Subject: Mark Suspinski crash and fire.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/12/2010, 5:49 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


In my opinion fuels pumps belong in the fuel tank,
either the mains or collecting header tank.

Doug in Japan




Which means in my plane that a 'high-pressure' line will be running through
the cabin (RV-6) instead of a suction line.
Not sure I really like that...

BrianG
Iowa


Excellent point. Thanks for bringing that up. I almost
crossed over to the other side.
C. Smith

Brian

Doug writes:
Yep good point and you are obviously considering fire.
C. Smith writes:Doug,  Not just a fire, but leaks and trapped vapors as
well.


Doug writes: Well none of us like the idea of being surrounded by huge fuel
tanks
and high pressure fuel lines but the fact is we are.  Just
because they might be on the other side of that thin firewall,

C. Smith writes: Perhaps this is the case in your design, but in most
aircraft, the fire wall is one of the most robust structures in the
aircraft, as it must bear a cantilevered engine load, as well as transmit
the thrust loads. Also, as the name implies, much of it's design
consideration is and should be to contain a fire.


Doug writes: in a crash or even a slight crunch, the airplanes structural
components deform or rupture.  The design concern is to choose
the fuel line material and routing that  offers the best chance
of maintaining its design integrity in a crunch.
When we run the 'what if'  scenarios we can then design systems
to cope with the multitude of risks.

C. Smith writes: No argument

Doug writes: We can't eliminate them.
Well<85 I take that back, perhaps we could but then wouldn't be
flying:)

C. Smith writes: Pure opinion, without factual support.

Doug writes: The point we should be considering is how to disable and
isolate
the source of fuel right at the tanks.
C. Smith writes: The only point? Why?

Doug writes: This would entail emergency shut off valves that
could be activated by pulling one cable.   That big red knob
could be set up to de-energize  the
fuel pumps as well, and perhaps at the same time another one
valve could depressurize the line.

Fire extinguishers?  Yes of course.  A nozzle going to the
engine compartment near the hot zone and another in the cabin.
Fuel lines should be chosen that are high quality, rupture
resistant, and placed in a manner that minimizes risk to the
occupants.  This could mean enclosed within the structure

C. Smith writes: All good ideas. All add complexity to design,
fabrication, and increase cost, as well as the implied necessity
to have tanks and airframe structures that permit maintenance of
the fuel pumps in tank, and effectively seal the fuel tanks.
Again, added complexity of fabrication and design, and increased
cost.

Doug writes: Since you are considering an engine that requires
high pressure
fuel to the injectors, to maintain the injector manifold
pressure unused fuel will have to be returned somewhere.  Where?

C. Smith writes: I have not finalized fuel system architecture,
of course it must be returned to the tank that is delivering the
fuel. But, correct me if I'm mistaken. The fuel pressure
regulator is typically at the end of the fuel rail(s). The fuel
return consists of fuel volume in excess of that required by the
injectors, and in a properly vented system, the pressure in the
return lines after the regulator would be: less than that in the
fuel rail; equal to the head pressure (weight of fuel volume in
the return line above the pressure regulator) and the resistance
to flow, or the restrictions of return line system.
Significantly less than the rail, or delivery pressure.


Doug writes: Or maybe I assume too much.

C. Smith writes: I believe that you are.

 Doug writes: Are you planning on running a
carburetor?
Doug in Japan

C. Smith writes: No.



All,

I have the advantage of high wings, but maybe this idea will
work for you.  Gravity drain from wing tanks to header tank,
where high pressure fuel pumps can be located inside or outside.
Vents are only in the wing tanks, although there are both
gravity drain and return lines to the header tank.  Header is
your reserve fuel size or a little smaller.  My lines, both high
pressure and low are Teflon with stainless braid cover.  I get
from the local hydraulic shop and use with barb fittings and
oiketer squeeze clamps.  I can get descriptions, etc if you
need.  Hose is about $5 to $7 per foot.


Dan F


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.