Subject: Capacitor discharge verse inductive ignitions.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/27/2009, 12:13 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

Here are a few charts from Heinz Heislers book Advanced Engine
Tech and others. The first chart shows that; as the fuel air ratio gets
real lean and the pressure lowers in the combustion chamber
at high altitude the voltage required to fire the plugs goes up.
Klaus has exploited this situation to lean his engine out
at high altitude and improve the BSFC to remarkable levels
by increasing the spark voltage. He has achieved as much as
100 MPG at 130 MPH and 60 MPG at more reasonable cruising speeds.
This is a piston engine where the spark plugs are at one end
of the fire and the piston is at the other end.

In our case we have a moving combustion chamber where the fire
travels along side the spark plugs for quite some time. IMHO We want
the spark plugs to continue to fire for as long as the unburned
and burning mixture is still present moving past the plugs. That takes
8.3 ms at six thousand RPM cruise RPM. See chart 2.

A capacitor discharge ignition system is very good at firing
spark plugs fouled with 100 LL but it only fires for .2 ms. Even
an inductive system (Chevy LS1 coil) or stock Mazda ignition
only fires for about .8 ms.

IMHO NO WHERE LONG ENOUGH FOR WHAT WE NEED!

IMHO we need an ignition system to fire for 8.3 ms or 300 degrees.

TEN times as long. MSD makes a multiple spark capacitor
discharge ignition system widely used by Mazda rotary
engine racers but it only works up to 3000 RPM. After that it
is "one strong spark" says MSD. Not enough in IMHO. This is why
I am doing a m.s.d. ignition system with several pre-charged
capacitors fired in rapid sequence by a cheap single chip computer.
I hope this is a break through in improving the BSFC of
the rotary engine. I think it is worth a try.

Patent applied for :)

--------------------------------------------------

This is the range of rotor positions I intend repeatedly firing the spark
plug. Mostly the leading plug (lower plug) as one does not want to risk
igniting the mixture in the following chamber.

Paul Lamar

Good going Paul. We need the long duration. Will be very interesting.
Sure wish we access to the Mazda factory development notes and a supplyof
the three sparkplug rotor housings the Mazda factory built for the R26B
LeMan's engines to improve efficiency.

Steve Beckham

Steve,
Heck I would just like to be able to buy factor P-port housings for a
reasonable price!
2 plug or 3 I don't care.
Paul,
I think the long spacing idea is a good one. The only concern that I have
is actual
spark duration. Modern coils and CD ignition may improve things there. At
Kawasaki
in the 2 stroke era there were many single-spark CDIs. We found that the
super short
spark duration was a problem when lighting lean mixtures. Kawasaki had
tried surface
gap spark plugs, which had no side wire. The business end of the plug
looked like a little
target with the center electrode as the bullseye,a ceramic stripe andthem
the case
of the plug outside that. the surface gap plugs didn't work well because
they carbon
tracked easily and then there was a conductor for the spark to jump
through. Later
the choice was a standard plug with an incredibly large gap, around .100
inches!
Surprisingly this worked well because there was plenty of voltage to fire
the gap, and
with the long (length) spark they were more likely to actually hit someof
the mixture
molecules! The large gap standard plugs with single shot CDI lasted tothe
end of the
2-cycle era. If the duration of the spark can be improved you will have
better results
when firing the lean mixtures we want to run to improve BSFC on the
rotary.
Bill Jepson

Bill, regarding your note about problems associated with firing lean
mixtures with short duration CD, we experienced the same problem withlean
mixtures and found the inductive worked much better all round. Ourengines
were tuned for lower rpm peak power. I think the factory used a custom
electronic CD with their LeMans engine. One of the file reference books
shows a CD ignition in the ex-Le Mans three rotor 1986 IMSA GTObeforethey
later switched to the four rotor for GTO. But it appears the factory was
using CD for these engines even before going to the threesparkplugengines.
But longer duration inductive system worked better for our engines.

Steve Beckham

Steve,
As Paul and many others among our group have said, many thanks forsharing
your wealth of experience with rotary installations. Can't beat hands on
experience. Getting back to the CDI vs Conventional ignition, the rotary
is a unique case because the spark plugs can't protrude into the chamber
at all. Since the sliding seals prevent that I would think that a plug
that presented the electrodes as close as possible would be best. I read
that VW was experimenting with a no-side-wire plug and apointedprojection
on the piston to fire to. I don't know if they ever used it inproduction.
The spark actually jumped to the piston. I thought that this typeofsystem
would be perfect for the rotary. The plug could be closer to the rotor
without a side wire and the long spark would be perfect to ignite the
lean mixture. Having the plug closer would even bump the compression a
little. Just thinking out loud but it seems like a possibility.
Bill Jepson

We always removed the spark plug washer to move the plug closer.
Works great. There are washers available from Mazda.

