Subject: Need your advice to purchase a tig welder
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/19/2010, 3:27 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Since i joined the group i know several of you are doing
some tig welding and i need some advise and comments
to find the cheapest unit and the appropriate one for
my project,i will have to weld my drive housing with
reinforcement gusset of 1/4 " thickness aluminum plate
and to 1/2 plate i found lot on the market true EBAY
and CraigLists.com.

I handle pretty good the acetylene torch , have
welded 2 chromemoly tubing Dafhne frames and with
a few practice i am convince i will be fine to
handle the tig welding.

As per some expert they say i will need minimum
250 amps for the 1/2" plate

Jean Prudhomme


Jean,
You do not want the cheapest welder you can find, especially to weld Al.
The low cost ones usually only have a 20% duty cycle. That means only 12
minutes per hour. To weld the 1/2" Al., I would look for a unit that gives
40 to 50% duty cycle. Cost likely $3000 and up a bit.

Dale Davies


Jean,
1/2" aluminum plate is the tough part. I have a Miller Syncrowave 250 that
would do it but it cost 3K+ when I bought it. If cost is your biggest
sticking point I would suggest looking into one of the inverter technology
welders from Miller or Lincoln. When looking be sure to mention the need
to weld
1/2" aluminum plate which may be too tough for them. You will need a water
cooled torch I'm sure. That isn't something that comes with the inverter
style welders from either manufacturer I believe. The Syncrowave products
are often sold in package deals which can often be negotiated on price.
That
may be your best bet, but don't think anything with the capability to weld
thick aluminum will be cheap. Note also that you will need at least a 50
amp 220 service in your shop.
Bill Jepson


Make sure the Tig Welder has High Frequency.
Henry.


Thank,s everybody i made my choice to the INVERTIG 201 and
there is an article regarding the unit


http://www.hemmings.com/hmn/stories/2008/08/01/hmn_feature21.html



Jean Prudhomme


Jean, I don't think you will be dissappointed in that choice. I took a one
day intro class
at HTP in Chicago, I was welding .025 al sheet butt welds within minutes.
(I confess to
having some previous welding experience). There is a lot of capability in
that machine.
All the settings may seem daunting at first, but they allow you to tailor
the heat for
very precise welds. That precision also makes it "easier" for the novice
to begin being
productive. Buy or aquire a pile of scrap metal of the alloys you wish to
work with, make
coupons (test strips) to practise on. Jeff will give you advise on any
projects, he not
only runs the business but is an experienced fabricator himself.
Work Safe!
C. Smith


C. Smith where are you located,i will be at Sun
And Fun next month do you think they will have a booth there??

Jean Prudhomme

Jean, I have not seen them at sun-n-fun, although they do advertise in EAA's
sport aviation and kit planes magazines.
Jeff runs a fairly small operation, with low overhead. Those booths at the
shows are an arm and a leg, I know, as I had a booth one year at air
venture. Try giving Jeff Noland a call at HTP. He will be happy to discuss
anything pertaining to the machine.

The big boys, like Miller usually have a big tent, with the opportunity to
try out the machines, and show prices, but a complete Dynasty DX AC/DC rig
is still a couple grand over the HTP-WC. However go ahead and use the miller
display, and play with a dynasty, ask them to set you up to weld some thin
aluminum. Ask questions about how the frequency and duty cycle controls
affect the penetration and cleaning. You will find it interesting. The HTP
has all the features of the Miller, except it's AC frequency range is a tad
narrower, and perhaps it may have a higher top end current. Otherwise they
are pretty much the same, just you pay more for the Miller name.
There might also be an EAA welding workshop there as well.
Best wishes.
C. Smith


Oh, I'm in Howell, MI. between Lansing and Detroit. Sorry, missed that the
first time.
C. Smith


GOOD EVENING C.SMITH

I GOT A GOOD NEWS I JUST PURCHASE A NICE TIG AND PLASMA 250 AMPS
SIMILAR TO THE INVERTIG 201

THEIR SITE IS WWW.EVERLASTGENERATORS.COM/POWERTIG

THE MODEL IS 256LX BRIGHT NEW AT A VERY GOO PRICE

I WANT TO TO GO ON THE WEB SITE AND GIVE ME YOUR OPINION

Jean Prudhomme


    Jean,

Everlast units are built with "low cost" in mind. I looked at one a year back.

Unsupported board were broken in shipping. Still functional, but a sign they really didn't think of industrial quality or even attempt a drop test on the product.

There was no potting or conformal coating of the boards. That is typical of something like a PC used in home or office environment.  In a workshop you will have a bunch of fine aluminum and steel dust due to grinding, plasma cutting, and generally fabrication. Without that coating on the PC  Boards they electrical traces will short between traces, causing issues.  They saved a few dollars per unit by not using conformal coating, but allows a technician to rapidly replace defective parts before shipping the units (Another savings as they do not need to buy as high of quality parts, just replace ones that failed... an advantage of cheap skilled labor).

I'd recommend keeping the unit covered when not in use. If you have a dust free storage room that is also idea to wheel the unit into that room.  A simple box with an open front and a fan and filter on the back, will help when you are using it. Lots of clean (dust free) air flowing over the unit to keep dust off the circuit boards

The older (pre 2007?) units used multiple FETs that often failed after a few years. Later units have a larger IGBT modules, which are more robust.

For home use, you are probably fine with the Everlast, but I would keep it clean as possible. I try to buy tools/appliances with long life in mind. Everlast was low price, but older units typically lasted only a few years.  They recently changed to a five year warranty, time will tell how the units fair.

Tom W


Jean, in corroboration of Tom's observations, if you read through the user forums on the Everlast site, you will find quite a few mentions of "shipping damage". The Everlast moderators have heaped all the responsibility on their shippers, and many are quite recent. So Tom's observation on the unsupported board weakness is well founded. I will also add that it appears they are quick to get the replacements out to the customer though. It also appears that they are having a great deal of trouble with their foot pedal control. I only read the first one or 2 pages of just 3 of the categories. The more you dig, the more you will learn.
C. Smith

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2009 All world wide rights reserved.