Subject: Oil film strength tests
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/11/2010, 8:31 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 G'Day Paul,
 I would again like to subscribe to your Newsletter.

 A few years ago I was a subscriber. At that time I posed a
 question regarding oil film strength in relation to the
 normal Australian practice of using two stroke oil in the
 sump of rotary engines, including those used in competition
 as I was proposing to use it and circulate it  through one of
 Tracey Crook's reduction drives. I was unable to find any
 objective information to compare ATF and two stroke oil.

 We built a fairly simple oil film strength testing device
 giving us a reading on the load applied and the amount of
 friction generated reading as amps. On being shown our results
 recently Tracey remarked that the components of Mobil 1 were
 responsible for a lot of apex seal problems. No such problems
 appear to occur on two stroke oil here in Australia.

 If you think your subscribers would find our results of
 interest I would be happy to share them with you.

 Let me know.

 Regards

 John Evans

 Quote.

 "On being shown our results recently Tracey remarked that the
 components of Mobil 1 were responsible for a lot of apex seal
 problems."

 Whose apex seals? Tracy's apex seals? Stock Mazda apex seals?
 Tracy is selling apex seals.

 We have been running Mobil 1 for at least 25 years in our rotaries
 with stock Mazda apex seals with no problems. We did a 500 F oil
 bake test and Mobil 1 came out on top of all the oils we tested
 except for turbine oil.

 As far as I know, and some of the evidence would support that,
 Tracy's apex seals are made from steel. We warned our readers 12 years
 ago about making apex seals out of steel. Mazda apex seal history
 also indicates that. Apparently and a lot of other info supports this,
 cast iron is the best metal to make apex seals and piston rings
 for that matter. Apparently it is porous on a microscopic level
 and retains lubricant while steel does not. Mazda spent millions
 coming up with this conclusion. The 13B apex seal environment is
 severe with the seals running at over 500 F.

 Does your film strength tester test at 500F?
 Unless you are testing at 500 F you are not testing :)

 What works best is Ianetti ceramic seals made from silicon nitride.
 Silicon nitride is used in high speed ball bearings as it will
 run over 1000 F while regular ball bearings start to have
 problems at 500 F.

 Read this http://www.rotaryeng.net/seals.html


 Paul Lamar

 Thanks for your reply Paul, I don't know anything about
 Tracey's seals, I showed him the results in relation
 to his gearbox. We certainly didn't attempt to "bake " the
 oil in our tests, so far as I know what we did was a valid
 test for oil film strength in a gearbox. Both the air cooled
 and water cooled two stroke oils we tested were very good.

 Perhaps one of your subscribers would be interested in
 replicating our tests to  confirm/debunk our findings?

 John Evans

 I don't think running the engine oil in the gear box is
 a good idea to begin with. You should use gear lube I suspect.
 What do the Rotax guys do? Lots of two stroke Rotax's out
 there with gear boxes.

 Paul Lamar

 _
 John, I would like to see the some reference to the testing
 protocol you are describing, for replication.
 I work at the R&E Center for Ford Motor Company in
 Dearborn MI. Having participated in numerous laboratory
 and production automotive environments, it is clear that
 he gathereing of data, and it's interpritation must be
 clearly laid out, and of course repeatable.
 I'm interested in replicating your testing protcol.
 C. Smith

 Strangely enough the person I work with is also C Smith!  As I
mentioned in the original post it was a fairly simple device we
used consisting of a 1/4 hp electric motor with a mild steel
disc about 1/4" wide and 1" diameter.  A pivoted lever with the
test piece mounted on it was pulled up by a large spring and
spring balance scale to measure the load.  The length of the
lever multiplied the reading on the spring balance by a factor
of six.  The oil to be tested is applied to the test piece after
carefully wiping off any previous oil, the load is progressively
increased in steps and applied with the motor already running
until oil film breakdown is evidenced by a sudden increase in
amperage reading, the motor slowing and smoke from the oil.

All this may seem fairly simple and even crude, but it did work
and was impressively repeatable.

Paul, as originally stated, the aim was to compare ATF and two
stroke oil as Tracey's reduction drive uses the planetary set
out of a Ford automatic - a C6 I think.  As you know these are
designed to be lubricated by ATF.  We wanted to get an
indication of their oil film strengths, but we did go on to
check a few other oils we had on hand.

As there seems to be some interest I'll dig the results out and
post them shortly.



John Evans                


John, I don't want to ruffle any feathers, but a summary look at your
protocol only tells us relatively how long one could turn the starter before
damaging the bearings, if the oil pump failed immediately after 5 or 6 turns
of the crankshaft, in a relativistic way.
Kind of limited utility.
C. Smith



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.