I went through the calculation for the front shaft using an online java
calculator here:
http://www.tech.plym.ac.uk/sme/desnotes/shaftMandT.htm
The attached screen shot shows the result of the calculator and would
indicate that the front shaft is indeed capable of taking the full torque
pulse of a 2 rotor, even if you add a
significant fudge factor.
If you only ask it to take ½ the load? Dual prop amphibian?
Decker, Michael
What stress level or material did you enter the program with?
Paul Lamar
UTS 800 Mpa
Decker, Michael
800 megapascal = 116 030.190 41 pounds per square inch Nobody designs a
crank shaft or e-shaft to run at 116,00 psi.
19 mm is a 3/4" diameter e-shaft. That is crazy :)
Yes it might not break if applied once but no engine designer would use that
number. 30,000 is more like it.
Paul Lamar
Even using 206.842(30000) it still works, and that is for the full max
torque
pulse, not half load max which would be 200ftlb.
Are you telling me that when they ask for UTS in these calculators
they don't really mean UTS?
Decker, Michael
Stop mixing and matching measuring systems. If you use foot pounds then
use psi instead of Kpa. I have to convert things and that takes time.
We got to the moon on inches... as my old friend Vance Jaqua RIP was fond
of saying :)
No but engineers don't always design things to ultimate tensile strength.
There are fatigue and deflection considerations.
If you want to try this be my guest. It is a free country. Just
please don't kill your self in a rotary powered air craft.
I don't want to waste any more time on this scheme. There are more
productive things for me to do.
Paul Lamar
-
Paul,
that falls under "internet engineering".
The reason I quit participating on the diesel truck hot rod site years ago.
These guys find data on the net and instantly they are engineers and can
override years of common knowledge.
good job just putting and end to this one. A single 68" pusher prop can
handle all the hp we can make, so 2 of them doesn't make sense anyway.
Larry
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.