Subject: TailwindForum] Re: weight and speed
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/30/2009, 10:00 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Paul,  this message was posted on the Tailwind Forum today.  I think
it could be  of interest to our group even though it is not about
rotaries.  Check it out before deciding to post.   Jerry


From: Schuyler Greenawalt
Sent: Sunday, March 29, 2009 10:19 PM
To: TailwindForum@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [TailwindForum] Re: weight and speed

Hello -

I just signed up last night for this forum, having been inspired by
the latest issue of Sport Aviation. One of my initial thoughts was
"wow, that would be a really easy wing to build with composite
materials" - funny that very topic is at the top of this group at
this moment. I work at a homebuilt builder assistance center, and
having read through the posts on this topic there's a few places
where I think I may be able to shed some light. For people who
aren't into the composite wing idea - this might be a pretty lengthy
post and you may want to just skip it :)

First, it should be pointed out that there are two distinct methods
of producing a wing - molded and moldless. They are similar in
required skills, but really quite different on many levels. The
classic example of moldless construction is of course the Rutan
designs, and a molded wing would be your Lancairs, Glasairs etc.
Each has its' own set of advantages and disadvantages. The Tailwind
wing could be done either way, it's just a matter of what works for
you.

Moldless:
For a moldless approach to the Tailwind wing, you would start with a
hot wire cut foam core, and then laminate your spars and skins over
this. This is a well established technique, and there are probably
many builders all over the world who would be happy to help you out
with the hands on construction. We are currently building a very
large (12 foot span) horizontal stabilizer for a customer using this
method, and I can say that it's a very quick and accurate way to
build. Moldless gets a bad rap for two reasons - accuracy/surface
waviness and for the long hours spent sanding to get a nice finish.
There's a few things that I can say about this. First, there are now
vendors who have CNC hot wire cutters. We used one (Eureka CNC) for
the cores for this project and I have to say they are nothing short
of amazing. The smoothest, most accurate cores I have ever seen -
which keeps the waviness down, the accuracy up. I designed a set of
jigs for this job (maybe I'll post some pics if people are
interested) that we had a local metal fabrication shop cut with
their new CNC waterjet. The accuracy of the CNC foam cores, combined
with the CNC waterjetted jig fixtures means we'll get a very
straight and true tailplane, with a minimum of filling/sanding etc.
Sure, we'll still have to fill the weave of the top layer (but you
guys have to do that with your fiberglass covered wood) but there
won't be a ton of peaks and valleys to sand and fill. The really
neat thing about this approach is this - someone could draft up the
templates for CNC hot wire cutting and the water jetted jigs as
well. If this would be an "open source" approach to this wing,
people could just order up the foam from a vendor and then go and
get their jigs cut locally (water jets are widespread and usually
the service is quite reasonably priced). No master tooling would
need to be stored/mainained - the tooling needed for this approach
would be electronic and easily distributed. The chore of filling the
weave can also be aided by some nifty vacuum bagging tricks - on a
straight lofted surface like the Tailwind wing you really don't have
to spend months sanding and filling pinholes.

Advantages:
Low tooling cost (just some jigs)
Easy to learn techniques - ask your local LongEZ, VariEZ builder
Accurate (if done with CNC)
"Open source" approach means many people could try it.

Disadvantages:
Not cheap (carbon is pricey, CNC cut cores aren't cheap but worth
their weight in gold, IMO)
Fairly light, but molded construction CAN be lighter
You can have this wing in any color you like as long as it's white.
Since blue foam melts around 165 degrees F, even if you use high
temp resins, the core can't get too hot - hence the white paint.
No wet wings - avgas eats blue foam.

Molded Construction:

For molded construction, typically someone would make a plug of the
entire wing, and then make a mold for the skins from there.
Additionally, other molds would need to be made for the spars and
such. If low weight is the absolute goal, this would be the
approach. However, in order to realize low weight, pre-impregnated
carbon (pre-preg) would need to be used, which is expensive,
requires a degree of skill not usually found in average homebuilder
and would require a very large oven/autoclave to cure the parts. In
addition, the mold would need to be able to withstand the
temperatures of oven curing, which means you're looking at some
fairly advanced, and expensive tooling. Lancair wing skins are made
in this fashion, and they're very light, but most certainly not
cheap. Also, pre-preg carbon has so little resin in it, you end up
having to fill the weave just as you would with moldless
construction. Making a full size plug of the wing, that's accurate
and free of waviness/defects is no easy task either - for the amount
of time required just for the plug, you could have a moldless wing
finished. Very few homebuilders would be able to construct a large
oven in their garage, and so you would need to find a shop
specializing in pre-preg layups. There's a few out there, but
they're not exactly in every city.

Advantages:
Lightest weight
Can be painted something other than white
Wet wings would be an option

Disadvantages:
Cost and time required for tooling
Cost of fabrication
Highest skill level required

Infusion/RTM
Infusion molding was mentioned in this thread, and while I haven't
done any actual infusion molding, I am familiar with the process.
Infusion molding would most likely be used in a molded construction
approach. If the goal of a composite Tailwind wing is to reduce
weight, I can say this is probably not the way to do it. By design,
infusion molding uses vacuum to pull resin into every last little
void in your carbon/fiberglass. If you have a very smooth mold, the
nice thing about infusion is that you get a very smooth surface,
that doesn't have any weave to fill. The drawback as I said is
weight. For carbon, ideally you'd like to see around 35% resin
content. Infusion is going to take you WAY over that, which can
actually make your structure weaker and heavier. A good hand layup
can usually be lighter than infusion - in fact I can't think of a
method that's heavier than infusion.

Engineering:
It should be noted, that both the approaches above would require
engineering by a qualified composites engineer. You can't simply
take the layup schedule from say a Long EZ wing and figure that
would work in this case. Unless there's someone on here who is
qualified and wants to donate to the cause, this would most likely
be the most expensive part of this endeavor, regardless of
construction method. If the original airfoil is used, no aerodynamic
analysis would need to be done, but if you want to go changing it,
well it would add to the cost of course.

FWIW, I think the moldless method would be the way to go. CNC hot
wire cores makes this such an easy process, and really reduces the
amount of skill required to do it. The only real downside is weight
- my guess is that these wings would not be significantly lighter
than the wood ones. Say you save 25 lbs on the pair - sure it's
better than having 25 more pounds, but will 25 pounds really change
your plane? Most likely no. These wings would be really easy to
build though, and would most likely go together in far less time
than the wood wings. By having the cores CNC cut and the jigs as
well, these wings would build very quickly. Three of us laid up a
12' carbon fiber spar on Friday and we'll do the second spar
tomorrow. Roughly 4 days of labor after that (with three of us
working on it) will be required to get it to the point where we'll
be filling the weave - not counting the time it will take to hang
the elevators (long story). That's quick! Also, the idea that the
tooling for this wing would be electronic and therefore easily
passed means that more people might be enticed to jump on the
composite bandwagon.

Okay, that's a pretty long post for a first post! I'll post some
pics for people who are interested of the stab we're constructing
and the CNC water jetted jig.

Schuyler Greenawalt

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.