Subject: Motor plate improvement
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/24/2009, 11:53 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


  A few minor problems for the 13B. One hole was ten thou
  off or so but it could be drilled out with no problems.
  One cup tab was a bit too long so that could be hacksawed off.
  We had a few typical bolt circle problems but easily fixed by
  drilling the holes out to 27/64th instead of 10 MM.
   Other than that the 13B was usable. The starter hole
  was a bit on the small side but I can set it up in my
  cheap Chinese mill and bore it out about .020.
  The starter hole should be 2.640.
   I was working from Tracy's dwg and I should have
  checked the dwg against Tracy motor plate which I also have.
  The drawings had a few errors and I probably made one or
  two my self. The dwg does not match Tracy's plate :)
   The RX8 extra bell house bolt was way off by about a half inch so
  that is going to require a whole new dwg which I have about done.
  I want to make the plates fit both the 13B and the RX8 motor.
   Jeff I'll get the  fixed dwg to you in a day or so.
   Paul Lamar
   Paul
  So this is usable. If  you want I can open up the starter hole
  here. It
 measures 2.620 on the solid model. I depend on the solid
   model for
 geometry for expediency. If you need to digitize the bolt
  pattern on the
 housing we can do that. We need absolute numbers. I do not
 know the
 difference between the RX7 and 8.  the half inch hole problem,
  does that
 make it unusable??? No worries, we just get it right for the
  folks that
 need them...
  jeff
  I'll ship it back if you want it. I only have one RX8 end housing
 and it is on my RX8 P-port test engine which I don't want to
  take apart.
 I think I got it measured fairly accurately.
  If you have a 13B end housing that would be a good one to
 digitize.
 The solid model is now fine. I fixed it. Jarrett has it now and
 he is converting it to a Solid Works file for you. I made a
  couple of
 other changes while I was at it. After you do it three or four
  timesyou get better and faster. The new version is much more
  accurate as
 I had been there and done that :) All ribs are now the same
  width and
 parallel. We need to drill all the 10 mm holes out to 27/64th
  as that
 will ease the bolt circle problem.
  No change in the back pattern.
  We should look into a spun or pressed bell housing and use
   the two
   hollow
 dowel pins on the end housing to locate the unit more
  accurately. Along
 with a lighter weight gear box of course :) The bolt and spacer
  idea is
 less than ideal.
  Paul Lamar
 Paul
 I think when you send me the new geometry I will make a
  template, send
   it to yo then you can check for fit. I am not in favor of
 making the
   holes larger. I can use my machine as a CMM and get the number
  exact.  I
   did that with the rotor housing and it is perfect.... We save
   these master coordinates for all future parts. This should be
   done all
  around  the block.
   I have machined bell housings before. Lots of aluminum chips but
  can be
   done fairly quick as opposed to finding and getting someone
  quote, setup, bid,etc. Lots of time and money.. My guess a
  billet block of 6061 for a bell housing would be atleast 60
   lbs..Al plate is a little over $3.00/lb.  Figure $200 for
  material.  It will machine down to about close to 8  lbs or less.
  If thehousing is not too complicated with lots of ribs, this
  could be machine in1 day. More,  obviously for the first
  article sample, but for anyproduction  at  all,  $600 to $700 is
  doable. Eventually get acast part , but this way we could get
  something out cheaper and sooner... I agree the bolt and spacer
  arrangement needs to be fixed....
 jeff
 No doubt about it that is the ultimate solution. I rejected it in
   the past because of the cost. Prices have come way down on NC
  mill stuff as a lot of people have the machines payed off.
 The problem with sand casting is weight. The foundry has
  problems with
   anything thinner than .2 inches. Also the cost of sand
   castings has
   gone way up. NC milling is now more competitive.
 Try these until Jarrett gets the SW version out.
 Paul Lamar
   Paul
   Tell Jarrett no need for file conversions anymore. I have a new
 SW2009  seat so all will work directly......
   jeff
   Great. Thanks Jeff.
  I'll bet it will load Rhino native directly :)
   Paul Lamar
   Paul, I did this over lunch so it's the quick version. I didn't
 put the cups
 on as we know they are strong enough. I just fixed one end
 where the
 cup goes [the farthest from CL] and the second one I fixed it such
 thatit was still moveable from the first yet fixed in the vertical
 plane [similar
 to how flexible an engine mount 'could' be. The trick here is
 if I
 make both
 ends fixed [ie cast in concrete] then there is some degree to
 stress that
 is carried via tension between the two fixing points. When I put
 one fixed
 and one fixed in the vertical only ?I think we get a better
 representationof the loads w/ a mount that has midle
 deflection at
 load. It looks ok still
 to me.. but I haven't spent too much time going over the
  results.  I can do  the 'real deal'  test later tonight but
  thought this might  help in  the mean time.Let me know..Jarrett
  That ia much better.
  Jeff this is the new design fixed with the RX8
 hole in the right place. I also added a rib on the highly loaded
 left side. The stress level is now very conservative which is what
 I was shooting for.
  Thanks Jarett.
  Paul Lamar
  No problem, do you want me to do one w/ the cups on it.. or are we
   good at this point?
 Jarrett  [geeze I've got to slow down when I'm typing.. and then
   proof read.. sorry about that...]
 NO cups needed. We are good. Jeff might need a solid works file.
 Paul Lamar
   Ok, Jeff, let me know if you do.  Btw those PSRU holes where put
 in on
  a 5.875" B.C.
  Two holed on the top x 12 holes [30deg OC] Each being 0.25dia.  That
  sound correct?
   Jarrett
   Jarrett
  I got the iges...... there where no holes for the psru and no
  registerin the back.  All the geom comes in as splines. That
  make it difficult
 to separate out for machining..do you have in SW a standard set
 made in
 lines and arcs. It's easier to manipulate and takes a lot less
  memory.If you don't' I will make a version here that's cleaner
  but we
 need to
 get the design absolutely established. send straight up SW from
 now on,
 no more conversions.
  jeff
  Did you try the step file? Jarrett has it in SW and he will
  send it.
  Paul Lamar
   Here's the SW file.. unfortunatly this too has splines [I've yet
  to see
  any that don't when they come over this way..]
  On this part [due to it being a basic 2D geometry for machining
  [2.5D]]one might as well just switch
  it to a dxf/dwg. The file is attached... I don't have the rear
  registerin there [didn't have time to go back
  and look up the dim's for it]. I put the PSRU B.C in but need
  Paul toconfirm the dim's [about 3 postingsabove this one]..
   Sorry not a huge help..  :/
   Jarrett
   I think the splines are when I use the "fillet curve" option.
  It ask for a radius but I think it "blends" the curves. One of
  the really neat features of Rhino. That is why it does cowling's
  and other compound curved shapes so well. It will also blend
  surfaces and loft.
   Fortunately sldprt is not a text file and does not need to be zipped.
   --------------------------------------------------------------
   Here is Tracy's dwg on the dims Jarrett.
   Paul Lamar
  Ok, my bolt circle should be correct [it matches] the registration
 hole will need to be
 added but thats minor [just a 1.504" hole x 0.310 deep. I can up that
 on and re-send
 if Jeff needs it..
  Jarrett
  Jarrett

