Subject: Dave Garber's bell 47 PSRU.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/8/2010, 9:06 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Paul,

 Any suggestions for a lightweight starter that will fit the 13B? This is
 the latest
 bottleneck, before I can finish modeling the Bell housing and PSRU. I
 think I tossed the
 1985 boat anchor that came with that housing.

 Doug

 They are all about 7 pounds. You have a real problem because
 the Bell 47 PSRU has no room for a ring gear. You might have to install
 a ring gear on the front of the engine. The DG 1 had a gear drive starter
 generator in the front mounted accessory case. Not as heavy as it seemed
 because it was doing two jobs. GM has some belt drive starter generators
 on some new 2009 Chevy-Malibu so-called pseudo hybrids.

 http://alternativefuels.about.com/od/2009hybridreviews/ig/
 2009-Chevy-Malibu-Hybrid-/Malibu-Hybrid-motor-alternator.htm

 "The motor/alternator of the Belt Alternator Starter
 (BAS) hybrid system is driven by a high tension belt
 from the engine crankshaft. It boosts power under
 acceleration, charges the battery, and restarts the
 engine after AUTO STOP."

 I think that is your best bet.

 Paul Lamar


 Paul,
 That accesory drive case looks just like the one on a solar turbine. Do
 you
 know if Dave adapted it?
 Bill Jepson

 I think it was custom made by Racing Beat. Jim Mederer built aircraft
 engines
 for others as well. This one is particularly cosmetic :)


 Paul Lamar


 Paul,

 The GM Belt Alternator Starter (BAS) requires 36 volts to run. What you
 would save on starter weight, you lose on having to carry two extra
 batteries.

 Caption for the picture reads, "The black box with the blue cable houses
 the
 36-volt hybrid battery that powers the motor/alternator for engine assist
 as
 well as restarting the engine from AUTO STOP mode. Protective cover
 removed
 for photo."

 Mark S.


 That certainly is a drawback for most of us.

 The batteries can be smaller as power is power regardless of the voltage.
 Battery power is a fixed function of battery weight. A starter requires
 roughly 3 HP or 2300 KW. At 12 volts that would be 186 amps.
 At 36 volts that would be only 62 amps. Certain devices like CD ignition
 systems work better with high voltage as they are already converting
 12 volts to 400 volts.

 One could use 3 small motor cycle batteries. Wired in series.
 One could also use lithium ion for a better battery power to
 weight ratio. In some cases one would need a custom designed
 voltage switching converter to convert 36 volts to 12 volts
 for powering radio's and other stuff.

 In Doug's case he has little choice. Doug is in love with
 electricity anyway as that is his main biz :) Here is a picture
 of his electric car powered by solar wind turbines in the
 back ground. He is the perfect man to do the development.


 Paul Lamar

 Paul, Do you have a guess where to get a part number and price for the
 alternator/starter. I like the idea of using three riding mower batteries
 in
 series for the starter and charging. With a composie airframe having ground
 wire requirements anyway, puting the batteries in series for charging and
 starting and parallel for other functions seems doable. Also I could
 segregate avionics, lighting, and engine off the three batteries. If the
 cost is similar to the combined price of a new starter and alternator which
 I have to buy anyway for the four rotor it sounds perfect for me.
   My airframe will be a prototype where battery weight is useful for
 adjusting CG and as an added advantage the cable weight reduction from the
 36 volt system is at least 8 pounds for a behind the seat battery location.
   I haven't found anything more on the internet than was repored
 here. The engine displacement and cranking speed comparison to a rotary
 will
 need to determined, but it has possibilities.

 george grimes

 I have no idea but they will be in junkyards sooner or later.
 Switching from three in series to 3 in parallel is very doable
 now a days because of advances in solid state switches.


 Paul Lamar


 Paul,

 I like the idea, but it looks like the first gen BAS is not living up to
 expectations, but may be fine for our needs. GM is supposedly coming out
 with a more powerful BAS in the 2011 models. May be worth the wait.
 Ref.

http://green.autoblog.com/2009/06/11/gm-to-discontinue-mild-hybrid-malibu-vue-aura-for-2010-model-y/

 Mark S.

 Looks like a new generation BAS on the market for 12v systems.

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://cms.ukintpress.com/UserFiles/Generator-(B-ISG).jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.enginetechnologyinternational.com/news.php%3FNewsID%3D16188&usg=__5QDdw19dUnpAT_CulmY3J7t5gn4=&h=258&w=300&sz=24&hl=en&start=27&um=1&itbs=1&tbnid=IKD0foz035OGuM:&tbnh=100&tbnw=116&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dgear%2Bdrive%2Bstarter%2Bgenerator%26ndsp%3D18%26hl%3Den%26rls%3Dcom.microsoft:en-ca:IE-SearchBox%26rlz%3D1I7ADFA_en%26sa%3DN%26start%3D18%26um%3D1


 "It's being reported that among the models that General Motors has decided to discontinue going into the 2010 model year are its existing mild hybrids. The Chevy Malibu, and Saturn Aura and Vue have been available with GM's belt-alternator-starter (BAS) system since 2007 but have never sold in any significant volumes. The system primarily provided automatic start stop functionality with a little bit of electric boost and regeneration. The system was limited by a weak motor and 36V battery system."

