Well, I am pleased to report that my turbo, stock housing with TO4
wheel and 60-1 compressor with a fixed open waste gate has lasted
over 230 hrs without a single problem. The solution to good enough?
Make it better. I just finished my annual during which I upgraded
my turbo to a similar TO4 big shaft wheel, but now it has a TO4E 50-
trim compressor and the wastegate flapper and actuator are back in
place. Why the change? Either I am a glutton for punishment or I
am starting to pin down this turbo issue. For those of you not
familiar with my turbo history, here is a quick recap:
First turbo - the stock second generation with waste gate flapper
installed, ridden hard and put away wet... it was run at full
throttle at high altitudes, often at peak EGT. It lasted 70 hrs
before the turbine wheel fell apart and broke off. The thought at
the time was that the stock turbo was just too small for this heavy
duty abuse and was overspeeding at altitude.
Second turbo - small shaft TO4 wheel with 60-1 compressor and
removed waste gate flapper. It was also run mostly at peak EGT but
the power produced was somewhat lower because of the bypassed
exhaust. It lasted about 140 hrs until it suffered the same fate as
the first turbo while I was in a long full power decent (read extra
high RPM and EGT's). My thinking at this point is that the high
EGT's are primarily the problem.
Third Turbo - The one I just removed after 230 hrs. Same
configuration as the second but I kept the EGT's under 1600, mostly
as lean as I could while keeping the engine running not too rough.
It was also run at pretty low pressure ratios. It could only make
about 38" MAP on take off and about 40" at full bore down lot. At
16k altitude it was down to about 22". My curiosity now is weather
I can perhaps increase the boost and continue to have the turbo last,
as long as I keep the EGT's under 1600. I know, glutton for punishment...
Other issues..
Lean of Peak operation. During the turbo change I discovered that
my stock cast iron exhaust manifold had developed a number of
serious cracks and some advanced erosion. Much of the
erosion/oxidation was near the mating surface with the turbo and it
had started a small leak. My concern is that all those hours of LOP
operation allows too much oxygen into the exhaust to promote to
oxidation and accelerates the problem. The question is, should I
start running rich of peak to prevent rusting away the exhaust
system components? ROP operations also allow me to keep even lower
EGT's (for the turbo) and smoother engine running (for the wife).
Turbos and exhaust components that I get from cars usually have the
appearance of being run rich, rather than the dry orange color of
the inside of my components. The only obvious downside is the
obvious much increased fuel usage. I think that for the next couple
hundred hours I have going to have to bite the bullet and fly ROP
(while at higher power settings). Thoughts?
S.A.G. is really baffling. Spark plugs only seem to be lasting 20-
30 hrs before SAG starts kicking in. Noted by a distinct and marked
loss of power as I cross through about 1500' AGL after take off.
The problem is usually intermittent and mildish at first becoming
more consistent and remarkable as the hours accumulate on the spark
plugs. The problem is always solved by changing out the spark
plugs. I am switching to colder platinum plugs in order to try to
get them to last longer. Perhaps running ROP will help them last
long too?
Time for a new Prop? On a test flight yesterday, the engine was
running great. No SAG. At 7000' and 33"MAP I was at 6500 RPM,
about 1/3 throttle and doing 175 KTAS [201 MPH]. It is a 64
length x 77 pitch 3-blade Cato, but that is more like an
effective pitch of closer to 71". I seem to remember being able
to get closer to 185 KTAS [213 MPH] at 6500 RPM in the past on
the same prop but I did have a little taken off because of the
low output of the previous turbo. After some more experience I
may discover that it is time for another new prop. Might soon
contact Paul Lipps, I liked his article in the last issue of
Contact! mag. If that is my worst problem, I am going to be
pretty happy.
Doing some formation flying with the guys next week that may make
its way into a movie...
Keep building!
--
David Leonard
Turbo Rotary RV-6 N4VY
http://N4VY.RotaryRoster.net
http://RotaryRoster.net
I really appreciate Dave's persistence on exploring
turbo charged rotaries in aircraft use.
The turbo life issue is not only the EGT it is the turbo RPM as well.
If the RPM is high enough the blades will disintegrate regardless
of the turbine inlet temp. The load on the blades is M times V
squared divided by R. V is the the tangential velocity of the blade
CG. M is the mass of the blade. R is the radius of the blade CG. All
rotating device suffer from this problem. As the temp goes up the
strength of the blade material is reduced. At 1600 F strength of
exhaust valve steel is down to 5000 psi which is next to nothing.
See the attached chart. Epoxy resin is 3000 psi :)
Here is a chart from Caterpillar on the situation. The turbine
MUST be kept within the limit lines of both temperature AND rpm.
I have repeatably tried to get Dave to install a Garret turbine
RPM kit. In fact I will buy it and send it to him. No luck
so far. If you send me the compressor Dave I will install
the RPM sensor for you and send it back as well. Perhaps Zack can
convince him :) We need to know the turbine RPM!!!!!
Somebody needs to try a Capacitor Discharge ignition system
to further investigate the spark plug "sag" problem.
Inconel is probably the only answer to high temp corrosion
of ferrous materials. I have seen many cracked cast iron
turbo exhaust manifolds.
Paul Lamar
Hi Dave,
Auto OEM "wisdom" dictates running rich while boosted to prevent detonation.
Also autos are regularly being accelerated off lights etc, which will give the
black soot.
How would ceramic coating the turbine housing work to keep heat out of the
metal? You would have to compensate for the thickness of the ceramic at the
mating surfaces or have them masked off so you do not coat those areas.
Dale Davies
Dave,
What is your new turbo make, number and trim? Same as the Cozy
Girls but with a built in waste gate? I have a similar cast
iron manifold as yours and you are welcome to have it. That
will get you in air fast. A better long term solution would be
if I donate a custom fabricated exhaust manifold to your
cause. I can with your dimensional assistance design and
manufacture a stainless 316L with altered pipe ells, It would
have a tangential junction connecting both runners so that an
external wastegate could divert the exhaust flow BEFORE it hit
the turbine. It will be more robust and lighter than the Mazda
cast iron manifold you are now using. Paul can attest to the
quality of the welds at the shop near me. Most of their works
is fabricating exotic alloys and they can guarantee fitting by
using my 13B assembled engine.
In return I as well as others need flight data. If you can fly
to at least 18k, and cruise rpms near or over 6K engine rpm
then the data you collect will be invaluable for not only my
project but scores of turbo rotary want- to-be's. Paul will
lend you a turbo tach and I believe a few of us could cobble up
a ten channel flight recorder so you don't have to take notes.
What do you say?
Doug in Japan.
Now that is an offer you should not refuse Dave.
Doug's shop is second to none.
3/16th inch thick 316 SS plate is ten times better than cast iron.
Here is a simple design that will divert the exhaust
gas before it reaches the turbine. The is the ultimate waste
gate. Zero to 100%. This 3D could be dimensionally interchangeably with
the stock cast iron 1990 manifold Dave is using now. Same
dimensions.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.