I have always been fascinated with the idea of building
a cheap airplane out of the lowest cost composite materials
possible. Back in 1965 when I worked for chaparral cars I did a
study on the lightest material to use for a race car body.
I settled on 1/4 inch PVC foam with one layer of 4 oz glass
cloth on either side. It was much lighter and stiffer per
square foot than .032 aluminum.
http://www.jmsonline.net/glass-fabric-4oz50-x-10.htm?source=googleps
We built the body of the chaparral 2F
out of that in a vacuum bagged female mold. The body was very
strong and so light the paint shop doubled the weight.
The car was capable of well over 200 MPH at some tracks like
LeMans so the body was plenty strong enough.
Race car bodies and airplanes have at least one unique thing in
common. The body panels and wing panels are subject to high pressures
distributed over the surface. The structure must be strong enough
to resists these kinds of loads. Sandwich panels are ideal.
At 200 MPH the worst case scenario on a wing is dynamic pressure or
about 100 pounds per square foot.
In other words the lift coefficient is one. If the ribs are one foot
apart the center of the panel should not deflect excessively or fail
with a distributed load of 8.33 pounds every inch. This is easy
to set up a test panel and check for failure and deflection.
It may be that rib spacing of two feet or more is acceptable depending
the core thickness. Thicker foam cores add little weight while
allowing greater rib spacing. In other words fewer ribs with less
fabrication work.
Female compound curve molds are very expensive and time consuming
but fast airplanes can be built out of flat panels and simple curve
parts. The Vans RV series are good examples.
A cured sandwich panel is very strong and stiff but it is difficult at
best to curve it to fit the top of a wing for example.
The question is: how do we build a wing out of pre-curred flat panels?
I think I have the answer. What we need is foam screws to screw
the flat panels to the curved wing rib edges until the epoxy sets
up. Here is a cheap, super light weight foam screw called a dry
wall anchor obtainable in any hardware store. It is used to hang
rather heavy objects on a dry wall.
The next trick to to lay up half the sandwich panel on a flat
surface so only one side is curred. The other side is raw foam.
This then can be bent, raw foam up, to cover the top of the ribs
and screwed to the one inch thick foam ribs with foam screws while
the epoxy glue cures.
We then lay up a single layer sheet of glass fiber on a smooth
flat surface and let it cure. It will be very flexible when
it is curred so we can bend it to fit over the raw foam
already bonded to the ribs shiny side up. Weights placed
over the rib areas can be used to hold it down while it
cures. These weights can be made from long skinny sand
filled cloth bags. In some cases bungee cord can be used
to make the leading edges conform. In certain extreme cases
one could use foam screws.
The whole idea here is to cut the cost and time needed
to build an airplane and take advantage of the low cost
rotary engine.
What do you guys think of this idea?
Paul Lamar
Paul,
That is the way I did the nose on the Limo EZ. I made a male buck,
glassed
one side of the divinicell foam and bent it over the buck and held it in
place with screws, then glassed the outside. Remove the screws and
repair
the holes. I also found that the foam goes plastic at 240 degrees so
I made
a female mold out of plywood screen and plaster, place it into a home
made
oven. The mold, raw foam sheet were inside of a heat resistant vacuum
bag.
After baking to 240 switch on the vacuum pump and the foam was pushed
down
in the mold. after it cools glass it like the plans. You can get
compound
curves. I did this for the fuselage bottom.
Joe Berki
Limo EZ
Paul,
This concept sounds surprisingly like the Fold-a-plane method that has
been
around for a while. The company used to be called Vision Aircraft and
their
aircraft is the personal cruiser. It appears they have had a funding and
expertise infusion and are now called Pro-Composites. Check out the
building
method on their site:
http://pro-composites.com/building.htm
Regards,
Jack Hilditch
Not the same wing contruction Jack. This is the old mold less
construction invented
by Burt Rutan. Glass over hot wire cut solid foam cores. As anybody that
has built a LongEZ can tell you there are hundreds of not thousands
of hours of sanding needed. Here is a screen capture from their web site.
Another draw back is it is heavier as it is hard to control the
resin content when glassing the foam. Also the wing is solid foam
so anything, such as wing tanks or landing gear, placed inside needs
extra work to hollow out the solid foam core.