 "We checked with GM's hybrid spokesman Brian Corbett about the status of the mild hybrids. Corbett told ABG that currently there are no plans for retail sales of any of the mild hybrid models."

 Near the end of the article it makes mention of being able to produce 25 Kw (33 hp) for brief periods.  I wonder who will incorporate that extra power for a brief takeoff limit (of maybe 60 secs??)  Probably need one heck of a battery.


 Greg in Canada


Paul,


Actually I agree with Matt.  "Can be done", Is possible" and "Is practical" are worlds apart.  I have been going back and forth on this issue for years and have tons of experience in charging different types of batteries at different voltages with different types of generators and different charge controllers.  It really takes a large amount of time to get a system right with new components.


THE PERCIEVED PROS.

Lighter weight wiring runs.  1/3 the ampacity.
Save space.  Eliminate  the starter ring gear and its 8lbs of weight and 7 lbs of starter motor.
Substitute a heavier alternator and its two pound controller.

THE CONS
In a word 'Complexity'.   Controller that changes the alternator from a fairly benign charging source to a 160 amp+ sucking motor depends on robust solid state FETs.  Having changed enough bullet proof, never-will-fail FETs out of generators in my life I know they need to be kept cool.  Also Murphy resides in the production room of these devices. Translation:  Only the less than stellar FETs (one in a million defects) will find its way to the most critical application.  Re-starting a motor in flight could be considered critical.

Batteries.  Now this topic and the charging there-of is a 'it depends' answer.  Generally the more exotic the battery, the more finicky and the more expensive the controller is.  I definitely wouldn't want a LiH battery of any significant size in my airplane.  Especially in an amphibian.  LiH combined with moisture makes hydrogen and fire.  'nuff said:)

Non standard voltage.
A stated 36 volt system is actually providing 42 to 45  line dc voltage depending on the type of battery chosen. Use of DC-DC converters to power the avionic bus from the combined battery pack is the wiser idea.  Direct use of high voltage to motors requires a robust switch with a resistor to dampen the stronger arc.
What about the motors for the hydraulic landing gear, flaps or retractable sponsons?DC-DC converters then becomes plural and become large and heavy for 500 watt  motors.  Add another failure mode in what some pilots already distain in electric/hydraulics.

Sourcing parts. Starter/alternators, or more likely their controllers, are not an item that can be sourced at the local market in the majority of places in the world.  Having a unique airplane is one thing, but it would be better to achieve uniqueness through elegant engineering.

Conclusion.  Less wire weight is a good thing.  How about 24vdc nominal? System voltage with two Concorde or GIL,  AGM batteries will be around 28volts.  Wire size is halved. Have two 12v. nominal alternators each charging a dedicated battery.
Busses can be one 24vdc (heavy momentary loads) and one or even two 12 volt  busses.

Use a bell housing, a ring gear and a 24 volt starter motor, or adapt a small planetary gear set and clutch so that the starter motor can be belt driven either from the front or back of the engine.

In my case* Take the weight saved from lightweight all-aluminum engine and move the counter weight providing batteries from the tip of the nose back closer to the CG thus cutting down on wiring runs.

Paul, contrary to what you stated I can put the RX-4 bell housing  on my engine and install a normal starter gear, starter motor and mount the Bell 47 PSRU to that.  I just didn't like  the look of it, and it forced me to mount the engine 1 inch farther back. The issue with the Bell 47 is the same one that Mistral had to deal with.

In short the sun gear and its drive shaft needs to be supported by a bearing and a sleeve to kept from exerting side forces on the e-shaft.  Both Mistral and the RX-4 semi automatic bell housing have that central bearing, sleeve, oil seal and oil delivery line built into their bell housings.

Mistral has a huge inner ball bearing supporting the outside of the  sun gear shaft.  The shaft is hollow and another internal sleeve is inserted to catch the end of the prop shaft passing through the planetary cluster.  Both rely on outer large splines to transfer power from the planetary cluster to the prop shaft. Both have a threaded inner prop shaft to lock the planetary cluster in place.   These features insure that any side load or gyroscopic tendency will be arrested by the bell housing bearings.  Dave Garber as you noted didn't do that and it would only be a matter time before the rotor bearing failed.

At this point I am dropping my quest for the exotic BAS system and going back to the Bell housing idea and look at ways to weld some engine mounts strong plates onto the side of it.


Doug in Japan

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.