Subject: comparison to a turbine
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/12/2010, 10:44 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 It looks like mistral has a very good shot at successful entry into the
 aviation field.
 Look at the specs of this latest Rolls-Royce entry.

 http://www.rolls-royce.com/defence/products/helicopters/rr_300.jsp

 A P-Ported turbo compound (with LW end and center plates) would beat this
 hands down, for
 installed weight, fuel consumption, power to weight, and probably intitial
 cost if the
 turbo compound existed. Even with out the TC, the numbers are very close.
 So
 where are the
 investors? If RR can justify this entry, one would think the rotary TC
 could
 be developed
 for less than half the cost of a turbine.
 C. Smith


 I'll say. A Mazda two rotor p-port powered helicopter would have almost
 twice the range. In other words half the fuel burn. This is a no brainer.

 Apparently there are no entrepreneurs left in Europe :)

 Paul Lamar

 Two different (while slightly overlapping) markets. In the private and
 experimental market where planes (and heli's) barely chalk-up any
 hours, all the talk is about fuel burn and acquisition cost. Whence
 you dive into the commercial spectrum, TBO, overhaul costs, parts
 availability, etc. come into play.

 Is the Mistral engine PP and use Al plates? Last I checked (and it has
 been a while) they were side port and Fe. I'm not saying that Mistral
 isn't going to be successful, but I don't predict any ripples in the
 commercial area.

 Regarding entrepreneurs, there be plenty. Now investors..... that's
 another story.

 Vlad

 It has been reported on Speed TV during the 2010 Daytona RX8 win that the
 cost of overhauling a 3 rotor is only $8000. Try $100,000 for a
 competitive racing piston engine and a lot more than that for a turbine.

 Paul Lamar

No doubt that rebuild costs for a turbine are astronomical, but that
is only one part of the grand problem. What about TBO? People who use
their aircraft for personal and/or pleasure purposes rarely reach
hourly TBO or rebuild (unless something breaks) but when you look at
flight schools, transport companies, etc. that regularly reach hourly
TBO before yearly, then the rebuild costs are slightly offset.

This isn't to say that a turbine having an x times longer TBO time
will pay for itself when compared to rebuild costs but rebuilds take
time, and for many companies time is worth more than higher rebuild
costs.

To put in perspective, take a MedEvac helicopter. When somebody needs
to be airlifted to the nearest hospital for life threatening injuries,
that person will not enjoy the fact that his ride (the helicopter) is
being overhauled so that the hospital (or lease company) can save
money.

Also factor in the premium for reliability. As far as the common
perception, turbines trump all other means of propulsion. This doesn't
mean that the rotary is unreliable or anything of that sort just that
when you buy a aviation product, reliability and quality tends to
scale well relative to price.

Vlad

There is lots of evidence that the TBO of the rotary
is close to 3000 hours. That is 1000 hours MORE than
the hot section of the RR turbine. Did you read the spec
sheet. Here it is again.

Paul Lamar

I wish I could find some documentation on larger turboshafts like the
T700 for comparison but it seems GE would prefer to keep that info n2k
only. Come to think of it, I can't find any info like that on
military used power plants.

That being said, the RR300 is a novelty turbine. All smaller turbines
are. The smallest turbine I would ever consider appropriate is (was)
the Allison(RR) 250. Again, I can't find any TBO info on it but since
it's been around for so long, someone must know something.

Vlad


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.