Subject: this may be what we are looking for
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/5/2009, 8:55 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



http://www.sae.org/mags/AEI/6906


http://www.freescale.com/webapp/sps/site/application.jsp?code=APLSMALLENGCTRL&tid=vansmallengine
http://www.freescale.com/webapp/sps/site/prod_summary.jsp?code=KIT33812ECUEVME
http://www.freescale.com/support

C. Smith

I'll second that. In the true spirit of the 555 one computer per injector.
If we can get this to work it will be off the shelf ignition and EFI at
very low cost indeed. Modular and redundant for safety.

For a two rotor, four FreeScale demo PC boards would be required as each
one has an injector driver. Two triggers are no problem for us as each
rotor fires once per rev. Just like a one cylinder two cycle piston
engine.

Hopefully there is a one cylinder 2 cycle piston engine FreeScale
software example that we can use to get a fast start.

I downloaded a bunch of stuff and got this version of the code warrier up
and running. Do we have any C programmers on here?

FreeScale makes you jump through a lot of hoops as far as registering and
activation which is a real pain in the ass. I called them and tried to
explain I don't run windows on the Internet for virus reasons so on-line
activation does not work for me.



Thanks Craig for letting me know about this.


Paul Lamar



Instead of re-inventing the wheel, one could modify/enhance what has
already been validated on thousands of applications:
http://www.bgsoflex.com/megasquirt.html
http://diyautotune.com/
Can't beat open source EFI for ~$300...



Or pay someone who has already designed the system to suit it's
application to aircraft:

http://www.maxwellpropulsion.com/
As seen at Oshkosh 2009

One unique device that I'm not aware exists outside of Maxwells
proprietary
design is an open source integration board to allow use of parallel,
redundant Megasquirt controllers.
Ideally such a system would approach the robustness of Mistrals solution:
http://www.mistral-engines.com/Technology/DEM



Cheers,
Zach Knutson



We are talking much much cheaper than the megasquirt. Also the megasquirt
does not integrate ignition for the rotary. This system does both ign and
EFI and it is far far cheaper than 4 megasquirts. You must do a lot of
stuff to get the megasquirt to work on a rotary.



Mistral is proprietary so you don't have any control over the software.
They do not provide a source listing of the software. Not to mention the
cost.



The same thing can be said about Maxwell Propulsion Systems and it does
not support the rotary. It is like total control by somebody else verses
totally unlimited personal freedom. Windows verses Linux :) If a problem
arises it can be shared and fixed by everyone.



We are looking for a very simple, low cost system that anybody can
trouble shoot and repair with open software. These FreeScale systems are
complete single cylinder ign and EFI on one small PC board. The rotary is
the equivalent a two cylinder 2 cycle engine so these FreeScale systems
are ideal.



Here is some more stuff on them.



Paul Lamar



Paul,
The support for rotary engines (specifically ignition) is an issue of the
past:
http://www.diyautotune.com/tech_articles/how_to_megasquirt_your_mazda_fc_rx7.htm
I'm not sure why you would need 4 controllers though, even with split
ignition timing and 4 coils...

If you haven't investigated the developments in MS hardware and software I
would encourage it. They are much more robust and powerful than even 2
years ago.

You'll get no argument on the open source debate from me, which is why
Meagsquirt is so appealing, the designs and features are always evolving.

Cheers,
Zach Knutson

What the heck kind of email program are you using? It double spaces everything. That is a real pain in the ass. Try setting it up to output plain text only.

The Megasquirt was designed for a four four cylinder four cycle engine.

The two rotor is more like a two cylinder 2 cycle engine with dual ignition. Yes the megasquirt can be made to work but you need two minimum and it is not simple to adapt it to the rotary.

Here is a diagram of just how simple this system can be.

For a three rotor you just add another CAS spaced 120 degrees and a couple more boards.

Paul Lamar

Paul,
Apologizes for the formatting, Gmail default.

Whatever the preconceptions about Megasquirt I assure you current
iterations will run a 2 rotor engine perfectly well with a single
control unit using factory (or not) equipment. This has been
simplified to the point that you can actually buy kits that plug
directly into the factory ECU connector in automotive applications.

It seems the purposed architecture would require burning calibration
tables to each individual card correct? If no, would there be a sort
of real-time link to a PC (laptop?) front-end which would run
coordination/calibration software so that one could tune the engine
without recompiling&burning code every step?


Would each card require its own sensors or would each sensor be split 4/6 ways?
It seems the complexities of stacking a design meant for single
cylinder control may be non-trivial.

As I'm sure you know and a lesson I've learned the hard way, is an
engineers compulsion for clean sheet designs should be tempered with
the reality that a design which refines/enhances previous, similar,
work typically ends with a superior result. Especially with limited
resources.

Best Regards,
Zach Knutson

Two sensor. Each crank angle sensor drives two cards. As far as I can tell the real drawback for our use looks like the input parameters are just air temp and O2 sensor. I'll need to dig further to verify that. Ideally we would have a mass airflow sensor signal. As I recall megasquirt does not use a mass airflow sensor but that may have changed.


We don't need a PC link and each mixture table could be identical. Tracy does not have a separate table for each injector let alone each rotor. He does have two computers and two mixture tables. The idea here is to keep it simple.

Here is a corrected diagram using a mass air flow input signal.

Paul Lamar

Paul, I was watching the webinar videos for this, and I noticed an input chart, it lists a MAF as an input. I don't know if things are still the same from my design days, but one used to be able to call the chip manufacturers and get in touch with applications engineers, to help work out particulars. My sense is that it is a doable application. Further, this would be a universal rotary ECU, and would be able to be used on any rotary spark ignited/FI engine made by anyone.
Still learning, unfortunately, I'm not a software guy.
C. Smith

I am working on it. I am carring on a conversation by email with them . I'll keep people informed.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.