Subject: 2-stroke oils are not all alike
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/5/2010, 2:50 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Paul,

I have learned recently that there are at least two quite different
types of 2-stroke oils widely sold widely. One maker (Amsoil) offers 5
different 2-stroke oils. As best I can make out, there are oils for
outboard motors (water-cooled, running at low temperatures)
specification TC-W3 by the NMMA. And there are oils for chain saws etc
(air-cooled, running much hotter) specification ISO-L-EGO or ISO-L-EGD
or JASO-FC or JASO-FD. And there is API-TC which fits in there somewhere.

http://www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/hpi.aspx
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JASO_FC

API is, I think, American Petroleum Institute and NMMA is National
Marine Manufacturers Association) and JASO is Japanese Automotive
Standards Organization and ISO is probably the Internation Organization
for Standardization. So these are overlapping standards by different
organizations. But the difference between high temperature and low
temperature 2-stroke oils is, I suppose, quite real. It is insisted on
by people who service outboard motors.

Are these oils are all acceptable for Mazda Wankel engines or which are
preferred?

Al Rees

We have been using the Walmart liquid cooled 2 stroke oil
but Idemitsu is now selling premix specifically
for the rotary. I use their rotary racing oil in my
RX8. 1/4 ounce per gallon to supplement the stock oil
metering pump.

http://www.idemitsu-usa.com/

Paul Lamar

I haven't run my engine yet. Based on my research Idemitsu would be my
first
choice except as far as I can tell it's not widely available.
So unless I hear of a reason not to I plan on using Royal Purple brand.
It can be had at many auto parts store. My thinking being even if I run
out
while on a cross country trip I can borrow the FBO's courtesy car and get
more easily.

Jay

Mazdatrix carries it.

I buy the Walmart stuff by the gallon.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

Certain Two Stroke oils would ruin the Norton Rotary, you would need one
with a high flash temperature, a simple test that we conducted was to line
up our base oil, ( known good one for us was Rotela 40 ) and but the same
amount in a tin cap on a hot plate and just keep poking a matchstick in to
the oil as the hot plate warmed up, to see if the fluidity was similar, if
it got drier and thicker quicker we normally did not test that oil any
further ( yardstick for small budget development ).

The Norton was a total oil loss system and the oil would bake after a very
hot stop, this build up did often cause seals to stick and poor starting.

The type expected to go in a oil tank was generally the worst as the oil
Companies added certain additives to ensure in cold weather that the oil
still flowed via the pozilube systems.

Bob
UK

I don't know about the Norton but there have been two million
Mazda rotary engines sold and I have yet to hear about
any 2 stroke oil ruining the Mazda in 12 years of running this
newsletter. I don't know how that is possible as all sorts
of cheap oils have been used in the "crankcase" and injected
into the Mazda engine.

Our quick and simple test for all oil is to heat it in
the oven for 30 minutes at 500 F. Do it when the wife
is not around as it stinks up the kitchen. When it comes
out of the oven there is usually a high residue content
except for Mobile 1 and aircraft turbine oil. Those are
the only two synthetics we tested. Turbine oil is $10 a
quart or more in the U.S.

Our other test for 2 stroke apex seal oil is do mix 50 50
with gasoline and ignite the mixture and let it completely
burn. The two stroke oils we have tested will sparkle while
burning and leave no residue. We have not tested everything
of course but that was the cheap Walmart brand bought by the
gallon. That 2 stroke oil has been premixed in the fuel in
at least a dozen aircraft with 100's of flight hours
accumulated over the last 12 years.

The Norton, if it is anything like the Midwest/Austro-engines
based on it, have air cooled rotors so they may be more sensitive
to 2 stroke oil. As I recall they use the same oil to lube
the roller bearings as they do to lube the apex seals.

BTW there has been a major break through in charged cooled
rotary engines by going to high tech and real expensive silicon
nitride roller bearing for the rotor bearings. The max RPM has gone
up from about 7500 RPM to 11,000 RPM. The 2 rotor AIXRO version
based on the Norton geometry is now putting out 130 HP
at 11,000  while weighing only about  22 kg or about 50 pounds.
The former MidWest/Austro version was limited to about 100 HP.
The P-port Mazda 13B rotary will produce about 300 HP at 9500
to 10,500 RPM with pressure fed plain bearings including
the rotor bearings.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.