Paul Yaw wrote:
Hi everybody,
I would like to point out a few things concerning intake tuning that I
think are inaccurate, and expand on a few others.
For some reason that I cannot explain, whenever I verbally disagree with
someone I tend to feel that I am being argumentative and abrasive. As a
result, I normally keep my mouth shut if I disagree with someones
opinion. Because of that weird personality quirk, I had not intended to
respond to this. Then it occurred to me that I certainly wasn't doing
anyone a favor since the whole point of this mailing list is the
exchange of ideas. So here goes.
Tracy Crook wrote:
I think we must remember there are two different methods of tuning at work
here.
The tuned pipe manifold that has been the major topic of discussion on
this
thread depends almost entirely on inertial effects
A "tuned pipe" refers to using the naturally occurring organ pipe
resonance to "supercharge" the engine. Inertial supercharging is an
entirely different matter, but both methods rely on increasing the
pressure at the intake port during the period from bottom dead center to
intake port closing.(Approximately 70 degrees after bottom dead center
on a 6-port 13B) The purpose is to create a pressure differential
between the intake port, and the chamber so that the chamber will
continue to fill even though its volume is decreasing.
(once the air starts
moving in the pipe it wants to stay in motion) and the resonant frequency
of
the pipe. (major simplification here) This is certainly a legitimate
method
of increasing volumetric efficiency but it has certain drawbacks. One is
that the improvement works over a small range of engine speeds (and as has
been pointed out, actually hurts at others) and the pipe length is rather
long at the engine speeds we want in aircraft use.
Regardless of the length of a pipe, these pressure waves will ALWAYS
exist.However, the pressure waves will typically be stronger in a
longer pipe of the same diameter. The reason for this is that upon port
opening the mixture in the intake pipe must be accelerated to initiate
flow. A longer pipe has a greater mass of mixture to be accelerated,
and so will require more energy to do so. This results in a stronger
initial pressure drop in the chamber which is what initiates the
pressure wave in the first place. In the case where the pressure wave
is initiated by the pressure increase after intake valve closing, the
same thing applies. The greater mass of mixture results in a higher
pressure which of course initiates a stronger pressure wave. Mazda, in
their SAE paper concerning the "Dynamic Chamber" completely ignores the
effect of the initial low pressure wave initiated at intake port
opening. Using long pipes for the purpose of harnessing high amplitude
pressure waves will most certainly have the effect of lessening the
power at some speeds, and increasing it at others.
The other method (the one I designed around) is the "Dynamic Chamber"
effect as described in Kenichi Yamamoto's book. I reprinted the charts
showing how this worked at the end of my conversion manual.The full
explanation of this effect would require a much longer message than this
but
if you study and understand what is going on here, you will see that it
depends on the fortuitous timing between the two rotors in the 13B.
(note
that this will NOT work on a three rotor 20B due to the different timing
relationships between rotors).One really nice thing about it is that it
is a broad band effect. It works at ALL engine speeds and has none of the
"dead spots" of the tuned pipe.
The "Dynamic Chamber" effect also relies on pressure waves traveling at
the speed of sound. For this reason it will be "in tune" at some speeds
and "out of tune" at others just like the pressure waves in an
independent runner manifold. The purpose is to have the pressure waves
arrive at the intake port at the proper time. Since the speed of sound
does not increase with engine speed, this can only happen over a very
narrow rpm range. If you look at SAE paper 831010 you can see that the
engine actually had better volumetric efficiency at 3000 rpm with a
separator in the plenum which kept each rotors pressure waves separate
from each other.
snip......... More stuff from Tracy.
In last months tech. article I went into a fair amount of detail on
pressure wave tuning. As it is written, it is meant to be applied to
the exhaust system, but pressure wave theory applies to intake and
exhaust in the same manner. You can find the article at
http://personal.riverusers.com/~yawpower/jantech.html
Good explanation of tuning effects Paul.
Thanks.
BTW what is the title of SAE paper 831010?
The proof of the various theories will be discovered in the long
run with actual performance of airplanes.
I might point out we don't give a fig about how broad the torque
curve is. The chart below is from Theory of Flight the classic
book by Von Mises. Pre is power required and Pav is power avialable.
Pav is mostly a function of the propellor. A variable pitch prop
or constant RPM prop (constant max HP) would convert the Pav to
almost a horzontal line. This chart is for a fixed pitch prop.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/http://www.linux.org
===============================================================================
LAST 8 years later :)
==============================================================================
------- Original Message --------
Subject: 13B intake
Date: Tue, 19 Jun 2007 10:39:51 -0700
From: Rotary Engine <
rotaryeng@earthlink.net
To: AARotary Engine <
rotaryeng@earthlink.net
Paul,
Okay, I can't stand it! I have a beautiful airplane almost ready to fly
and I don't want to skimp on the power plant. I ordered what I think I
need to build the runners and dynamic chamber, but now I'm not sure it
will all fit under the cowl. How important are size and shape of the
chamber? and I am shooting for 28inches on the runners right? How about
the significance of where I install the injectors?
Sorry I'm a pest!
Steve Denny
No problem Steve. I'll work with you until you have something you like.
