Subject: Results of the cowl contest
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/6/2010, 10:52 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


In order of when received.
Please vote on your favorite.

The first 3 were done with Solid Works.
Jeff, Jarrett and Larry.

The next one was done by George with Rhino.
George did a remarkable job based on only
three weeks of learning.

I took George's design and used Rhino
to make a few improvements like radius the
cooling openings for the last entry.

IMHO the point is that the $4000 cost of Solid Works
is hardly justified compared to the $1000 cost
of Rhino. They both do simple things like
mechanical parts with about the some quality.
Solid works has a slight advantage for mechanical
parts.

IMHO Rhino is clearly a better tool for cowlings.

Paul Lamar
--

All of these look great, I'd be happy to have any of them on the front of my plane (if I had one :( )
- Part of the choice boils down to what a user wants--something that looks "conventional" even though we don't have a horizontally opposed engine under there, or something that looks good and also fits the actual cooling requirements of our installation.
I vote for Larry's design, with Jeff's as a close second.

If I had any talent and any skill with Rhino, I'd draw a wide, thin profile design like Larry's, but with no intakes at the front, and put a wide scoop underneath to feed a low-mounted horizontal radiator.
Again, all are great. Thanks to all for contributing.
Mark W.

There are lots of improvements that could be done over the existing 'stock' cowl..

As I understood it, when the challenge was given. We were to try and duplicate
the original as close as was possible. [Duplicate what we saw in the pictures].

If I was to design a cowl for a Rotary install, it would look significantly different from the
stock unit.

Jarrett [I won't vote... since I entered :) ]

You are correct Jarrett it was not a design contest per se.
It was a attempt to duplicate the stock cowl.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.