Paul,
In recent emails you have noted the potential advantages of water cooled
(water cooled per SAE paper 900035) eccentric shafts.
I am trying to remember the thermal characteristics of oil vs.
water/anti-freeze and I can't. I do know a generation back or so, some
Suzuki sport-bikes were oil cooled via a radiator.
Is oil thermally at a disavantage over water?
If you went with water and ceramic bearings could the bearings be cooled via
water and anti-freeze like the early 80's Chrysler turbo-Daytona did?
Note I am not sure that was a success to mirror, however I had the pleasure
of attending a Taurus SHO kick off a year ago and the vendor display of the
turbo had oil lube and water cooling in the turbo housing to keep the
overall housing temps stable. Interesting concept to keep the turbo cool.
My best,
Anthony
A lot of of turbo's are water cooled including the stock Mazda RX7 versions.
I think the problem is the heat transfer coefficient or conductivity from
metal to the oil is not as good as metal to water. This problem manifest
itself in two ways. In the engine from metal to oil and from the oil to the
radiator or oil cooler metal.
Lighter weight oils such as 5 weight seem to work better. The RX8 manual
recommends 5 W 30 as I recall.
The bottom line is one must measure the metal temperature and not the
coolant temperature alone.
Paul Lamar
The trick is to rethink the current charge-cooled engine and just stop the
heat from getting to the Eshaft.. Composite rotors with ceramic coating,
maybe sodium filled rotors, maybe very thin or hollow cross-section rotors
and reduce the incoming charge temp then aftercool it before the engine uses
the mixture. Increasing the velocity through the crankcase volume may also
help. Reducing the rotor width may also work, an area thing and reduces the
residual unburned fuel near the side seals. A thermal study of several
concepts may prove fruitful. Keeping the heat away from the rotor/Eshaft
reduces the need to cool it. My turbo work showed reduce charge temps
throughout the rpm range. I never could measure the rotor bearing temps so
the turbo-ed charge temps may have been a heat transfer issue. But the
bearings looked good at tear down. Just some ideas that I have been thinking
about.
Bud
Try some heat sensitive paint on the e-shaft close to the
rotor bearing.
http://www.tmchallcrest.com/thermax-paint.php?switch=TMC_Hallcrest&ref=Paint
Paul Lamar
I've had recommended to me that I use 100% water in my cooling system,
which makes sense in one respect- that water has a higher specific
heat than the 50/50 water/antifreeze mixture that I am now using.
If I were to do this, does anyone have any thoughts about possible
corrosion and corrosion inhibitors and maybe an additive to decrease
the surface tension of the coolant? I anticipate my first flight in
the next two weeks.
Brian Trubee
Not a good idea from a corrosion point of view.
Lets see what happens in the climb out. Pick
a cool day for first flight.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.