Skip


Skip did you use no washer or the substitute washer from Mazda? Any
measurable difference in performance or other, such as different carbon
patterns on rotor at disassembly?


Steve Beckham

Steve, We took the washer off. It was a drag race application. The gain
was only measurable at the track clocks. We thought we had a secret
performance gain, then we found that Mazda Speed offers washers to
move the plug in or out.

Skip

Steve, I'd like to say some more about the spark plug issue. The sparkplug
washer trick did not have any effect on charged cooled rotaries. In fact
is was a negative effect. Don't know why that was. What did work is we
changed from a 14mm spark plug to a 10mm spark plug and gained some real
hp and torque. Ten to twelve hp on a single rotor. There is a serious
leak when the apex seal goes over the hole or any hole in the rotorhousing.
So the smaller the hole the better. I'd like to reduce the Mazda. I don't
know why they don't. Just about every mfg has gone to a smaller sparkplug.

Skip
-

That is only for the trailing plug Skip.
There must have been something else going on with the Rotamax.

Paul Lamar


Thanks Skip...no doubt about the factor of the apex seal going by the spark
plugs.I remember at some point one of the Mazda factory guys in the early
1990's telling us they dealt with this factor when they did the three
sparkplug modification for the four rotor LeMans project.They were using
castings with an additional sparkplug above the two original sparkplugs to
address the highly quenched trailing end and its poor flame propagation,
they made the plug hole as small as possible.It demonstrably worked to
address fuel consumption byburning some of the fuel that was before simply
going out the exhaust pipe.

But having said that, the leakage was clearly
evident because while it actually improved fuel consumption, the volumetric
efficiency of the engine dropped according to the Mazda folks.About the
simplest way they addressed the high-to-low pressure area flow was to keep
the plug hole as small as possible.For our application of the engine to
sustained high power settings involved in aircraft use, at this point in
development and using proven technologies, it seems the three sparkplug
approach with this small hole would work well to substantively address the
issue of this highly inefficient and quenched area in the combustion
chamber.

But Mazda is driven by the automotive production market and it is
clear they ran the numbers and more cost-effective to develop the two
sparkplug side port RX-8 to reduce the overlap and improve BSFC for road
cars.Just wonder whether deep in the bowels of Hiroshima whether a group
of people have, or arepresently working to save this little engine by
experimenting with more than one option, includingUncle Paul's turbo
compound ideas.If not, it is because their hands are tied financially by
short term cash flow and profitabilitythreatening car companies.The
Mazda organization has some amazing, smart folks who remain inspired by
their rotary "father", then later Mazda Chairman Yamamoto.It seems they
must have already, or are currently exploring the TC option to see what it
could hold for this little engine by putting to work that unusually high
amount of energy going out the exhaust pipe.

Meanwhile, absent any major
changes in design, we know a three sparkplug approach works to improve the
burn and improve fuel mileage.Yasuo Tatsutomi told Yoshinori Honiden they
had to reduce fuel consumption 10-15% to win LeMans with an rpm band that
could range from 6,000-9,000.To do that with a standard, homogenous charge
engine is like climbing Mt. Everest. They simply could not have done it
without those rotor housings.Even with them, the LeMans drivers had strict
orders from Yoshinori Honiden to lift and early/coast at the end of the
straight and soft pedal through the corners.The primary goal was fuel
savings but it was also easier on the engine heat flux.In this respect
they even went from black to silver paint on the upper engine cowlto
address temperature issues.

The previous year the ceramic exfoliated inside
the engines. Aircraft race duty cyle is harder--no lifting at the end of
the straight stretch and going into corners-- and we are attempting to do
that using what are basically warmed over, off-the-shelf production parts
for grocery getters.That is a serious challange no matter how we slice it.
But in the words of Nobuhiro Yamamoto (he headed up the third gen RX-7
engine development),after the LeMans effort,"We can no longer say we
share major components between the production and racing rotaries.But we
are still a very close bunch--the rotary people!"A rotary brother indeed.

-
Steve Beckham




-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.