I made a math error. That happens when I get angry :)
Here is the corrected article. Not quite so bad
as I thought. Still disgusting. I found the problem when
I programmed the situation for all
speeds from 50 MPH to 210 MPH. Table attached.
Acceleration everywhere would be improved.
The same lap times could be had with a smaller engine
or less RPM in the short term. Total fuel burn
would be down so the cars would not have to carry
as much fuel to complete the race next year with
no fuel stops. The cars would be lighter. Transmissions
would last longer.
This is an easy change. Can be done short term.
BTW this HP reduction comes right out of the energy
in the wing tip vortexes making the car in front easier
to pass.
-------------------------------------
Max width of the F1 race car is 71 inches.
Max F1 rear wing span or width is now about 29.5 inches
I think.
If the wing is 30 inches cord (front to back) the wing area is 885
square inches or about 6 square foot. The exact number
is not important for this analysis.
Dynamic pressure at 200 mph is 104 pounds per square foot.
For a wing with a slotted flap the lift coefficient
is around 1.5. It could be as high as 2.0. The exact number
is not important for this analysis.
Assuming the lift coefficient is indeed
1.5 that means the current wing is generating
958 pounds of down force at 200 MPH.
The drag from this wing is primarily induced drag
due to down force. All other drag factors like skin
friction drag pale into insignificance.
The formula for the drag coefficient is the lift coefficient
squared divided by pi times the aspect ratio. See the page
scan from Von Doenhoff Theory of Wing Sections.
The lift coef. squared is 1.5 times 1.5 or 2.25.
The aspect ratio of any rectangular wing is the span
divided by the cord or in the case of the current wing
it is about one.
Therefore the drag coef. is 2.25/3.14 or about .716.
Drag = Cd X wing area X dynamic pressure.
Dynamic pressure at 200 MPH is 104 pounds per square foot.
So the drag of the current wing at 200 MPH is 447 pounds.
200 MPH is 290 feet per second. HP consumed by
the rear wing alone is 129,567 pound feet per second.
One HP is 550 pound feet per second.
266,800/550 is 236 HP. Approximately 1/4th the total
HP from the Formula 1 engine.
And yes the end plates reduce this number but not by much.
Putting it in terms of GPH of fuel consumed by the wing
alone at 200 MPH it would be 141 pounds of fuel or 43 gallons
per hour. Obviously a Formula 1 car does not average
200 MPH so the fuel consumed by the wing is not
that high. They do average somewhere between 120 MPH
and 150 MPH depending on the race track.
Lets rearrange the wing shape so the span is the same as the
car width and see what happens. Same 885 square inches
divided by 72 inches means the cord would be
12.3 inches for the same wing area and the
same 958 pounds of down force at 200 MPH.
The coefficient of lift is the same 1.5.
The aspect ratio is now 72/12.3 or 5.85 instead of only 1.
A huge difference.
Therefore the new drag coef. is 2.25/3.14 X 5.85 or about .122
So the drag of the new wing at 200 MPH in pounds
is .122 X 104 X 6 or 76 pounds. (Drag = Cd X Area X dyn. press.)
HP is 76 X 290 feet per second or 22,040 pound feet per
second or 40 HP!!!!!!!! not counting other very low
drag factors such as skin friction and form drag. Still
these factors are down in the noise compared to induced drag due
to down force. Remember one HP is 550 pound feet per second.
Yes ONLY FORTY HP!!!!!!!!! for the new wing.
Fuel consumed by the new rear wing at 200 MPH assuming the BSFC
is .6 pounds per HP, per hour is 24 pounds per hour or
only 3.84 gallons per hour.
If some of this is not clear google is your best teacher.
I was well aware of these factors back in the late 1960's
when I was working for Chaparral.
This is down right shameful when the world is trying to conserve
oil resource. If I were the CEO of a car company I would cut off funding
to Formula 1 racing immediately if not yesterday.
William, you have my permission to publish this or something
like it.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.