Subject: Air France Airbus
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/4/2009, 6:04 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

They are reporting today the plane was intact when it hit the water.
Perhaps intact means everything except the tail, haven't found a
clarification on that.

Perry Mick

30 miles is a long way for a vertical fin, lacking a sail, to
move away from the main debris field. That is about three minutes flying
time for the average airliner going 600 MPH. Airplanes have flown
some distance without vertical fins. I also think the crash took place
in an area of the ocean called the doldrums where there are few surface winds.
The crash was only about 5 degrees south of the equator. This picture
supports the lack of surface wind theory. There is no spray.

Excepting thunder storms of course.  Any ocean current would also
move the main debris field as well.

Assuming the fin fell off in the air it would only take about
3 minutes or so to hit the water from 30,000 feet assuming it
fell at a modest 150 feet per second. Not enough time to blow
very far away due to winds aloft.

I don't think Air Bus could or would admit it broke apart in the air.
That would be the end of a lot airlines that use mostly
Air Bus products. It would also be very damaging to Air Bus
themselves needless to say.

I wonder what independent organization would
spend the huge amount of money necessary to recover the black
boxes for an unbiased report on what really happened.
I don't see the NTSB doing it.

Air Bus obviously believes the black boxes will never be found.

If I were in charge of the NTSB I would take a close look
at the design criteria of the Air Bus vertical fin compared to the
design criteria for the Boeing vertical fin. If Air Bus does not
cooperate in providing that info then that fact should be made public.

I would also inspect all Air Bus vertical fins for de lamination
signs and conduct water submersion with subsequent freezing
cycles.

In the mean time I would also think twice about flying on an Air Buss
product :) I don't envy the pilots that are forced to fly them.

Paul Lamar



Apologies in advance for some of my frank statements, but some of this touches a nerve...

Speaking as one of said pilots, I think you are spot on. We deserve pity,in fact most
airline pilots seem to think they do! ;)

Just my two cents in the Boeing vs. airbus debate. I have experience on both schools
of thought (737NG vs A320 series). Firstly, the battle goes to the Boeing, hands down.
Any one who says different is either a hypocrite or they do not know anything about flying.
There are less buttons to push on a day out in the ībus and it has a few nice features.
That is what is to be said for it. Everything else the Boeing does betterand safer.

The airbus is marketed as an aircraft that is so advanced that it is supposed to be very
simple to operate and therefore lessen training requirements. This is a grave
misunderstanding perpetuated by the airbus marketing department. The factof the matter is
that the system is so complex, that it has contaminated itself.

On a Boeing, if one pushes a button, one can be quite sure what the consequences will be.
On an airbus there is so much what I call cross-contamination in the FMS/FGS, so knowing all
the consequences of one push of a button takes a long time and only comeswith experience.
Very very Poor design if you ask me. The controls are not for one second intuitive.
It is an engineers airplane, and as such it will not cooperate if things do not go exactly
according to plan. Which of course they rarely do in aviation.

One very important thing when it comes to airliner flight management systems is called
mode reversions. When a selected auto pilot or flight director mode no longer is valid
the system reverts to another one. These reversions should be designed sothat to the greatest
possible extent they are safe and will not require immediate crew intervention. Not so on the ībus.
In certain scenarios it does the strangest things and if one wants to avoid that big round blue and
green thing one has to react. Poor design.

The Boeing NG is far from perfect (mainly due to some nay sayers at Southwest), but you get
what you pay for when you fly it.

The ībus is all the fine print that none can be bothered to read.
It should never have been certified under the current circumstances. A redesign of the aircraft and
its systems, or at least of the training syllabus is what is needed. To me it is evident that many
pilots can not handle the aircraft when things start to go wrong, becauseit is supposedly so "easy"
to fly when it works. Well, first of all, its not. Its just different, conventional aircraft are just
as easy plus one gets to trim them to ones own personal liking. What it does though, is turn into a
bitch once in a full moon. This is when some computers fail, and one endsup with direct law. Now the
airplane is totally conventional, even with manual trim flown by a pilot who hasnīt flown a proper
aircraft since IR training. In my mind it would be far better if the system was constantly in
direct law when the autopilot is off, and presto, one dangerous reversiongone! Plus one gets
better pilots thrown in for free.

That is just the ergonomics of it all. Dont get me started on the structural bit. I know of a 737NG
that was close to 100 knots into the barber pole (above Vmo), due to poorpiloting during an end of lease
test flight where procedures require all hydraulics to be shut down. An out of trim situation placed
the aircraft in a dive.
No structural problems were encountered to my knowledge. I for one would not have liked to parallel
that maneuver in a 320.

JMHO

Chris


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.