  No need I got it..............1.504............I had 1.501........

  Paul ..got the plate in today.  do I bore the starter hole? or is the
  part not usable??

  I will make a template for fit right away,  then order more material
  when it looks good........

  jeff

  My mistakes. I should have checked Tracy's dwg with the real world :)
  You did a beautiful job making this plate.

  Bore the starter hole out to 2.645" (now 2.630 I think). I just used
  my dial calibers to measure two different starters :) That should
  give .010 clearnace on the diameter. Tracy called out 2.675" but I
  think that was for a different starter.

  The mounting holes in his dwg are wrong for most of the four
  starters that I have. An over size hole won't hurt however as match
  drilling the starter mounting bolts will take care of any minor
  misalignments. The starter everybody should use is the starter with
  the solonoid at a 45 degree angle as the starter in the left of this
  picture. It has 12 teeth. The other one has 13 teeth.

  The right cup tab is too long by about .1 inch. (pilots view) Make
  it the same as the left cup tab. Easier to weld on the cups. The
  welder will have to do a bit of filing anyway to get rid of the
  radius and fit the cup.

  One 10 mm  hole is slightly off by about .030". I don't know what
  happened there. Could have been an error in the dwg. I very
  carefully converted the polar coordinates of Tracy dwg to
  rectangular coordinates.

  Consequently this hole needs to be elongated  slightly in a
  Northwest direction by about .030"  It won't have any affect on the
  plate location because of the five other bolts. The bolt will then
  screw into the end housing easier. It can be screwed in now but it is
  a bit too tight.

  Paul Lamar


  That is the fanciest motor plate I have ever seen! A little Zoop Seal on
 it to keep the finish and it will always look that good. Excellent work.

 Dale Davies

 opss that is North East and not North West.
 And I am supposed to be a pilot. Well according to the FAA anyway :)

 Paul Lamar

 Paul

You open at all to bolted on cups....saves mucho welding issues.............

jeff

That is great Jeff. I hope it does not add too much to the cost.
How long does it take to make a cup like that?

I am open to that. I guess one would have to find a welder and
pay him anyway.

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.