Subject: New front cover with motor mounts - One step backwards.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/12/2009, 11:01 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


  Phillip Groelz is building a cast aluminum front cover incorporating
  Lycoming motor mounts much like the Mistral version.

  Add some bosses on there Phillipe to mount my ignition
  and fuel injection crank angle sensors :)

  I talked to Steve Roth who was piloting when the
  Mistral Piper Arrow crashed and he said the front cover did not break
but
  the motor mount was bent. Always good sign. Means the front cover can
take
  it.

  Here are some pictures of the wood patterns and the Mistral version for
  comparison. I like the idea that Phillip is using the stock Mazda water
  pump
  cartridge.

  Paul Lamar
  ------------------------------------
  Paul, and Phillip!
  Sign me up for a couple (or 3) of those castings! Try and make sure they
  fit
  all versions of the 13B and 20B's, the 20B larger water pump, have acc
  pads
  (cs prop pulley driven pump), etc! (I have mostly 13B REW and 20B
  engines-the AT engines have a different bolt/starter layout, as does all
  the
  20B's as they were ALL AT only). In any case.
  I suspect that this mount is the typical "dynafocal" Lycoming style used
  on
  the Lyc O and IO360's like in some of the Piper Arrows If so, I have
this
  MM hanging from my hangar ceiling. I was waiting for this to
  happen.....and
  didn't want to deal with Mistral......
  Any idea on a price and when

  Marc Wiese

  Sign me up as well. I'm at least a year behind with doing the same
thing.
  Had thought of purchasing a complete Mistral engine just for the chance
  to measure and CNC that front plate. If it's engineered to handle the
  loads of up to and including a 4 rotor you should have no problems
  getting customers. Price and timeline would be great.
  Greg Fleming
  London, Ontario, Canada



  Sign me up too if you're taking orders! :-)I have a 20B and would
  really like to use this type of mount with my Velocity SE-RG. Any
  idea of the weight yet Will the longer tension bolts of the 20B
  handle the additional weight thats cantilevered out This would be
  a nice piece of work to use with our engines!
  Best wishes,

  John Bell


  Paul, I have been using RX7 and RX8 side housings to measure bolt
locations
  and water and oil passage interfaces. It looks to me that the tension
bolts
  thread into the front side housing and do not pass through it to the
front
  accessory case casting.It looks like the patterns shown will gain some
  support from the oil pan attach bolts and water pump studs, however
these
  are small fasteners and while the oil pan itself appears plenty stiff,
the
  bolt hole clearance would limit support to the friction component of the
pan
  and gasket to the front cover. I would suggest looking at some through
bolt
  bosses that would allow attachment of 1/4" plate brackets back to the
core
  engine castings. The mounting front cover mounting idea should advance
  rotary use as Lycoming mounts are available for most anything, and the
motor
  mount worries builders more than the induction system which you have
already
  taken the pain out of. How does the center of gravity of the
  rotary/redrive/prop compare with the Lycoming engine an prop assuming
the
  cooling system is under the engine? george grimes

  The center of gravity will be well forward of the Lycoming. I was
concerned
  with the same thing and that is why I checked with Steve Roth of
Mistral.

  If it survives a crash it is probably strong enough.

  The two hollow dowel pins would help locate the motor-mount/front-cover.

  The oil pan flange will help out as you mentioned.

  Seems to me is the most highly stressed part of the new front cover is
the
  upper right corner with few six mm bolts in that location. Mistral has
added
  at least one new 6 mm screw in that area. High strength bolts are used.

  Paul Lamar

  Is this cover meant to fit the larger 20B (and 13B REW) oil pump
  configurations? Those engines have uprated oil pumps.
  Marc Wiese



  Paul

  "Seems to me is the most highly stressed part of the new front cover is
  the
  upper right corner with few six mm bolts in that location. Mistral has
  added at least one new 6 mm screw in that area. High strength bolts are
  used."


