Subject: New front cover with motor mounts.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/16/2009, 10:37 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

 Phillip Groelz is building a cast aluminum front cover incorporating
 Lycoming motor mounts much like the Mistral version.

 Add some bosses on there Phillipe to mount my ignition
 and fuel injection crank angle sensors :)

 I talked to Steve Roth who was piloting when the
 Mistral Piper Arrow crashed and he said the front cover did not
 break but
 the motor mount was bent. Always good sign. Means the front cover
 can take
 it.

 Here are some pictures of the wood patterns and the Mistral version
 for
 comparison. I like the idea that Phillip is using the stock Mazda
 water
 pump
 cartridge.

 Paul Lamar
 ------------------------------------
 Paul, and Phillip!
 Sign me up for a couple (or 3) of those castings! Try and make sure
 they
 fit
 all versions of the 13B and 20B's, the 20B larger water pump, have
 acc pads
 (cs prop pulley driven pump), etc! (I have mostly 13B REW and 20B
 engines-the AT engines have a different bolt/starter layout, as
 does all
 the
 20B's as they were ALL AT only). In any case.
 I suspect that this mount is the typical "dynafocal" Lycoming style
 used on
 the Lyc O and IO360's like in some of the Piper Arrows If so, I
 have this
 MM hanging from my hangar ceiling. I was waiting for this to
 happen.....and
 didn't want to deal with Mistral......
 Any idea on a price and when

 Marc Wiese

 Sign me up as well. I'm at least a year behind with doing the same
 thing.
 Had thought of purchasing a complete Mistral engine just for the
 chance
 to measure and CNC that front plate. If it's engineered to handle the
 loads of up to and including a 4 rotor you should have no problems
 getting customers. Price and timeline would be great.
 Greg Fleming
 London, Ontario, Canada


 Sign me up too if you're taking orders! :-)I have a 20B and would
 really like to use this type of mount with my Velocity SE-RG. Any
 idea of the weight yet Will the longer tension bolts of the 20B
 handle the additional weight thats cantilevered out This would be
 a nice piece of work to use with our engines!
 Best wishes,

 John Bell

 Paul, I have been using RX7 and RX8 side housings to measure bolt
 locations
 and water and oil passage interfaces. It looks to me that the
 tension bolts
 thread into the front side housing and do not pass through it to
 the front
 accessory case casting.It looks like the patterns shown will gain some
 support from the oil pan attach bolts and water pump studs, however
 these are
 small fasteners and while the oil pan itself appears plenty stiff,
 the bolt
 hole clearance would limit support to the friction component of the
 pan and
 gasket to the front cover. I would suggest looking at some through
 bolt
 bosses that would allow attachment of 1/4" plate brackets back to
 the core
 engine castings. The mounting front cover mounting idea should advance
 rotary use as Lycoming mounts are available for most anything, and
 the motor
 mount worries builders more than the induction system which you
 have already
 taken the pain out of. How does the center of gravity of the
 rotary/redrive/prop compare with the Lycoming engine an prop
 assuming the
 cooling system is under the engine
 george grimes

 The center of gravity will be well forward of the Lycoming. I was
 concerned
 with the same thing and that is why I checked with Steve Roth of
 Mistral.

 If it survives a crash it is probably strong enough.

 The two hollow dowel pins would help locate the motor-mount/front-
 cover.

 The oil pan flange will help out as you mentioned.

 Seems to me is the most highly stressed part of the new front cover
 is the
 upper right corner with few six mm bolts in that location. Mistral has
 added at least one new 6 mm screw in that area. High strength bolts
 are used.

 Paul Lamar

 Paul,
 It appears that Mistral has committed to a front motor mount for a bed
 style mount on the 3 rotor.
 You may have seen newer layouts so I'm asking here. All the 3 rotor
 displays
 used a mount attached to the bell housing. The mounting pad for that
 was almost in the same place as the Shirtz mount designs on the 13B
 mounts you have been doing. It doesn't appear that Mistral wants to
 mount the 3 rotor off the front/rear plate. It seemed smarter to do
 a P51 style mount for the 20B. Your thoughts
 Bill Jepson

 Here are some pictures I took at Aero in April 2009. Still the
 Lycoming
 cantilever mount.

 I am biased as I came up with the mount under the engine/GB/Prop
 combo CG :)
 for the rotary. Well not me. Jim Griswald used it on the Questair
 Venture.
 The Lycoming mount for a 3 rotor is a risk.

 Paul Lamar


 The picture showing what you guys are calling a Lycoming motor mount
is not really how the mount was or is intended to be.(or actually is-
if you were to buy the standard conical ring)
Other than being the 30 degree angle shape built into the motor. I
mean, really look at the massive tube size of the Conical Mount that
you would buy that handles the ISO blocks with the 3/8's bolts
running through them to the single 3/8's hole in the motor case. Then
using a 10 tube stand off tube system (5 each side- 2 top, 2 bottom 1
from top fire wall to bottom conical) Just  completely different than
what is shown for strength.

I would really like to see a cosmos (solid works stress test) on the
motor mount shown in the photo. A lot of the bracing shown in the
photos is being used to hold the bushings in place rather than motor
twist/tork.
And perhaps a optical allusion, but it appears to be a acorn nut on
the bottom fire wall bolt? Hope not.
Just my $0.02 worth.

It can be made stronger at the same weight, but would guess not with
the bushings set aft of the ISO blocks.
Scott, Iron Design L.L.C.


Scott Weinberg

http://www.irondesign-airparts.com/Tailwheels.htm


We are not talking about the steel tube part Scott. Don't pay any attention
to that in those pictures.

We are talking about the aluminum mounting ears on the engine
itself.  The issue is... will the engine bolt on a stock off the
shelf Vans RVx steel tubing mount that came with the kit?


Paul Lamar

Paul, I looked up recent webpages  showing the mistral engine disassembled
(some on their website also) which is different from the display engine seen
at airshoes. They now show the 30 degree mounting tabs cast into a new cast
iron side housing which  appears to be  a modification of the Mazda RX7
part. I talked to their sales rep at Sun-n-fun  in 2007 and he mentioned
that  new patterns were being finished up to make parts for a production
model of the engine and that the redrive displayed was for the production
model.

The new front side housing with the dynafocal ears has what appears
to be a mounting boss for the Mazda oil pump with the integral oil suction
and pressure passages but without the feed circuit to the injection pump. I
also recently saw pictures of a mistral with all the front accessorys direct
mounted to the front face of the accessory housing on a development version
af a four rotor.The extra side housing did not appear to be cosmo on the
four rotor.

Also the cast iron side housing in addition to  all the stock
tie rod bolts  being threaded into it, there are what looks like 20 MM
external tie rods running just above the oilpan rails to the rear housing
and redrive. Thats at least 19 significant sized bolts tied into the cast
iron  front side housing/motor mount . My rational is that I am not hanging
500 pounds of drive train parts off of blue styrofoam but am hanging blue
styrofoam on the engine, and that mstral design seems almost overkill.

Mounting off the accessory case would require the same annalysis of  moment
arm and load vectors we already use to design the motor mount tubing
structure to find the tension loads on the bolts/studs and the pull out
strenght of the fasteners in cast aluminum.Through bolting where possible
and/or some fabricated brackets off the  back side of the accessory case to
existing OEM mounting points on the core engine seem like a good investment
in fwf weight.Also noteworthy is that this mounting is all behind the engine
moving the cg of the engine back slightly.

George-Grimes

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.