Subject: Cooling System Electric Booster Pump
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/28/2009, 5:35 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Sorry,  not sure  what  happened to that link, but here it is    again:

_http://www.daviescraig.com.au/Electric_Water_Pumps-EWP115__12V___ELECTRIC_W
ATER_PUMP___PART_No__8025-details.aspx_
(http://www.daviescraig.com.au/Electric_Water_Pumps-EWP115__12V___ELECTRIC_W
ATER_PUMP___PART_No__8025-details.as
px)

Don

Don,

Long    links do not come across in email most of the time. There  are
several

reasons for this. Perhaps one is you may have sent it  using  html instead
of
plain text. There is an old saying in the  computer  world. Something to
the
effect of; "if you want it to  work for the  most number of people, you
must
use
the least  common denominator."  That would be plain text.   Each  different
O.S.
and email  program deal with email things  differently.  Windows, Linux,
Mac,
etc.,etc.. In fact it is worse  than that as each  person can set  up their
email
programs in  different ways. Word wrap with a   different  character
positions,
different margin settings,  different   character sizes, different fonts,
etc.,
etc., etc., The  situation  rapidly  turns into a computer nightmare.

There is no  real  reason to use html as  a word is a word. The downside
to
using
it as is there is a vast amount of  knowledge out in  the  world in plain
text and
plain text is the most  compact  form of  communication that takes up the
least
amount of  storage  room on  computers. Computers can deal with it in  the
least
amount of time.   Some computers use hardware to  deal with plain text
rather
than
having  the  main processor  plotting each pixel on the screen one pixel at
a
time.
The   character hardware is ten times faster than plotting  each  character
one
pixel at a time.  Another way of looking at   it... is to consider html  in
email
it blootware.

Now  here  is the up side. If you are looking  at web site, or you  are
trying
to
understand a complex subject, links and  pictures  can be  embedded in the
html
text to take you off in a  different  direction  to understand a concept
that
you
may not  be familiar with. That   was why it was invented. IMHO it is  the
only way
to go for web   sites.


Here is the  solution to long links in plain    text.

http://tinyurl.com/create.php

Paul  Lamar



To  the best of my knowledge, I've never had that  problem before.
Oh well, I  thought it was a great topic, and as I  researched it, I found
that a lot of  car manufacturers like BMW and  Audi use electric booster
pumps
in   their cooling  system.  That makes me feel better about attempting  it.
I was  just looking for some specific plumbing   recommendations.

Don

This message is a good example of how   different email programs and O.S.'s
can
screw up a   message.

Electric water pumps work great in cars as 99% of the time  the  car engine
is
generating less than 40 HP. Here are some  numbers. A car  frontal area is
about
25 square feet average.  Height times width times 80%  for rounded corners.
Drag
factor is C  sub d and is .3 on average. Therefor  the aero drag is .3 X  25
square
feet times the dynamic pressure at 60 MPH  which is six  pounds per square
foot.
.3 X 25 X 6 = 45 pounds of aero drag.  60  MPH is 88 feet per second. HP is
therefore 88 X times 45 or 3960  pound  feet per second. Divide that by 550
to get
HP in terms  familiar to the  public. 3960 / 550 =  7.2 HP. Double that  for
tire
rolling drag and  you get 15 HP. Assume the drive train is  80% efficient so
we
are looking  at 19 HP out of the  engine.

Here is another way of calculating it.  Assume for the  moment it is 20 HP
and the
BSFC is .5 giving the engine the   benefit of the doubt. That means the
engine is
burning 10 pounds   of  fuel per hour. Fuel weighs 6.25 pounds per gallon
so
we
have  burned  1.6 gallons of fuel to go 60 Miles or 37  MPG.

One can  change these key variable numbers anyway you  want.
One can change the speed  which will have the largest affect on  the HP and
MPG.
One can change the  frontal area. Height times  width times 80%.
One can change  the BSFC  in the range of .4 to  .6. .4 being real good.
One can change the proportion  of rolling drag  to aero drag. 40% to 60%.
One can change the aero drag  factor. A  Prius is .26 and a Ford Model A is
.5.

The bottom line   is  no matter how one manipulates the numbers one will
still
come  out  with a number of less than 40 HP. This is also the reason 300  to
400 HP
car piston engines are very light duty indeed and do not make  good
aircraft engines.

One can write a QB program in less than half  an hour  to do the
calculations for
for any of the various key  variable  numbers.


Paul Lamar


Again I totally  understand what you are saying.  I realize that a lot  of
work  and engineering must be done to maximize air flow through the
Cooling
system, but I guess I'm not making my question very   clear..........with
all
the link errors and all.  I'm trying to  discuss the  other part of the
equation.......coolant flow through the  block.

You wrote:  "High water flow velocity in the  block  helps  transfer heat
from the
metal to the coolant. If this  does  not  happen hot spots in  the rotor
housings could  occur. The heat   going into the metal is   directly
proportional to how much power  the  engine is  generating on  a
continuous basis. An electric   water   pump that might work in  a car
where anything over 40 HP is  a  rare and  temporary occurrence  will not
work in an  aircraft  engine. One could  be fooled by relying  on  the
water temperature  alone. The water  temperature could be  below  200 F
while the metal  temperature in the  rotor  housing could be over  500 F
in the hot  spots. "

I know  several people who have struggled to do all the calculations   and
meticulously designed the air flow through their cooling system only  to  be
plagued with engine overheating issues.  This makes me  wonder if their
problem is more related to inadequate coolant flow due to  an inefficient
water
pump or cavitation during the extended periods  of high RPM that we
continuously run at for aviation use.  All the  calculations and pain
staking
attention to details in the area of air  flow is essential, and I
acknowledge this
completely.  I'm not  advocating that anyone ignore that  part of the
cooling
system  design....... I'm simply attempting to open a  discussion about
other
options for optimizing the other half of the  equation.........  achieving
adequate water flow through the engine block,  especially  during high load
or
low air flow periods (long climbs, taxi,   etc).

I would not advocate attempting to use a solo stand alone  electric  water
pump and that is not what I'm trying to discuss.   I'm attempting to
discuss
the merits of maintaining the original  mechanical water pump, but  adding
an
additional pump......... an  electric water pump........ to be  activated by
a temp switch only  when the engine approaches the max set  temperature.  So
in  effect, just using the electric pump as a booster  pump only when  an
overheating condition is reached.  And if this  is a feasible  way to
supplement
coolant flow during periods of overheating,  what is  the best way to plumb
the second pump into the  system?    The pump I attempted to provide a link
for will provide  30 gallons  per minute ( at 12 volts ) of boosted coolant
flow through the engine   block with only a 2.16 lb weight penalty. It has
an
electronic  controller  available or you can just use a thermal  switch.

Don


Do you have any pictures of those meticulously  "designed the air flow
through
their cooling system" that don't  work?  Who are those people as I may have
some
pictures  already?

IMHO right now the stock water pump is not the weak link. I  think one
should get
the air flow working first.

A screw driver  held on the pump and to your ear will tell you if the pump
is
truly  cavitating.  It makes a sound like grinding gravel. Also if the pump
is
truly cavitating it will be destroyed in short order. I think reports of
water
pump cavitation in the rotary is a urban legend.

Paul  Lamar


Point taken, I'll drop the subject and just follow quietly.
Don

Don't do that Don. Confirming conventional wisdom is always a good idea.
If you believe in it and have the time and money to pursue it we can always use the confirmation that it works or does not work. One learns as much from one's mistakes as one does from success. Not enough people report their mistakes unfortunately.

BTW what is your right margin set at?

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.