Subject: EFI verses carbs
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/17/2009, 11:31 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box




 My problem with electronic FI is in the systems support..
 Requires
 independent, redundant power (dual alternators), and high
 pressure
 fuel. Not insurmountable by any means, but I'm not
 convinced the
 payoff is worth it for what I want to be flying.


 Matt-

 It's part of the risk that one must accept when
 building or flying an
 experimental aircraft or using a non-certified engine. Am
 I against
 making
 the systems safer and less likely to cause a catastrophic
 failure, no.
 But
 I'm not asking an engine from a car to be as redundant
 and rudimentary
 (read
 safe) in design as a $25k+ aero engine. Would I fly an efi
 rotary with a
 single alternator, battery, ecu, etc., yes. If I was that
 concerned about
 safety, I would get a certified slug and call it a day.
 Vlad

 To interject a disrupting thought. I have a Bosch CIS fuel
 injection
 running on a rotary in an airplane. Al thought the plane
 has not flown(
 a problem with me not the plane), the injection was
 extensively tested
 on the ground on a test stand. The CIS is a mass flow
 sensor with
 automatic mixture adjustment. In addition the mixture can
 be
 modified to any level from too rich to run to too lean to
 run. All the
 hard work of air verses fuel has been done at time of
 manufacture of the
 unit.
 The units are very inexpensive from a junk yard. I have
 several that I
 have used on cars that were no where worn out. A little
 clean up and
 they work perfectly.
 However they are not without problems.
 1. Size is a problem.
 2. High pressure fuel.
 3.Weight might be a problem. They are not light because of
 the cast iron
 fuel distributor.

 C Smale

 I was going through my records, the MAF I purchased new from Rock Auto was
 $61, ('02 5.4l V8) didn't have to hunt through junk yard, just type on
 keyboard, no time spent removing, or driving to junk yard, or cleaning and
 reconditioning. ABS sensors, $22 ea, same conditions, with added benefit
of
 not laying on my back in the mud or getting crud in my face removing them.

 Time spent researching part numbers and tracking down flow data for
suitable
 injectors so far I've put in maybe 4-5 hrs. I have decided it is easier to
 just buy some 42 lb ford racing injectors(known qualities), set of 8 for
 $210, that's $26.25 ea. free shipping. Anyone want the other 4?
 That's under $300 so far. I figure, maybe another $200 for the rest of the
 electronic 555 parts and circuit boards. Fuel runner and regulator,
haven't
 priced yet, can't be that much.
 I figure the rest of the intake stuff like tubes and slide throttle would
be
 necessary no matter how you skinned the P-Port cat, so those costs are
 comparably the same.

 Because of differences in the MAF and injectors anyone decides to use(or
 carburators, and differences in how you make your induction setup), I
agree
 that anyone choosing to go rotary should be prepared to put in tuning
time.
 Everyone has to do it, so it is not a differentiating factor. I REALLY
like
 the FI systems resistance to icing.
 I dont think hardening the electronics is going to be difficult, I plan on
 using an appropriately sized MOV and LM-150K (proven and reliable,
 inexpensive) in front of the control circuitry.
 I really can't see any substantial cost difference in either approach.
 Your results may vary.
 C. Smith

 As far as having two power sources for an EFI airplane, my thought is that
 instead of having two alternators, have two batteries-  by a new one every
 year and rotate the oldest one out. I have two  Powersonic 28 amp/hr
 batteries that are sealed saturated fiberglass mat, cost about $50 each.
If
 the alternator goes out, I have enough juice in the two batteries to fly
 quite a ways to a safe landing strip. A  charged battery in good condition
 is one of the most reliable power sources around.


 Brian Trubee

 Brian, that is how Cessna has set up their G-1000 aircraft, although
 rotating batteries wasn't part of the maintenance plan. They use a split
 bus, essentials on one, everything else on the other. A complete charging
 system failure would still leave you with a 45 min reserve battery to
power
 one display at some reduced capability. I feel quite comfortable with
 electronics, and a well thought out electrical system architecture. There
is
 a fellow named Bob Knuckolls, runs a list called Aeroelectric Connection.
 His book and website cover just about any set-up you could envision, and
he
 answers questions with factual information backed up with well researched
 documentation.