  I agree. Mistral's work is well done. And yes CNC would be stronger
  and lighter. Also a point to note is their front cover is attached to
  iron. When using an aluminium front housing things might get, uhhh,
  interesting with the CG so far away. The lower mounts are in compression
  and shouldn't be a problem for the amount of metal they have. The
  upper ones concern me but not in regards to the front cover per se. If
  one could bring that load forward near the bell housing interface it
  would be a lot safer. This would keep the engine block in compression
  instead of stretching it and turning it into part of a long lever in
  which the internal dowel pins are creating localized stresses. The
  engine bolts aren't that strong and depend on sharing the loads equally
  between them.We are playing with an engine that is segmented axially
  compared to one split down the middle. The superior strength of the
  Lycoming case should be obvious. I suspect that this was one reason
  Mazda abandoned the front case mount and went to the trouble to put
  close to the engine CG. and attached to the intermediate housing. If one
  has the cowl space then their are only two words to remember with engine
  mounts.BED MOUNT. It is the superior and safe solution and how Mazda
  envisioned the engine to be mounted. One may say, "Yes but I am making
  an airplan...." Yes but you are, but you are choosing to fly with an
  engine engineered to be supported in a different manner.

  Doug in Japan

  If the CG of the 3 rotor is 2 feet ahead of the front cover
  and the total weight is 400 pounds the bending moment
  at the rubber bushings is 4,800 foot pounds at 6 G. The tensile
  load on the upper rubber bushings is therefor about 4,000 pounds or
  2000 pounds each bushing. The compression load on the lower
  bushings is the same. I am sure the rubber bushing will take
  a momentary load of 1000 pounds. The 1/2 inch bolts running
  through the rubber bushings would be no problem. Just about
  any half decent 1/2 inch bolt will take 30,000 pounds.

  The upper 10 mm (a little over 3/8th inch) tension bolts
  may be over loaded however as they already have a tensile
  stress in them due to just torquing them down. Over all
  it looks a little marginal but it might be OK.
  A metal constant speed prop is 50 pounds all by itself
  so it is probably not a good idea.

  The shear stress must be taken by the two hollow dowel
  pins that run through the housings locating them relative
  to each other. They will probably survive.

  In the stressed Lemans engine Mazda added upper and lower plates
  on the engine to take the bending loads. You can clearly see it
  in this 2nd picture and the mounting bolt holes. It appears
  to be carbon fiber honeycomb. Much like an I beam.

  Paul Lamar

  Yes!  Jack Yamaguchi wrote in "RX8":  "The multi-rotor engine is
built like the famous Dagwood sandwich, with a number of
trochoid housings and side housings bolted together.  This
built-up construction is inevitably inferior in shear stiffness
to a conventional piston engine with a single piece cylinder
block.  To overcome this shortcoming, the four-rotor unit is
reinforced by stiffener plates, carbon fiber on top, aluminum
honeycomb on the bottom."


And most significant for this thread about engine mounting,
Yamaguchi continued: "Although the reinforced engine was used as
a stress-carrying member of the chassis, its contribution should
be relatively small, reasoned (Mazda 787 chief chassis engineer
Takao) Kijima" (addition mine).  1


1. Jack K. Yamaguchi, RX-8, The Mazda RX-8: World's First
4-door, 4-seat Sports Car Plus Complete Histories of Mazda
Rotary Engine Development and Rotary Racing around the World,
ed. John Dinkel (Kanagawa, Japan:  RING, Ltd. for Mazda Motor
Corporation, 2003)  pp. 163-164.



Les Nordman :-)


John Dinkel sounds familiar :)

Paul Lamar

Status Update

I thank you guys for your words of encouragement as well as for your
thoughtful comments about details I should consider.

After Paul's visit with Perry Mick, Steve Beckham and me last month, it
was clear to me that I needed to bite the bullet and become proficient
with my TurboCad software.  I have the CAM package and I also have access
to a CNC router. I've been putting off the learning process because of the
frustration of having to relearn all the CAD commands.  I know that I have
to learn the system at some point because of all the projects I have in
mind.  And after our visit, I realized that making the patterns would
probably be farther along if I had made the effort in the beginning.

It will have pads for attaching a printed circuit board for the Hall
effect transistors.  I was planning to use that system for timing my fuel
injection and ignition as well.  I see that Guru Racing has aluminum
pulleys available for the e-shaft and I am thinking about embedding the
magnet in the face of the pulley.

Regarding questions of dates and pricing I cannot predict.  My estimates
about how much time I need are always low anyhow.  I did take a course in
CNC programming last spring, so that should help keep the costs
reasonable.

Particularly after considering your comments, the first mount will only be
for the 13b.  Also, I looked at an RV-10 and the cushions for the Lycoming
540 attach to the mount structure while on the four cylinder engines they
attach to engine case.

Philip Groelz



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.