Hi, I really enjoyed your 35 MPG rx-8, and I was wondering if
instead of a
third smaller rotor if you could turn off one of the 2 rotors?
If you wrote an article and I couldn't find it I apologize.
Also, subscribe :)
Yes. The drawback is you still have the friction of the dead rotor.
Paul Lamar in Bartow
Paul,
The rotary is obviously compact and reasonably light, which makes it
attractive for aircraft, but the efficiency problems you are trying to
address are what limits its popularity in cars.
Consider that a garden variety BMW 328i sedan already gets 35 mpg at
65 mph,
even though it weighs at least 300 pounds more than an RX-8 and at
has least
five percent more aerodynamic drag. And the 328i is also geared too
short
for optimal fuel economy, in order to retain some top-gear
acceleration.
The next generation 3-series will likely include a four-cylinder
turbo with
probably more power than the 230 hp of the 328 and 65-mph fuel economy
upwards of 40 mpg. Though I'm sure that the rotary can, and will, be
improved, the Wankel is competing against a moving target.
Csaba Csere
Yes I am well aware of the current BSFC problems with the current
rotary
engine in automotive applications. However the moving target is not
moving
very fast. The piston engine is near the end of its development
cycle while
the rotary is just getting started.
We just did a video interview with the CEO of Wankel Supertech in
Germany
and
they have apparently solved the low power BSFC problem by a slight
change in
the R/e ratio. Compression ratio is now up from 10:1 to 14:1. They are
claiming a BSFC of 240 grams/KW-Hr. That translates to .389 BSFC
down from
.52 BSFC. The current RX8 gets about 25 MPG at 65 MPH so that alone
would increase it to 32 MPG while retaining the size and weight
advantages
of the rotary. A mere switch to a paddle shifted, all mechanical auto
transmission would further improve the steady speed MPG on the RX8 by
lowering the freeway cruise RPM.
The rotary remains the best engine to apply the turbo compound
principle
as there is no exhaust kinetic energy lost to the exhaust valve.
That positions the Wankel engines as potentially the most efficient
portable internal combustion engine of all time shy of large
electrical
turbo compound (AKA bottoming cycle) electrical power plants. These
plants
are 60% efficient by using the waste heat in the exhaust to generate
steam
for steam turbines.
Half the kinetic energy in the exhaust is currently lost in the
exhaust
valve. Diesel engines are now embracing the turbo compound
configuration
despite the exhaust valve.
Car engines appear to be shortly forced into this configuration by
misguided
political considerations :) CO2 is not a pollutant. It is essential
for life.
Ansdale has a better chart on this compression ratio thing but you
will have
to wait for it until I get back to LA and can scan it.
Paul Lamar in Bartow
Paul,
We'll see if piston engine development is tapped out over the next few
years. The new EPA fuel economy standards that were just announced
will
raise the mandatory corporate average fuel economy from 2010 to 2016
by
around 35 percent. The new standards are sized based, so this
improvement
won't be achieved via downsizing. Most of it will come from powertrain
improvements. The easiest approaches are down-sizing combined with
turbocharging and adding more transmission speeds.
If I recall correctly the biggest problem with rotary efficiency is
the
inherently high surface-to-volume ratio of the combustion chamber.
The high
heat loss that this produces helps the rotary's tolerance for low
octane
fuels, while also hampering its BSFC.
That said, your analysis of the rotary's suitability for turbo-
compounding
seems sound. The question will be whether that approach will be able
to
offset the engine's inherent inefficiency and produce a better
result than
one of the new turbo piston engines.
We shall see.
Csaba
We will all be driving around in Smart cars in a few years unless we
get
rid of the jerk :)
Paul Lamar @ Sun n Fun
How 'bout the argument that the "230 HP" BMW engine can't maintain that
HP for hours on end nor could it get 40 mpg at 230 HP. It also weighs
more
than a rotary and still has torsional vibration issues in aircraft use.
Gene Kahn