 I think proper battery testing (yes, there is a right way to load test
that
 allows you to not have to just buy batteries on a fixed schedule) is
 reliable enough and well proven, so I would be comfortable with a dual
 battery, single alternator, split bus system.

 When I get to the point of final board design, I'll consider a few
different
 back-up/emergency systems for the FI. I will share that when it happens
down
 the road.
 C. Smith


All well and good..  Testing batteries, changing batteries, etc.
However, dual alternators is less maintenance which equals more flying
and less fiddling.  How many batteries will you replace before meeting
the cost of the second alternator?

At the power consumption of a complete EFI system, how big does the
battery need to be to support flight to the exhaustion of fuel on
board?  Having to land within 45 min of electrical failure while
there's still fuel in the tank is not a good design choice for a
traveling airplane.  Especially if you plan to fly anything but clear
VFR.  If you don't care about weather flying, that's fine, it just
doesn't satisfy what I'm going for.


Matt-

Let's address all those questions, one at a time.

How many batteries will you replace before meeting

the cost of the second alternator?

Can you tell me how much the second alternator architecture you are thinking
of costs vs a single alternator single battery architecture?
Given that all batteries should be load tested annually, or if you subscribe
to the replace at intervals, (I'm hoping no one subscribes to the use till
failure system) any given scenario is a two battery system will be replacing
2 batteries on average over a battery lifetime. How does the price of
batteries compare to your dual alternator? I can't answer that if you don't
tell me what your dual alternator architecture costs.

At the power consumption of a complete EFI system, how big does the

battery need to be to support flight to the exhaustion of fuel on
board?

How much fuel do you have on board? What is the power consumption of your
EFI system? Is your emergency requirement MAX on board fuel? Wouldn't that
depend on your aircraft.

Having to land within 45 min of electrical failure while

there's still fuel in the tank is not a good design choice for a
traveling airplane.

I have to call your judgment on this one, I think the FAA considers an
electrical failure a cause for landing at nearest airport, and cause for
immediate landing. I'll carefully say that any pilot who would even consider
flying any further than the nearest landing in the face of a known
electrical system failure to be wreckless. [reckless? :)]

I have an instrument rating, and the G-1000 architecture meets certified IFR
requirements. Rhetorical questioning doesn't advance the body of knowledge.
If you have specific requirements, and already done your own cost analysis,
help me with the figures please.
C. Smith


C. Smith,

That the FAA certifies something doesn't make it good or even
particularly capable.  All it means is that the thing they certified
meets a certain set of specifications.  It doesn't actually make it
safe or guarantee its utility.

Please keep in mind that I'm not actually a big fan of EFI in an
airplane.  I like the idea on its own, but when integrating the system
into a real airplane, I think there are real challenges.  I want a
fuel system that allows the airplane to use all of the fuel on board
even after the failure of any single electrical component.  For
gravity feed or engine driven pump, this is a non-issue.  if the
system is EFI, that complicates the systems side of things because of
the relatively high power draw of these systems, and because the
engine needs them in order to run at all - unless a redundant fuel
system is included.

The operating scenarios that might make having your airplane's
endurance unexpectedly cut short are several.  One is operating over
water - beyond 45 minutes (or whatever your battery capacity is) from
the nearest airport.  A similar scenario is making a flight where at
least some of the airports along the route are below IFR minimums.
These are not crazy ideas, nor even particularly unusual situations.

To answer your question, if I chose EFI, I would likely use one belt
driven automotive style alternator and a permanent magnet (motorcycle
derived) dynamo mounted on the e-shaft.  At least, that's my first
idea.  But still, I'm not committed to having an electrically
dependent engine.

Finally, I believe Bob Nuckolls supports the idea that a second
alternator can be a significantly better value than a second battery
(or outsized first battery).  We can move this discussion to his list
and see where he might weigh in.


Regards,

Matt-


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.