Subject: Slide throttle: Needed with carb?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/12/2009, 10:48 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 I'm fairly sure I'm going to eventually go with a simple mechanical carb with manual
 leaning (as we discussed a while back).  If so, what's the likely penalty
 (HP/weight/fuel consumption) for using the built-in throttle on the carb rather than
 going with the more efficient slide throttle for a NA 13b P-Port setup?
 Thanks
   Mark W.

 I don't know Mark but my guess is not much.  The big problem with a 13B p-port and carb
 is idling stability. You need the throttle close to the rotor housing. With an RX8 side
 exhaust it would be just as  stable as a side intake 13B.
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------
   Another problem you will have to deal with is stand off fuel vapor. With any tunned
 system air flows both in and out of the carb. At around peak torque plus or minus 1000
 RPM lots of fuel vapor is generated outside the carb as the air flowing out of the carb
 also sucks fuel out of the venturi. You can see this in our Youtube video Using a weber
 carb.
   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkKw72dZ2yc
 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQL45DYgIFw
   We checked for this with fuel injection on Marks Suspinski's engine and it does not
   happen.
   You will have to deal with this fuel vapor with a sealed air box above the carb to make
 sure all the fuel vapor is captured. I am not sure how much of this happens if the air
 box is provided with ram air at cruising speed. I suspect the phenomena is much reduced.
 Sorry but you will be on the cutting (bleeding?) edge.
   Here are some 3D's of a system using a Holley 500 CFM two barrel carb with leaning block.
   Paul Lamar
   ***********************************************************
   Paul,
   Thanks very much.  Yes, something will have to be done about the fuel vapor
   "outflow".  I think the ram air might help hold things inside an air box at cruise
   speeds, but on takeoff it wouldn't be much help.  Maybe (at cost of some efficiency) go
   with a carb location closer to the engine and tuned pipes before<< the carb?  I'm sure
   the change in intake diameter through the carb will eliminate the chance to get a
   constructive standing wave from the intake port to the bel mouth, but maybe a
   constructive wave from the carb to the bell mouth could be set up with the right runner
   lengths.
    Or maybe intake length tuning is too much trouble for my simple application.  I'll
   already have more HP than the plane is designed for, and simplicity and weight are both
   important factors.  Maybe for me the best option is an air box fed by ram air,
   convenient length runner to the carb, convenient length runner to the engine.

   Mark W.

   There is limited room to put the carb closer to the rotor housings.
   You could lose 50 HP in a p-port config and more in a side intake port config.   
   Early 13B's with 4 barrel carbs were 145 HP.

   What kind of aircraft are you building?

   Paul Lamar       
 ------------------------------------------------------------


 Paul,
    It will be a Vision.  ( http://pro-composites.com).
 The designer wants 300 lbs max FWF and calls for an engine of 100-160HP, I'd like to be
 on the high side of that range--or slightly above it.  Two examples with O-320s have
 flown.Would a 13B p-port with a 4 bbl need to have a properly tuned intake in order to
 make 160HP?  Some of this might also depend on the exhaust configuration, I'd like for
 the plane to not be excessively noisy.

 Mark W.

 Well you have a lot of time to make a decision on the engine.

 The cowling will be tight so pick a config that is low height.

 A stock manifold will get you 150 HP. You might contact racing beat or Mazdatrix and see
 if they have a manifold for a Holley 4 barrel and then you could get 2 leaning blocks.

 Is it a 4 port or six port 13B?

 Paul Lamar

Paul,
   Oh, yes, I've got a lot of time before I'm ready.  I don't have an engine yet (if I did, I would have done all I could to get it to you for the present P-Port-a-thon you are running!).  I was hoping a p-port drawing through a 4 bbl carb, even with a non-tuned manifold, might make 160HP.  But, "hoping" isn't the same as "getting."

Mark W.

Well that changes a lot of things. Try to get an RX8 engine and p-port it.
There is a cost penalty for using a side port engine with a Holley 4 barrel. Manifold and Holly 4 barrel carb would cost you close to $1000.

In a Vison there is no room under the cowl for an up and over manifold of any kind as I recall.

Paul Lamar                        

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.