Subject: On the topic of motor mounts
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/3/2010, 4:18 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

snips..

I am currently considering options for a Mazda 13b lightweight engine
installation. these drawings represent one of 2 ways to skin the cat. the
significant modification I seek comment on is the addition of the struts
at
the top of the FW to transmit loads back down to the main spar.
Please review the included discussion. I look forward to your comments, as
to wheather this is a good idea, and or if you feel any changes to improve
it.
Craig Smith
CH-640 SN 00078


Craig,
This installation looks very messy at best and needs to be redesigned in
my
opinion. However, with the drawings you emailed, I can not offer a simple
solution for you. The top tube going through the firewall will damage the
firewall as you will have a large up/downward load in that area.
Mathieu Heintz
Zenair


What specifically is "messy" about it Mathieu?

At 100 FPS second take off/climb speed assume the net thrust from the prop
is 1000 pounds. To put that in HP perspective that would be 100,000 foot
pounds second. Since one HP is 550 foot pound seconds that is
181 HP net out of the prop. Since the prop eff. is about 80% that
translates
to 226 engine HP. Since max HP is a constant As speed increases the net
thrust from the prop decreases until the net thrust equals the drag at top
speed.

Given 1000 pounds of net thrust out of the prop the top MM strut takes
half
or 500 pounds. The two lower rubber bushings take the other half.

error snips.............

--------------------------------------------------------------------
I forgot the down load introduced by the diagonal brace tubes.
I am so used to thinking of firewalls as being rock solid SS devices
braced
by sheet metal cowling's over the instrument panel area.
This one appears to be free standing from the longerons up.

There is a moment around point A of 5000 inch pounds so the download on
the
firewall due to the brace tubes is 5000 / 12.25 or about 400 pounds.

I don't have a dwg on the fuselage so this is just a guess. I do know the
801 had a sheet metal channel section riveted to the front of the firewall
part number 8F7-3 but I have no dimensions on that either.
My guess it was 2 inches wide with a one inch flange so the total width
was 4 inches. I am also guessing on the fire wall thickness as being .032"
thick. If the channel was also .032" thick that would provide a column
roughly 4 inches wide .064 thick or .256 square inches. Compressive stress
would therefore be about 400/.256 or 1600 psi. Well below the buckling
stress of a column only 10 inches high. If it were a 5/8 diameter 2024T3
tube with .035" inch wall it would take 2500 pounds to buckle it.

The buckling formula is shown in the jpg for anybody that would like to
calculate the load the column will take.
E is ten million as I recall for aluminum and L is ten inches.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Column

I is a bit complicated to calculate but not impossible.

I would be helpful if we had some dimensions on this stuff.

Paul Lamar

So, what your saying is with the addition of the 801 specific parts to the
firewall, it might very well be a viable design. I guess we would need the
help of one of our 801 builders to identify the differences in the parts
and
reinforcements.
Paul, are the advantages of the top mount strut brace significant enough
over the lower brace to the nose gear bracket to warrent the effort?
Sounds
like a bigger mod than we first thought.
Why not try bouncing the original method off Mathieu?
C. Smith

I would not bother. I have seen his of attitude before. Rather

than suggest improvements he just bad mouths the entire project.
He obviously knows nothing about rotary engines. I think it is an ideal
rear
mount as it is the simplest and lightest and half the thrust is removed
from
the lower rubber mounts which are not all that good in the radial
direction
anyway. I got the idea from Steve Beckham and Everett Hatch as they used
to
mount their rotaries that way 15

years ago. They had to beef up the RV firewalls as well. Since the engine
is
six inches further forward the old 801 bottom mount will not work well.

I have a shear and a brake so when you get the firewall send me a picture
and I will bend up a reinforcing hat section and send it to you.

