Question:
I know that Lancairs have been flying IFR for years, but they have
certified engines, props and instruments.
According to FAA rules, can rotary engined experimental with IFR
instruments and IFR certified CS prop be registered as IFR-certified, or
"IFR approved" ?
Or should the engine be also IFR certified to start with, like eg.
IO-360? This has some connections to PSRU project...
Please comment. Did I forgot something?
Cheers,
Petri
Question, what is an "IFR certified" powerplant or prop?
C. Smith
There is no IFR certification by the FAA of experimental aircraft. The
standard operating limitations issued by the FAA for Experimental
(Amateur Built) specify Day VFR operation "unless equipped for night VFR
and/or IFR in accordance with FAR section 91.205. The representative of
the Administrator issuing the Airworthiness Certificate and accompanying
Operating Limitations may add any other limitations they feel necessary
for safety, so it would be prudent to discuss this issue with the
persons you consider to employ for certification of your airplane.
Choose a DAR who is not antagonistic towards rotary power. Both my
IO-470 powered RV-8 and my Subaru-powered (all-electric, fuel injected)
RV-6 have the preceding language permitting IFR if equipped per Part 91.
Victor Roberts
I'm fully aware of all of this Victor, which is why I asked the question,
what is an IFR certified engine or prop.
A "aircraft" is certified for operation as IFR, an experimental gets an
airworthiness certificate with operating limitations.
Powerplants and props get certification for use on certificated aircraft,
but I'm not familiar with the "IFR" bit as it pertains
an engine or propeller, and would like to know more about this.
Thanks.
C. Smith
Hi,
My question could be set confusingly, I am not familiar with the
procedure how FAA gives permits for IFR flying for experimental
aircraft. I just know that it could and has been done.
That talk about IFR certifed prop and engine has it's origin on some
shady bits of information like "you cannot get IFR with xxx prop" and
"you need redundant systems to get a single IFR certified".
What's interesting is how auto engine conversion like rotary engine mix
with this - does 13B count as "sufficiently verified" design or should
one expect difficulties when trying to get that IFR certification.
Victor's reply implies that the result depends on the DAR's attitude.
(Designated Airworthiness Representative?)
Has anybody tried this yet?
Cheers,
Petri
There isn't any IFR certification for experimental aircraft.. If the
manufacturer (you) equips the airplane to meet FAR 91.205, and the
pilot is properly rated, IFR flight is legal.
Another point is that it's possible to have a glider meet IFR
requirements - and be flown in clouds.. They don't have engines or
props.
An experimental will cause no problems for IFR flight from a
regulatory standpoint.
Matt-
Matt, I would respectfully challenge the assertion that a glider can meet
IFR requirements. One can certainly equip it to meet FAR 91.205(d), but
there is no way you can do a missed approach, among many other reasons.
If you have an example of a certificated glider operating IFR, or an
experimental unpowered glider whose operating limitations allow operation
in
IFR (and yes, it must state in the limitations that IFR approved) then I
will stand corrected. A common misconception about the experimental
category
is that you can do anything you want unless it is prohibited, but in fact
it
is the other way around, your limitations will spell out exactly what you
can LEGALLY do.
If when making application, you do not include aerobatic flight, and your
limitations do not say aerobatic flight is permitted, then you may not
legally perform aerobatic maneuvers in that aircraft. The same is true for
IFR. The reasoning is quite simple. In issuing your airworthiness
certificate, the DAR would clearly want to know if for instance, the fuel
system was capable of supplying fuel in inverted flight, or that the
airframe has been designed and built to the necessary minimums for
aerobatic
loads. Sure, people perform aerobatics in non-aerobatic aircraft and don't
get caught, but it is illegal just the same (not to mention reckless
behavior).
The same would be true of operation in an IFR environment. Remember the
primary mission of the FAA is supposed to be safety of flight.
C. Smith
Certainly should you want to file for any kind of terminal operations
you would need to be able to meet all requirements of flying a
procedure in that environment. However I don't believe being able to
make any kind of instrument approach is a requirement of IFR
operations.. I believe it's perfectly legal to file IFR from one
point in space to another - no terminal operations - or at least to
get a clearance. I know it's legal to file departing from an airport
without any departure procedure so long as you maintain VFR until you
reach a minimum vectoring altitude and/or controlled airspace. I
believe I have actually filed for an IFR clearance while in flight -
to an intersection and then to a VOR - my instructor wanted me to fly
within a cloud for a while.
I also know that gliders sometimes operate above 18k MSL and outside a
wave window, without a waver. I'm pretty sure this requires IFR
equipment.
Regardless, the topic was whether flying IFR would require any
certification level of the powerplant.
Matt-
Look Guys,
There is no such thing as an "IFR Certified" engine, or almost anything for
that matter. (except maybe a pilot, or an aircraft's static system). Not
Radios, not transponders, not engines, not even GPS.... but
There is a TSO standard for some things, and FAR91.205 implies that if an
experimental aircraft were to be flown IFR its equipment would have to meet
the specifications of the TSO in order to be legal. So in that sense, you
could call that a IFR certification.
But TSO requirements mostly only apply to the transponders and GPS. So as
long as you have standard wording on your airworthiness cert. Then the pilot
in command is responsible for making the call for IFR flight. Since I do
not know of any transponder or GPS that would meet the TSO without being
built under a TSO (TSO certified) then at minimum your transponder should be
TSO certified and if you want to use your GPS for navigation, it must be
"IFR Certified" as well... Not only that, you must have verified that your
GPS INSTALLATION meets the TSO performance.
A certified engine is merely one that is used on a certified aircraft and
has nothing to do with IFR certification.
Many of the experimentals that fly IFR do so on non-certified engines or
engine-prop combos. A rotary is not less certified than an un-certified lyc
clone.
I got my instrument rating in my rotary powered RV-6 with a wood prop. I
fly it in IMC regularly, and legally.
Yes, you want to make sure everything as safe and redundant as possible.
You want that IFR or not.
There is nothing wrong with a wooden prop for IFR, or IMC. Like Matt
pointed out, not all IFR is in rain, or even clouds. Different IFR aircraft
are tailored to meet different jobs. Gliders fly IFR because they go high
but would not do an approach. I fly IFR to go up and down through the SoCal
Marine layer but avoid anything more serious than that. Because of my
wooden prop try to avoid rain but fly in it if necessary (it chips the paint
and I have to re-paint). IMHO, no light aircraft should be flying around in
large winter storm systems and areas of very heavy rain... i.e. the
suitability of the aircraft for the situation is up to the pilot. Aircraft
come in all shades of capability, IFR minimum equipment is just the starting
point.
Put to answer you question Petri, absolutely positively the Rotary can be an
appropriate and legal engine to use while flying IFR.
Victor is right about some DAR's or FSDO inspectors trying to step outside
their role either with good intentions or ignorance and put the kybosh on
your IFR plans. So it probably would be worth while to ask around before
you select one. Or even consider just calling an talking to him ahead of
time, tell him what you have and would he have any intentions of altering
the standard phraseology in your AW cert. (which usually should not be
done).