I just ran across this data on the 2nd gen RX7 mass airflow sensor.
Bosch wrote it up as part of the L jetronic injection system manual.
I suspect it is made by Denso under license and installed
in 1986 to 1991 RX7's. I don't think it is a computer.
I think it is similar to a 555 system. All hardware and no
software.
Perry Mick has been flying this system for years in his Long EZ
with hundreds of hours.
It is very reliable. He has tricked the ECU into thinking it is
still in car. He has even installed an RX7 instrument panel
in the cockpit.
There are probably over 100,000
of these systems out there. They are real cheap I suspect.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
This may not be doable for Aviation and I have no doubt that someone
will
tell me why, however all ideas should be explored if only to eliminate
them
IMHO. Now some motorcycle carbs have floating slides whereby the
density
of
the incoming air varies the slide compared to the throttle position
- for
altitude compensation. I can't remember exactly how this is
accomplished
by
lifting the slide with the incoming air. There is a sloped face
which is
supposed to have a critical angle to accomplish this task. It may be
there
is a calibrated spring that air density is pushing against.
This is the simplest solution air density adjustment I have heard
about.
For your consideration.
George ( down under)
George,
My motorcyle has these. Tuned for sea level, it runs rich when going
over
the Sierra's.
If you tune it for Denver, pings like crazy at sea level.....
The slide is lifted pulling the mixture needle out of the jet by the
low
pressure area created by the air flowing by an orfice in the bottom of
the
piston.
The top of the slide has a larger piston (or diaphram) and the vac
on the
top side pulls the slide up. But they are not density sensitive.
Sorry.....
Larry
Larry,
I disagree, there is a degree of self adjustment when crusing. There
will
obviously be a POWER loss as I'm sure you are aware. There are limits,
because the diaphragm is frequently over sized so the slide will
respond
quickly, many sudden throttle openings, (like driving in traffic), will
show rich on the plugs. Steady state crusing will lean after you reach
steady state. With respect to aircraft, the carbs will work better than
the
motorcycle use since throttle openings don't change very quickly. For
leaning that is
Bill Jepson
Thanks Bill, Larry, Matt & Vlad.
There certainly are some interesting points, food for thought. Not as
simple
as I first thought.
Never heard about lowering the jet instead of raising the needle
Matt, my
initial thoughts are that it may raise some sealing issues as the fuel
goes
through the jet - probably some O-rings involved. My idea of raising
the
needle may well need some O-rings as well
I guess I will have to keep thinking.
George (down under)
Bill,
you are correct in there is some degree of self adjusting, being a
rung up
the ladder from the typical booster venturi carb design.
hot wire mass air is just further up the ladder.
Larry
Larry, Paul, and group,
I think there are distinct ways to go on the Rotary. Simple: Carburetor
induction and simple ignition, even coil and points will work. Moderate
technology: Keep as many of the systems mechanical as possible.
Bendix or
airflow technology mechanical injection. Proven reliable
electronicignition.
Lastly full modern system: EMS or at leastfull electronicFI. I do agree
withPaul that the modern MAF sensor is the way to go. These are very
reliable devices and are not as pulse sensitive as the map sensor.
For the
rotary the EMS should be capable of being a "single lever" system with
complete altitude compensation but for best results LOP operation
should
be
possible.
The modern system is where we have been headed, with some
diversions. The
rotary really begs for LOP operation to improve BSFC. The real problem
that
we have is that often people expect a system to be "bolt on" and
that is a
reasonable thing to want. The problem is that there are so may
variables
on
amateur-built aircraft that it is almost impossible for an EMS to be
programmed properly "out of the box". I read a very interesting article
written by one of the recent Corvette engineers about all-electronic
engine
management systems. His comment was that to make one work (an EMS) took
every bit as much tuning as a carburetor and mechanical ignition
system,
and
sometimes more. It was a very honest evaluation, with the insight of a
manufacturer to back it up. The comment he made was that every time you
change induction, exhaust orengine internals a new complete engine
map has
to be made. The system will get the engine close to begin with and is
somewhat self adjusting but fine tuning needs to be done for the
particular
combination of induction exhaust and engine timing. (cams and valves
in a
piston engine, porting and compression in the rotary)
My point is that the
guys that buy Tracy's system shouldn't be supprised that some tuning
skills
will be needed and the tuning will take some time. This is going to be
true
OF ANY SYSTEM from the simplest to the most complex. An EMS gives
you more
tools, and a degree of self-adjustment but you will still need to know
what
you are doing, there is no "silver bullet" system. When Paul was
working
on
the dyno He didn't have the time, (read $$$), to tune Tracy's system
and
changed over and ran a carb system that the Mazdatrix had already spent
the
time tuning. A wise choice considering the cost of Dyno time. It seems
like
we cycle through the desire to keep everything a simple as possible
to a
full EMS and back. Any system used will take time to get exactly right.
