaldimir,
 My personal favorite would be a 150hp single rotor NA @ 150 lbs.
 - all
 aluminium, water cooled.
 Wear surfaces are important, det gun seems the best, or steel.
 If designing from  scratch, a wider lighter rotor. The
 Mazda 16X has gone
 back to the 12A width but bigger with a larger eccentric.
 It can be done- best of luck, looking forward to reading about your
 achievements.
 George (down under)

 Hi Vlaldimir,
     Avoid the mistakes of your predecessors.
 Mistral Engines is a hugely
 brilliant company with an outstanding product line. BUT, look at the
 aircraft statistics available thru the FAA. The marketplace is
 shiftingtoward Experimental light sport aircraft. Amateur built
 new registrations
 are rising strongly. Certificated PISTON powered new
 registrations are
 barely stable (even when adjusted for the current economic downturn).
 Certificated TURBOPROPS are on the rise but beyond our scope
 here. The
 certificated PISTON powered aircraft industry is mired in it's own
 business model and for insurance and liability reasons is unable to
 change as Mistral is finding out. The Rotary IS different and anything
 different in the certificated world is suspect...no matter how good!

     My suggestion is to tailor your business plan
 toward the EXPERIMENTAL
 marketplace ONLY. If you doubt the profit potential in this market,
 google " R V " and check up on Dick VanGruevnson ( 6,000 planes
 FLYING,only Dick knows how many kits sold still on the ground).
 Mistral has a
 CERTIFICATED engine package that is a very hard sell into an
 inflexiblecertificated industry and at the same time is way over
 priced for the
 experimental marketplace. Their certification costs have to be
 amortizedinto the engine pricing and that puts them in the same
 engine selling
 price bracket as the venerable old Lycoming or Continental
 competition.With no rotary cost advantage, a slightly higher
 rotary BSFC, and a
 customer mindset that history has proven the horizontally opposed
 piston engine viable, airframe manufacturer's have no incentive
 to change.

     BSFC....This is the place where if you
 seriously want to make a
 difference, You CAN make a difference. There are suggestions on this
 newsletter that are "application specific". It would be nice to
 incorporatesome of them but your goal should be to create as
 broad an accomplishment
 as possible for the money invested. Investigate
 "TURBOCOMPOUNDING". Paul
 and others on this list have done extensive background on this subject
 and will be here to help you in any way. Successfully done, this will
 give ALL rotary applications the advantage rotaries need to give
 airframemanufacturers that reason they need to justify designing
 around the
 rotary engine. The Mazda rotary engine work and works well, you can
 CHANGE it easily enough, but IMPROVING it will be very
 difficult. You
 can move the water pump, build in an alternator, charge cool it (not
 historically successful),etc....so what?

 BUT REDUCE THE FUEL COMSUMPTION 25 % and the world WILL notice.

 Dave M

 Brilliant essay Dave.
 Thanks.

 Paul Lamar

Vladimir,

From Dave M

"TURBOCOMPOUNDING". Paul
and others on this list have done extensive background on this subject
and will be here to help you in any way. Successfully done, this will
give ALL rotary applications the advantage rotaries need to give airframe
manufacturers that reason they need to justify designing around the
rotary engine.

And you why TURBOCOMPOUNDING Because the rotary engine has no exhaust
valve.  May I remind you :))  That is THE ADVANTAGE over the other
aircraft engines.  A LOWER BSFC over ANY other turbocompouding aircraft
engine.  Your friend/partner is right Vladimir :))

Marc Joseph


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.