Subject: 2-stroke suitability for turbo compound
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/3/2009, 1:07 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


  Hi Paul,

  I read your article in the August edition of Kitplanes with great interest
  and share your frustration that there is not more innovation in aviation
  power-plant development worldwide. Obviously the price of avgas/oil is not
  enough to overcome the barrier that engine certification provides to
  suppress innovation.

  One of the things I read that resonated with me was what you said in your
  article about poppet valves acting to slow down the exhaust gas flow with a
  corresponding reduction in the kinetic energy available for use in turbo
  compounding/turbocharging etc. hence the advantage of a rotary with exhaust
  ports instead of poppet valves. It occurs to me that a 2 stroke diesel would
  have a similar advantage over a 4 stroke [with poppet valves] as a rotary in
  that the exhaust gas kinetic energy available for turbo-compounding would be
  greater because of the velocity of the gas would not be constricted by the
  poppet valves.

  I love the idea of a 2 stroke diesel for aviation, I think there is so much
  to like about it and wish someone could get it up and running as a
  commercial venture. Challenging yes, but surely with some engineering nous
  you could develop a compelling package. Super efficient, compact, light
  weight, reduced number of moving parts and throw turbo compounding in to the
  mix, wow, what a package.

  Around the same time as I read your article the Hirth UAV 2-stroke engine
  which uses Orbital's air-assisted direct injection system which not only
  gives great flexibility in terms of fuel type [if you want] but all the
  advantages of 2-stroke engines without the high fuel usage and the need for
  supercharging/scavenge. My assumption is that one of these engines with a
  turbocharger coupled to the final drive would offer similar advantages as
  you discuss in your article as a rotary with the high velocity exhaust
  gases.

  I actually contacted Hirth/Orbital about their plans for certification of
  their multi fuel 2-stroke. Unfortunately their partner Continental the auto
  component manufacturer [not the aircraft engine company] with whom they
  developed the fuel injection system is not interested in the high insurance
  costs associated with product liability if they were to certify their
  engines for manned flight.

  What a pity, it seems like yet again a great opportunity lost to provide
  something new and improved in the aircraft power scene. I would love to get
  involved in a project like this to produce an engine like this.

  Where do I start, do you have any ideas????

  Regards

  Glenn

  Glenn Henry

  The Napier Nomad was a two stroke diesel with sleeve valves.
  One of the most efficient turbo compound engines ever built.
  Unfortunately the 18:1 or 20:1 compression ratios required
  by diesels adds a lot of weight and has been the downfall
  of more than one diesel aircraft engine.

  Paul Lamar

Check DeltaHawk engines. They are developping a two stroke diesel
for aviation use. Although it has been around for years, they
claim to be now very close to production. I visited them at
Oshkosh last week.
Philippe CHENEVIER


Diesel aircraft engines have been around since 1930. Ever wonder
why they never caught on? :) The most successful was the Junkers
Jumo and it lasted about five years.

Before Delta Hawk there was the Zoche. Zoche was at OSH for years
starting about 15 years ago until they became a joke. Each year
Zoche production was going to be next year. Finally they got so
much abuse from the potential customers they stopped showing up at
OSH. Zoche is still alive and they were at  Aero in Friedrichshaven.
The booth money is obviously coming from an eccentric millionaire dilettante.
I suspect the same situation applies to the Delta Hawk. IMHO it will never fly.

Paul Lamar



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.