HI PAUL
I WONDERING IF SOMEONE TRY THE SAME SYSTEM AS FUEL
INJECTION WITH
SERVO,SPYDER AND MECHANICAL INJECTORS,IT SEEMS SO SIMPLE
TO COMPARE
WITH THE ELECTRONIC FUEL SYSTEM.
I ASK QUESTIONS BEFORE CONVERT THE 2005 GENESIS
THANK,S PAUL
Jean Prudhomme
Yes it is. Steve Beckham on here did a lot of work with
mechanical fuel
injection.
The Mazda rotary engine road racers used it for years.
Paul Lamar
Jean--Don Rivera at Airflow Performance is the guy you
need to contact.
He
supplies a complete fuel injection system for rotary
aircraft engines.
We
dyno and flight tested his stuff for over 10 years on
various rotary
aircraft engines and it worked perfectly. Don worked at
Bendix and his
mechanical fuel injection system for aircraft engines is
very similar.
Don's
system works as well as, if not better than the original
system. Don
also
services certified aircraft Bendix-based systems which
are still
supplied
on
new Lycomings, and offers all kinds of services to
experimental aircraft
builders including components and full systems. His units
are also sold
by
Van's Aircraft.The system we developed for rotary
aircraft engines in
the
late 80's and early 90's used Don's
components. He has done rotary
projects
with Jim M @ Racing Beat as well. Sean Tucker and all
the top airshow
and
aerobatic competitors use Don's injection systems.
Great guy, great
family
owned and operated company with great service and
products.
Steve Beckham
Steve or anyone know how much this system costs - a bunch
is my guess.
George (down under)
$2,860.95 is the list price from Airflow Performance for
the 13B kit.
Vlad
Vlad,
I can see why your looking at carbies.
George (down under)
That's pretty steep pricing, indeed. Is it cheaper
than the Lycoming
setup? The rotary only needs half the nozzles and spider
outlets.
Then again, I guess it's probably a fuel pump setup
that's not common
to anyone else - the LyCont FI setups being accessory
case driven..
The Holley with the leaning block looks better and
better. I'm not
_that_ interested in sustained inverted flight. For
naturally
aspirated, I think the Holley will be tough to beat.
Parts available
world-wide, any mechanic can figure out how it works,
cheap rebuilds,
known tuneability.
I think the only way FI makes sense on the rotary is for
forced
induction or for aerobatics (which opens a whole other
set of
challenges (oil management)). FI makes more sense on a
regular
multi-cylinder piston engine because it offers relatively
easy
balancing of fuel flows between the cylinders. On a two
rotor engine,
it should be relatively easy to get good fuel (and air)
distribution
given that there are only two induction paths.
Regards,
Matt-
I couldn't have said it better Matt. I'd venture
to say that the Airflow
Performance kit is most likely still cheaper than the OEM
system. In
regards
to the Holley, sure seems nice to pay $80 for a oem
'renew' kit and drop
the
whole lot off at a local mechanic for a rebuild. Talk
about chump change
in
aviation money.
Vlad
Good.
The only thing I might back off from is Paul's 555
system. It
definitely shows a lot of promise, but it's as yet
unproven. I am
hopeful, but I'm still enamored with the idea of
buying nearly off the
shelf stuff. It also sounds like Mark's engine may
be around the
corner with Tracy's injection system. I'll be
interested in
continuing updates on Mark's status.
Regards,
Matt-
Matt are you sending stuff out in html format?
Paul Lamar
Paul's 555 system shows an amazing amount of
potential. If I were ever in
need of a standalone, I would either build a 555 or buy a
MegaSquirt and
call it a day. The simplicity and cost make the 555 really
shine but the
problem I have with the system is the need for a MAF
sensor. I understand
why Tracy choose to use MAP instead as the costs for a new
MAF sensor are
just ridiculous. This all goes back to how many people
REALLY need efi?
Vlad
I'll be back working on that soon. I have a p-port RX8
motor I will run it
one.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
I'm not an electrical engineer by any stretch of the
imagination so I have
to ask why can't the 555 system be converted to run
info from a MAP sensor?
I know I said I'd refrain from asking questions as to
'not waste your time'
but I'll play a hypocrite for the sake of knowledge.
Vlad
You could but why would you want to do that? You have seen
all the
trouble people have had trying to tune MAP systems. It is
not for nothing
the entire automotive world uses mass air flow sensors. The
mass air flow sensor
does it all for you.
I guess I'm not much for the value of money, but the price of an
after market mass MAF for say, a 5.4l v-8 is about $110, I've
seen them for less on close-outs and smaller engines. I don't
think that's excessive. $30,000 for an IO-360, now that's expensive.
In many cases, I've found that the cheapest route isn't always
the best in the long run, whether it is from cheap things wearing
out or failing prematurely(then having to pay again to replace it),
or quality issues that aren't readily appearent. I don't let my
ego prevent me from admitting that I made a mistake in the decision
making process to go cheap. If money were the issue, I wouldn't be
flying, I would be bowling. My opinion only, your results may vary.
C. Smith
They cost as little as $10 in a junk yard. You can check them in
a junk yard with an ohm meter :) If they are working they are as
good as new. Many are rejected by the dealers when all they need
is a bit of cleaning with a tooth brush and alcohol.
I had to clean the one in my V8 Mercury
Cougar once a year :) Take it into the dealer and drive out
with a $500 bill :) My 94 OBD II V8 Merury Cougar "check engine" light
came on. No idea of what was wrong. I kept driving it for a couple
of months and finally it started to miss real bad. I took it into
the dealer and paid them $82 just to diagnose it.
This light can come on and will stay on for any one of 256 different
"faults". One of which is leaving your gas cap off. You then need
to take it into the dealer and have him turn the "check engine"
light off for $82. If you don't do that and you take the car in
to have it's CA bi-annual smog check and the smog person sees the light
on it won't pass smog.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.