Thats is why I am here.
Forget the dynamic chamber. The runners would have to be only 12 inches
long
as that is probably very difficult to convert to actual hard ware.
The Mazda versions are designed for torque at 3000 RPM which is useless
in an aircraft. Use some 2 inch OD tubes on the outer ports
and 1-3/4 OD or 1-7/8 OD on the two center housing ports. Make
them about 28 inches long but design it so you can change the length
a few inches one way or the other. Put a plenum on the end.
If you use a 4 inch round tube plenum and weld the runners in you get
a fair transition so you may not need trumpet mouths on the
ends of tubes where they enter the plenum. Your throttle body
looks fine. Cold ram air is very important. However if you
have a dusty runway you will need a filter some place.
The injectors can go anywhere. There has been reported a slight
BSFC advantage if the injectors are mounted out near the plenum.
Others say no.... mount them close to the engine.
This Ford Escort manifold is the right idea but the runners
are too small.
Put a power bulge on the cowl if necessary :)
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul,
Oops! Sorry I fat fingered the keys and sent that last one by mistake.
Thanks for the info. It sounds easy enough. I plan to use thin wall 4130
so I can weld it. I'm not sure what to use or where to look for the 4".
Should the pressure taps and temp sensor for the controller be mounted
in the plenum then?
Steve
Yes on mounting the pressure tap and temp sensor on the plenum.
BTW you might want to run it the way it is. I am sure you will
get at least 150 HP. Later on after you fly it you can make
some improvements in engine HP.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.
I still think the trombone inlet is the slickest thing for airplanes
that lack constant speed props. Control the position of the slide
with an electric motor. Run it long for takeoff and climb and shorten
it for peak airspeed for a given fuel flow once in cruise..
Regards,
Matt-
Paul
Is there clear information on dynamic chamber effects in 2 rotor engines?
I would like to understand the Renesis Variable Intake Valve including
detail such as its position relative to the ports.
Thanks
Steve Izett
Perth Western Australia
The main Mazda focus for the rotary engine over the years as
been low speed torque. In other words higher torque in the
2000 to 3000 RPM range for car use.
HP accelerates a car but the driver must be willing to shift
down to get the RPM up where the HP is. When you increase the
torque at low RPM you also increase the HP at low RPM so the
driver does not feel the need to shift quite so much.
Mazda basically buys transmissions from others so they are
forced to use transmissions designed for piston engines. The
250 HP 2.6L Mazda rotary engine is a small displacement engine
for the power generated. Most piston engines that generate
250 HP are 3.5 L.
These larger displacement piston engines have higher torque at low RPM.
Torque is proportional to engine displacement so you can see the
problem. It could be solved with better transmissions more like
a rapid shifting (1 ms) seven speed Formula 1 transmission.
Mazda is not in the business of making transmissions so they looked
elsewhere for a solution.
OK that is the back ground on where the Mazda engineers were
coming from. What did they do? Organ pipe tuning was and is the
answer. They can do what Chrysler did back in the 1960's and use
real long 4 foot intake pipes designed for 2000 to 3000 RPM. See
the attached jpgs. Some bright engineer said hey. "We have two
single rotor engines running 180 degrees out of phase. Lets
bounce the intake pulses back and fourth and make the runner
look twice as long as it really is." Instead of being four foot
long the runners could be only 2 feet long and work like four foot
runners at 3000 RPM instead of 6000 RPM.
Notice they never used this on the 3 rotor.
The pressure pulses on the 3 rotor are NOT 180 degrees out of
phase so it won't work on the 3 rotor. It worked on the 2 rotor
however. They called it the dynamic chamber. They introduced it
around 1985 on the first fuel injected RX7.
Here is the first SAE paper Mazda wrote on the subject as far as
I know.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/1984-recent-tech.pdf
Unfortunately the paper was translated from Japanese and the
real concept did not come across clearly and some people thought
it was supposed to increase the power at 6000 RPM. It did not. Tracy
Crook himself, a very influential person in the rotary A/C engine
community, adopted it after he gave up on short runner triple motor
cycle carb system. Some others adopted it and some, even recently,
inexplicably :)
Later Tracy correctly realized his mistake and did away with
it when he had his first RX8 engine built.
Mazda went on from there adding stages to cover a broader range
of RPMs and the RX8 engine is the ultimate example. The RX8
system is described in this SAE paper.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/New-rotary-eng.pdf Of course a computer
is essential to know when to switch stages from one to the next.
Unfortunately the multiple dynamic chamber intake system is very
bulky and doubled the height of the stock RX8 engine making
it unsuitable for our purposes. Currently the bare engine fits
under most cowls no problem.
Note also that the Mazda Lemans engine did not use a dynamic
chamber. Mazda could care less what the Lemans engine torque was
below 6000 RPM as they had racing transmissions to keep the
engine revs up in the rotary power band of 6000 to 10,000 RPM.
Here is the paper on the Lemans engine.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/Mazda_R26B_US.pdf
Our use of the Mazda rotary engine is much more like the Lemans
engine use than it is like street car use. In other words
2 foot intake runners work fine and they are easy to make.
We don't need no stinking dynamic chambers :)
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.