Subject: 4 vs. 2 rotor all up weight
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/17/2009, 3:39 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Paul (anyone else) can you comment on the firewall forward all up weight of
 a 2 and 4 rotor engine.

 The 2 rotor would be P Port - 300 Hp and use the 110 lbs mostly all aluminum
 core that has been referred to by others.

 The 4 rotor is P Port - 600 Hp and assuming the core would be about 200 lbs.

 The all up weight should include the engine mount, all fluids rad etc. I am
 estimating 30 lbs and 50 lbs respectively for a belt drive reduction for the
 2 and 4. The prop is 16 ft in diameter.

 For the 2 rotor add to that about 50 to 70 lbs for 2 decent sized turbo
 chargers, plumbing and intercooler for very high altitude.

 For the 4 rotor twin turbos add 100 lbs as above.

 My own estimate is the FF 2 rotor 300 hp P Port at 400 lbs plus twin turbo
 system bringing it to 450 to 470 lbs.

 The estimate for the 4 rotor is 500 lbs plus turbo assembly bringing it to
 600 lbs.

 High, low?

 Cheers,

 Brian Feeney

 The firewall forward depends on a lot of things. An all aluminum
 engine 2 rotor can weigh as little as 110 pounds. There is a picture
 of one held aloft by Doug Fir on the front page of our web site.
 http://www.rotaryeng.net

 Tracy's gear box is 45 pounds limited to 300 HP (350?) and the prop can be
 as much as 50 pounds. It is hard to estimate the firewall forward for weight
 from those numbers. BTW a TO4 turbo weighs 16 pounds. I have one
 right here. Somewhat lighter than the 22 pound Mazda turbo with
 built in waste gate. Why dual turbo's? 300 HP is no problem at
 all with one turbo. Lots of 400 HP one turbo 13B engines out there.

 I will say there are a lot of non turbo 320 pound firewall forward
 packages out there with wood props. So take off about 80 or 90 pounds for
 the all aluminum version. In other words about 250 pounds. You could
 also save another 10 pounds or so by going with an inconel exhaust system.

 The four rotor I don't have the foggiest unless you can find a Bell
 47 final drive to use as a gear box. In that case the gear box weight
 is about the same as Tracy's but it will work up to 1000 HP at 6000 RPM
 according to some Bell engineers. Doug has one but he has not run it
 yet.


 Paul Lamar



Dear Paul:

I am confused.
You wrote above, "An all aluminum engine 2 rotor can weigh as little as 110 pounds."
Yet the caption of the photo from the AREN website (attached) reads:
"Doug Fir holding 109 pound all aluminum Mazda 13B.
Racing Beat aluminum end housings."

These three statements seem to contradict each other.  Apparently.
Does these statements mean that just the end housings are made of aluminum?

Does they mean that just the block of the engine is aluminum and thus
weighs 109 pounds?  In other words, does the weight of object held by
Doug Fir not have the two iron rotors inside, and therefore weighs 109 pounds?

Light weight in Wankel rotary engines interests me intensely, so
any clarity you can give I would appreciate greatly.

Sincerely,

Les Nordman :-)


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.