I have decided to do away with the ABS and crank angle type
magnetic inductive sensors as too expensive and too big. I
would have trouble clearing the water pumps. Klaus has been
using hall effect sensors for years so I am going to copy him.
They are cheap at less than 2 bucks each and we need ten. It
will only require one small rotating magnet to trigger the ten
sensors. The sensors can be placed much closer together so the
diameter of the trigger system can be reduced and fit below the
water pump.
Klaus's system fits on the prop shaft so it must be much larger
than necessary compared to our e-shaft pulley.
Here are some graphics on the ABS sensor type and the hall data
sheets.
I have lots of experience using optical sensors. They work
well and are cheap and easy to use but they are way too prone
to dust and grea
----------------------------------------------------------
This is the one I am going to try. I ordered a couple from
Digikey. The price went up to $6 each but that beats $16 each
for ABS sensor since we need ten. If it works and I buy more
than the price will go down. We don't have a lot of choice in
the matter as the trigger mechanism will be limited in diameter
due to the proximity of the water pump. These things are tiny
so the circuit board will be small and light weight.
If anybody has any experience using hall effects sensors I
would like to hear about it. Klaus has been using them for
quite awhile so I will also talk to him when I get a chance.
I am worried about the end play on the e-shaft but the Lycoming
engine also has end play. I'll check all that out on the bench.
Paul Lamar
Paul, I have looked over the data sheet and app notes for the sensor
you have chosen. You picked an excellent candidate, in that it is a
digital output type sensor, so the sine wave graph that was
posted is not applicable to this type of device.
I believe that temperature will be more of an issue with
stability and repetability than end play. Particularly
if you go with a high flux magnet rare earth magnet for
the trigger. The same company that you suggested for pole
pieces has some good candidates.
http://www.kjmagnetics.com/proddetail.aspprod=D11
C. Smith
I wonder if the 'cleaned up' signal is all that accurate with varying
end play. If all they do is run the signal through a comparator, the
output will look good, but the accuracy may not be all that good
depending on RPM and end play..
Matt-
They do more than that.
An amp and a schmidt trigger probably.
We will find out on the bench.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
I worked on an optically based ignition system in the early 80s.
It worked great for a while, but the sensors would pick up a
coating of oil and oil seal dust. This ignition was on a Kawasaki
900/1000. There was no visible oil leaking past the crankshaft
seal, but we still had to clean the sensor about every 20 hours
with ethanol. We built aversion of the system for Harley KR750
flat trackers and found out about all kinds of vibration induced
failures. I think that the "dirt" problem was why Kawasaki went
to hall effect sensors. They had two types of sensor as well,
one had a magnetic rotor and the coil was by itself. The other
version was interesting and had a small magnet incorporated into
the sensor. That unit only needed a reluctor to operate since the
field was generated by the reluctor cutting the magnetic field
of the small magnet that was packaged with the sensor. That unit
had a radial gap of about .020 inches. The axial length of the
reluctor was about 10mm but it didn't need to be that long it was
just easier to make that way. No problem with end play.
Bill Jepson
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.