We have our detractors. Some are advocating Subaru's.
When you run their HP numbers things don't add up.
Here is what to look for.
The climb rate.
The gross weight.
The drag if available.
Here is one example from a detractor of the
rotary from his web site.
Claimed 2 square foot equivalent flat plate area.
Claimed climb rate 900 FPM
Claimed climb speed 100 MPH.
Claimed gross weight 1854 pounds.
HP required to lift 1854 pounds at 900 FPM or 15 FPS
equals 1854 x 15 / 550 = 50 HP.
HP required to over come drag at 100 MPH where
the dynamic pressure is 26 pounds per square foot.
Apparent drag at 100 MPH is there fore 2 x 26 or 52 pounds.
100 MPH is 528,000 feet per hour or 8800 feet
per minute or 147 feet per second.
To get the HP consumed you multiply the FPS times
the drag and divide by the one HP constant
which is 550.
Doing that you get 7644 pound foot per second
divided by 550. That gives you 14 HP out of the prop
for apparent drag alone. That probably underestimates
the actual drag as the airplane is in the induced drag
due to lift speed range. In other words it is not in
or above the drag bucket.
So lets give it the benefit of the doubt and
double the drag. That will double the drag HP number
to 28 HP. Now we need to add the HP required
to lift the gross weight of the air craft which we
calculated above and it came out to 50 HP.
Therefore total HP out of the prop is then 78 HP.
If the prop is say 70% efficient (a rather low eff. prop)
the HP out of the engine is 78/.7 or 111 HP.
With a good .8 eff. prop it would be 97.5 HP
If you want to learn more about this subject
I highly recommend the book "A Practical Guide
to Airplane Performance and Design" by Donald
Crawford.
http://www.actechbooks.com/products/act488/
About right for a 2.5 liter Soob in an aircraft.
The 13B rotary is 2.6 L.
IMHO here is the reason for these
low HP numbers. The Ross gear box used is a 1.85 ratio.
If the 68 inch prop is limited to 2700 RPM due to the tips
going supersonic the engine is running at 5000 during climb.
The prop and engine climb RPM details are missing so I am
guessing on the climb RPM based on the PSRU ratio.
The HP of the EJ25D 2.5 L DOHC 1997 Soob
is claimed to be 165 HP at 5600 RPM.
Obviously this person is not coming close
for gearbox ratio and perhaps some other reasons
unknown.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subaru_EJ_engine#EJ15
No way will you get that with only
a 1.85:1 gear box. In other words to belabor
the point you will not get that HP number unless
you are willing to run the engine flat out.
Full chat. 5600 RPM. I know of nobody doing that
with any stock piston auto engine in an aircraft.
If you have ever been in a dyno room with a piston
engine running full power full load at the red line
you will understand what I mean when I say hand
grenade mode. They will however indeed do it for a
few hours.
The rotary on the other hand can do that for
24 hours and it has proven that many many times having
won more 24 hour races than just about any single
make of piston engine including a couple in the
last few years.
Another number from the web site is 7.5. gallons
an hour at 175 MPH. Giving the engine the extreme
benefit of the doubt with a BSFC of .4 that translates
to 117 HP. Most aircraft engines are in the .45
ball park with the rotary at .47. The speed is
mostly a function of drag and not HP so that is a
pretty low drag airplane to go 175 MPH on only 117 HP.
Top speed is the cube root of HP.
The person says nothing about the weight of the
engine and claims to have (conveniently) never weighed
it :) It is also rather wide due to the dual
over head cams which also adds to the weight compared
to say a push rod aircraft engine of the
same displacement. Not that there are all that
many out there. 2.5 L is 150 cubic inch while
the 100 HP O-200 comes closest.
For some strange reason the last entry in the
web site that discussed the installation of
a six cylinder Soob was 2006. Did this person
give up?
Paul Lamar
Paul, I don't have an issue with the claim of 165 HP out of 153 cubic
inches which is close to 1 HP per cubic inch normally aspirated that is
achieved by most every piston automotive engine. The problem for me is
running a piston engine at a
continuous 5000 RPM. The exotic engines such as the indy car Honda and
assorted formula 1 brands such as Ferrari only run about 1500 miles before
replacement at their rated RPM and they are $135,000.00 per copy.
For me the rotary has a very low frontal area and a small cross
section just behind the prop which presents a huge opportunity for flat
plate drag reduction. Also the rotary needs to be run above 5500 RPM which
keeps th HP up. In comparison to Subaru, no one is advocating trying to run
an aircraft rotary at the stock 8500 RPM, With a gearbox that held the
engine to 3800 RPM on the subaru would be a nice 90 HP engine although a
little heavy at that HP.
george grimes
Back in the old days some auto engines used really good material.
I rebuilt my mothers 1937 Packard engine and it was a work of art
with chrome molly steel forged crank and rods. The Volvo's from
about 1947 through the 70's as I recall were also made from
excellent materials. Now a days cast iron or nodular iron
is used extensively for cranks and rods. Some rods are made
from powdered metal.
Formula one engines last two races. NASCAR one race. Engine
failures among racing piston engines are common. I would say
at least 10% of the piston engines fail on average in every race.
It is common for rotary engines to last a whole season or two.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.