Subject: Rhino - not feeling the love
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/23/2010, 7:27 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Hi Paul-

 Trying to do some simple modeling with Rhino.  I'm not loving it.
 Stuck trying to do something very simple.

 I just want a triangular solid.  (imagine a 1/8" thick sheet of al.  I
 want a right triangle 19" x 4".)

 Hints on how to do it?

 Mark Supinski


 Go into dimension properties grid set snap spacing to .125

 In the side view draw two perpendicular lines one 19" and one 4".
 Select loft under surface. Chose the lines and press enter.
 Viola you have a surface. Go into the top or front view
 and choose solid-extrude surface-straight.
 extrude it .125 inches. Your done.

 Paul Lamar

 Mark,

 To get the two perpendicular lines, right click on the line icon
 near top of left side toolbar, click a point on the screen then use
relative
 coordinates in this case r19,0,0 and then r0,4,0 to get the lines.

 If the triangle isn't lined up with the grid draw a line longer
 than 19 (like 24") then pick a point more than 4" away from one ot the
 ends and click the perpendicular snap  on the bottom toolbar to get the 90
 degree corner. Then  go to curve/offset curve and offset the short line
19"
 and the long line by 4" to make a rectangle draw a line from corner to
 corner with the intersection snap and trim off all the unwanted stuff
(trim
 is near the bottom of the left toolbar). You can join lines with the
 edit/join command and then surface /planar curve to get the surface.
 solid/
 extrude surface/ straight with a .125 distance to make the thickness.To
get
 rid of whole lines just select one and push the delete key.

 Don't be confused by Rhino considering all curved and straight
 lines, circles etc to be classified a "curve".
 You can download the user guide as well as two large manuals from the
wiki/
 McNeel web site. They are fast to read and show where to find the commands
 on the screen.The book "working with Rhino 4.0" from  novedge.com
 (santa Paula calif) is a good book also but not free ($35)

 george grimes

 ROFL

 Paul Lamar



Technically, a line is a curve..  A line is a curve with an infinite
radius.


Matt-



Cynthia,  welcome to the group.  I have recently tested all the major
CAD systems and several inexpensive programs as well.
I designed my airframe in autocad 14 after hours at work and liked the
program. It worked in 3D space and did curves with splines and polylines ,
but had no loft feature.  It literally took a week of evenings  to do  the
wing which morphs from 30312  at root to  37412 at  end ofstrake out to a
40415 at the tip with quarter eliptical tips. this program DOES NOT DO LOFTS
which are essential
for the compound curves on a fusalogue or engine nacile. I did the bulkhead
shapes and will build the plane from them shortly but am changing CAD
software for future work.

    I read the operators manuals (bought on ebay for $34 each) on
"solidwoeks" and it's twin  "catia" which had a different user interface
than the drafting based autocad and appeared to require a very long learning
curve. These programs were tailored to multiple users working on a single
project and stored the parts of a drawing in three different file
extensions.  As a former user of autocad systems I used their autocad 2010
as a student version ($175) which will run out in two years on the licence)
This is the full version for 3D rather than the LT version which is 2D. The
screen was filled with tool bars, tool ribbons, and the right 1/3 of the
screen with a block on each command options. The available drawing space was
40% of the screen and if I was in the right "workstation" enviroment
everything was 3 menu's deep to a command.  The loft command did not work at
all complainng about my objects not being correct. It gave the same message
on 2 offset circles. The render comand produced a black screen no matter how
I setit up. The learning curve just to find the commands is too steep.

       My next try was Rhino version 4, also a student version. The loft is
spectacular and worked on the first attempt. I tested it on rotary engine
intake ports which morph from round to the shape in the side housing
(trapazoidal) while curving 47 degrees. There is a blue ball on the screen
which will do a shaded render with 2 clicks or you can set a viewport to
shaded which stays on. The drawing commands are available on the left tool
strip with 1 click and the surface, solid, and transform strip across the
top of the screen is 2 clicks to a command. There is about 80% of the screen
available for drawing. This system is based on mathmatical
curves (NURBS) which are computed from the points you enter. (This is also a
solid works feature and the basis if splines in autocad) You can change the
type of continuity where lines and surfaces meet and the degree (variable
squared, cubed etc) of these NURBS curves and add or delete control points
that control shapes.


 All 3 of these programs offer parametric commands.
Basically you have a shape and can pull or push it to a different shape with
2 clicks of the mouse. I bought Rhino 4.0 service release 6 from
Novedge.com   online for $778     The autocad started at $3700  and the
suite of solid works programs went
for upwards of $15000.    I bought Rhino because it works, can be learned in
3 weeks if you just read the book or the  tutorials in the on screen help
menu, and the price is quite reasonable for such a powerful software. The
WIKI  McNeel site and user forums are extensive and the tech support from
the developer   Robert McNeel is excelent.

        A fourth entry in my list would be Alibre Design which is also 3D
and well featured. It originally sold for $750 but has been offered recently
for $99 and can still be found at that price online.  Several people on this
newsletter are trying it out and producing drawings.  Jean Prudomme is
designing a twin 13B cannard pusher with Alibre, and when I met him a while
back he had never had a CAD system. You might do a post and ask these folks
what they think of alibre.  If it does loft shapes it is a contender.

       There are several free CAD programs and one CAM program on the
linux.org site. I don't know of any users of linux cad but their EMC2   CNC
program is great.    BY the way if you are doing CNC you may need a program
to make the G code files which run the milling machine.  I bought Meshcam
and like it. It cost $173, is easy to ues and it works.

      I would reccomend that you download the Rhino 4.0 user manual or the
training manuals level 1 and level 2 from the WIKI site which are free  and
see if  you think you like the software.  If the price isn't in your budget
there is a student licence which runs 1 year for $175

george grimes


.


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.