For
what it's worth.
Bill Jepson
Paul,
I apologize if my reply is hashed up.. I haven't got gmail fixed yet,
but can't resist replying.. :)
Not arguing with Bill.. I agree with his points in general. But:
The airplane operating requirements are relatively simple compared to
that of a performance car like a Corvette. In the Corvette, they want
good throttle response at all RPM, and good fuel economy with very
minimal driver involvement - one lever. On the other hand, the
airplane really has only a couple of requirements.. It can't quit.
It can't burn too much fuel in cruise. It has to make the peak
horsepower afforded by the mechanical limits of the engine. That's
not too bad by comparison. The airplane engine doesn't have to idle
all that well as long as it doesn't actually quit. It can have a
separate lever for controlling power vs. economy. All of this makes
the tunability of the airplane easier to accomplish by comparison.
As far as running the engine on the dyno, I think that was a p-port,
and it was being run with the manifold pressure tap located at the
wrong place on the engine for good readings. It would be interesting
to hop on the dyno with the mp tap installed in the housing and see
how the tuning goes.
Regards,
Matt-
Looks fixed to me. This looks fine.
Paul Lamar
Wonderful response Bill. I would add that the choice between carb, mech
fi,
efi, distributor, dis, etc boils down to not only simplicity but also
cost.
This wouldn't be the case in the certified market but since we don't
have
to
jump hops for the FAA, we can choose our options based on more than
just a
certificate. With regards to fuel delivery, it seems like the only two
cost
effective options are the Holley and custom efi (555, Tracy's,
Megasquirt.)
If someone could find a better carb in terms of function and cost, that
would be cool but at this point that seems very unlikely. Mech fi
would be
a
very good feature if it wasn't SO expensive. For $2900 I could buy a
Motec
(read $$$) and still have money left for dyno tuning. While custom efi
would
be the holy grail of performance and flexibility, how many people
really
need it? The turbocharged and the aerobatic (are there any using
Mazda's?)
could genuinely use them, for everyone else, seems unlikely.
Vlad
--
My problem with electronic FI is in the systems support.. Requires
independent, redundant power (dual alternators), and high pressure
fuel. Not insurmountable by any means, but I'm not convinced the
payoff is worth it for what I want to be flying.
Matt-
It's part of the risk that one must accept when building or flying an
experimental aircraft or using a non-certified engine. Am I against
making
the systems safer and less likely to cause a catastrophic failure, no.
But
I'm not asking an engine from a car to be as redundant and rudimentary
(read
safe) in design as a $25k+ aero engine. Would I fly an efi rotary with a
single alternator, battery, ecu, etc., yes. If I was that concerned about
safety, I would get a certified slug and call it a day.
Vlad
To interject a disrupting thought. I have a Bosch CIS fuel injection
running on a rotary in an airplane. Al thought the plane has not flown(
a problem with me not the plane), the injection was extensively tested
on the ground on a test stand. The CIS is a mass flow sensor with
automatic mixture adjustment. In addition the mixture can be
modified to any level from too rich to run to too lean to run. All the
hard work of air verses fuel has been done at time of manufacture of the
unit.
The units are very inexpensive from a junk yard. I have several that I
have used on cars that were no where worn out. A little clean up and
they work perfectly.
However they are not without problems.
1. Size is a problem.
2. High pressure fuel.
3.Weight might be a problem. They are not light because of the cast iron
fuel distributor.
C Smale
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.