The new method described above eliminates the sanding and
automatically forms a light weight sandwich skin hollow wing.
The layups are done on a large flat smooth surface so excess resin
can be squeegeed out. It is a multi step process. First the lower
skin of the top cover is laid up with the thin foam core
bonded to it. Then it is attached to the ribs causing it to conform
to the rib curve. Then the top skin is laid up on a large flat surface
and turned over. It is then curved and bonded to the now curved
and thin foam sandwich core.
The ribs can be made the same way to add strength and seal them from
gasoline.
Paul Lamar
Hey Paul,
Do you have any pictures of this laminating process in action? I'm
having a problem understanding how you plan to curve the cured
lamination with one side cured. My experience with cured composite
tells me that it's usually pretty stiff stuff. Do you do this bending
when the layup is only partially cured and still flexible?
I remember seeing a similar process back in the 60s in Popular Mechanics
magazine. They proposed building a wooden armature with frames and
stringers to support the foam. A bit of heat applied with a heat lamp
made the foam conform to compound curves. After the foam core material
was shaped over the armature a layer of glass was laid over the
outside. Then the armature was removed and the inside was laid over
with glass. I never tried it but it sounded pretty easy.
Mark LaPierre
--
Just and additional 3D illustration uploaded here.
When you lay up a single cloth layer 4 oz glass or carbon "laminate"
it is about as flexible as heavy weight paper.
Since it is bonded on one side to a 1/4 inch or 1/2 inch thick
foam board it gains very little bending strenght as the foam
is easily stretch on the tension side. Go to Home Depot and find
some 1/4 inch thick Styrofoam board and get a feel for it.
No pictures yet but I have been designing and building foam and epoxy
composite structures off and on ever since about 1960 when I worked for
an aero space antenna manufacturer in Arlington Va called Melpar.
BTW Some of our complete chassis at Chaparral were made solely from 6 to
10 layers of 10 ounce epoxy fiberglass curred in an auto clave.
The 2D Chaparral that won the Nurenburg ring around 1967 had a fiberglass
chassis. Not my best material choice for a chassis. The modulus of elasticity
of fiberglass is too low for a chassis where stiffness is paramount.
Paul Lamar
From a structural standpoint, I believe it's not favorable for
there to be foam between the outer skin and the skin on each
rib. I believe you give up significant strength to weight ratio
by building the structure as you have shown. Said differently,
the value of even having ribs is significantly diminished by not
making a glass-glass bond from the ribs to the outer skin.
Matt-
The load on the top skin worst case is 8 pounds per square inch
tension separating the top skin from the foam at 200 MPH assuming
the top skin alone provides all the wing lift. The tensile
strength of the foam therefore does not need to be any more
than 8 psi average. Of course the suction load is higher in some
places than it is in others. Namely around the quarter chord
point close to the main spar location. A row of one or more foam
screws near the spar can provide a stronger attachment.
http://building.dow.com/ap/china/prod/prop_fab.htm
This web site gives the tensile strength of STYROFOAM RTM
at 700 KiloNewtons per square meter of 700 or 100 PSI.
A factor of ten in this application. If not true the top
skin of your Long EZ would be sucked off the foam.
The only function of the skin on a wing is to contain
the lifting force. In effect rib stitching provides this
force in a fabric covered airplane
A secondary function is a shear force to add torsional
strength to the wing. Easily provide by the lower skin
of the sandwich. It also retards the tendency of the
wing to lozenge due to outboard drag force.
For those of you that want to get into the nitty gritty
of aircraft structural design I can highly recommend
this book. Analysis & Design of Flight Vehicle Structures
by Bruhn 1965 Lib Of Cong #64-7896 When I bought it
back in the late 60's it cost me $14.76 :)
Paul Lamar
http://www.amazon.com/Analysis-Design-Flight-Vehicle-Structures/dp/0961523409
"In my 16 years in the Aerospace Industry I have rarely come
across a more quoted or well known text with the possible
exception of Roark's Formulas for Stress and Strain. Bruhn
is the basis for most Aerospace company strength manuals.
It is truly the Bible of flight vehicle analysis."
Michael Rodgers
Admittedly, flight loads on the skin are low. The high
loads come in handling the airplane.
Matt-
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.