Paul Lamar

Very well, I will take some photographs as soon as I can and forward them
to
you. the firewall pan itself is in my hangar. I can't say I fully
understand
all this, but the point about the longer distance changeing the
effectiveness of the other system makes some sense. Do you need any more
structural detail from the prints, or has what I have sent enough for your
needs?
I'm sorry about the conflict, too bad there couldn't have been more
constructive comment. I'm sure that when this aircraft shows up in OSH and
Sun-N-Fun, we will hear a different song.
C. Smith

One high performance take off and they will come with hat in hand :)

This dwg is good. I think I have enough.

Is the firewall pan galvanized steel? If so that helps as E is 3 times
aluminum.


Paul Lamar


Let me know what dimensions you need, I'll measure them. I've got a
handful
of suggestions to help the 801 mount fit a little better too.

I've been installing the connecting arm to the top-center mount point, and
had to fabricate a different mount attach to the center section to provide
clearance between the arm and the top of the renesis front section, among
other things. I'll send photos.



--Kenny A.
http://websites.expercraft.com/kennya/

I think we have it covered by now Kenny.
Thanks anyway.

Paul Lamar

Here are the pictures of the front and back side of the FW pan. It is the
material called out in the prints, galvanized steel, 26ga.
C. Smith

Craig,
I thought it was pre punched or something. OK no problem you have to drill
all the holes anyway so you can add anything you feel like.

Add in a part like the 801 part that looks like this.
Make it out of galvanized 26 gauge sheet steel.
2 inches wide 3/4 inch deep with 1/2 inch wide flanges.
Bolt the whole works together with 4 10-32 screws.

Won't burn in case of an in flight fire. Stiffer than aluminum. No need
for
the brace tube in the back but the top cover over the backside of the
instrument panel should be .032 minimum. If it is .025 increase it to
.032.
If it is .032 now increase it to .040.


Kenny, I would still like to see the photos. I was not referring to those
photos. I will revise the 801 mount.

Paul Lamar


Let me get this straight. With the addition the hat section reinforcement,
(full FW vertical if practical, nested with the nose gear stuff) will
eliminate the 2 angle braces of the original beef concept. That's an
easier
do, will you be making a run of the top block attach bases?

(radio announcers voice) Sounds like yet another fine product, by Lamar...
C. Smith


Nothing new here as Kenny is doing the same thing on the 801.

The big difference is the 640 cowl is sheeted over behind the firewall.
That makes all the difference in the world.

Not quite done.

Make a bracket like this that goes behind the firewall and is riveted to
the
top skin.

You can make the brackets out of .062 thick 4130 sheet and tig weld them.
and rivet them where possible in addition to the 4 10-32 screws holding
the
whole works together.

Don't be freaked out by the 1/2 inch bolt going through the rubber ball
joint as that is what they need.

This is not a big enough market to make NC parts.

Paul Lamar




I tracked down the top skin, and it is a carbon fiber composite.
http://forums.matronics.com/viewtopic.php?t=67959&sid=0668103757c01b344c0eb4aea7b609e6

How does that change the game?

Can I please get a .dwg, or 3D or 3 view of the mount design with some
dimensions referenced to the doddridge plate? The asymmetry kinda throws
me
a curve ball, and I don't think I can measure it very easily. Thanks for
your time, I know I'm being a bit of a pest.

C. Smith


That looks like fiberglass. You will still need the 4130 bracket
to feed the loads into that skin. I would layup at least one layer of
carbon
on the diagonal on the inside to be on the safe side.

No problem Craig. You do have Qcad so here are some dwg dxf's that should
load.
From those you will get the dims.

The MM trick is set up a piece of plywood to act as the firewall.
Prefab the firewall fittings and the rubber holders.
Locate the rubber holders in space and cut, fit and tack weld everything.

BTW how many people on here can weld steel?

Paul Lamar


I do. Are you interested in doing mounts for other people?

John

I would be but, 1) I have no credentials as a welder and 2) I'm in Canada
and the border might present some complications. I thought someone was doing
mounts and had jigs and everything ?

John

Jerry Hey retired from making mounts due to eye sight problems.
Me and a lot of other people miss him I am sure.

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.