<< Mark writes:
From what I can tell, hydrogen (for use in vehicles) is a dead end.
Here's good link to lots of info on why.
Pitching alcohol as a better fuel ignores the fact the we
have limited farm land, and growing fuel competes with growing
food. Note that the article was written in Q1 2007, before the
steep increases in corn prices and other farm commodities
started to effect the US economy.
<<
Hydrogen briefs well, and sounds good from a podium, but the problems of
producing it (the most economical way by far is from natural gas, so it's
not
carbon neutral). [snip]
Hydrogen for the hydrogen economy will not be produced from
natural gas or from electrolysis -- it will be prepared using
high temperature (2000 degree) nuclear reactors. The (now dormant)
Savannah River nuclear plant is being evaluated as the primary
site for the production of hydrogen fuel. You can cheaply
produce vast amounts of hydrogen using a high temp nuke to
split water.
HOWEVER, the problem with hydrogen is not how to produce it,
it is how to store it -- it leaks through the molecular spaces
of containers. There is a lot of research being done to find
a cheap way to economically store hydrogen in a chemical matrix.
There are now a few promising technologies, but nothing ready
for production. In addition, the proton exchange membrane
(PEM) in current fuel cells is very expensive, and cheaper
alternatives for PEMs need to be developed before fuel cells
will become practical for hydrogen conversion. Once the
storage issues and PEM costs are resolved, hydrogen will
become a viable energy source. These are not trivial issues
to solve.
Energy research scientists believe electric vehicles will be the
only viable alternative to oil for the next 30 years. Hydrogen
based cars are not expected to become practical until 2040 or 2050.
It is unlikely that many of us will live long enough to see hydrogen
fuel become a reality for normal transportation, so while it is a
great concept, it's a problem for the next generation to solve.
Dave Stoddard
I agree Dave.
The problem with electric cars is 50% of the juice in the USA is generated by
coal burning power plants. Another large fraction is generated by very efficient
(50%) compound gas turbine/steam turbine power plants running on natural gas or
oil. Overall efficiency is much lower due to transmission and conversion
inefficiencies. A local turbo compound internal combustion engine would shift
the balance in favor of the gasoline powered car. Japan and France are 70% or so
nuclear plants so overall efficiency matters not.
There are a couple of studies out that state the price of food in the world has
doubled in the last few years due to land being devoted to growing feed stock
for alcohol production used for fuel. The US being one of the major world
producers of food.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethanol
"Recent articles have also blamed subsidized ethanol production for the nearly
200% increase in milk prices since 2004, since the price of fuel has driven up
the costs to cultivate, grow, harvest, ship, refine, bring to market, etc., all
commodities including, but not limited to, milk, although that is disputed by
some."
We need more Co2 and not less so food can grow faster.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.