Subject: Air France Airbus
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/3/2009, 6:38 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


They are reporting today the plane was intact when it hit the water.
Perhaps intact means everything except the tail, haven't found a
clarification on that.

Perry Mick

30 miles is a long way for a vertical fin, lacking a sail, to
move away from the main debris field. That is about three minutes flying
time for the average airliner going 600 MPH. Airplanes have flown
some distance without vertical fins. I also think the crash took place
in an area of the ocean called the doldroms where there are few surface winds.
The crash was only about 5 degrees south of the equator. This picture
supports the lack of surface wind theory. There is no spray.

Excepting thunder storms of course.  Any ocean current would also
move the main debris field as well.

Assuming the fin fell off in the air it would only take about
3 minutes or so to hit the water from 30,000 feet assuming it
fell at a modest 150 feet per second. Not enough time to blow
very far away due to winds aloft.

I don't think Air Bus could or would admit it broke apart in the air.
That would be the end of a lot airlines that use mostly
Air Bus products. It would also be very damaging to Air Bus
themselves needless to say.

I wonder what independent organization would
spend the huge amount of money necessary to recover the black
boxes for an unbiased report on what really happened.
I don't see the NTSB doing it.

Air Bus obviously believes the black boxes will never be found.

If I were in charge of the NTSB I would take a close look
at the design criteria of the Air Bus vertical fin compared to the
design criteria for the Boeing vertical fin. If Air Bus does not
cooperate in providing that info then that fact should be made public.

I would also inspect all Air Bus vertical fins for de lamination
signs and conduct water submersion with subsequent freezing
cycles.

In the mean time I would also think twice about flying on an Air Buss
product :) I don't envy the pilots that are forced to fly them.

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.