Subject: cheap and quick to build composite airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/2/2010, 9:07 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 I have always been fascinated with the idea of building
 a cheap airplane out of the lowest cost composite materials
 possible. Back in 1965 when I worked for chaparral cars I did a
 study on the lightest material to use for a race car body.
 I settled on 1/4 inch PVC foam with one layer of 4 oz glass
 cloth on either side. It was much lighter and stiffer per
 square foot than .032 aluminum.

 http://www.jmsonline.net/glass-fabric-4oz50-x-10.htm?source=googleps

 We built the body of the chaparral 2F
 out of that in a vacuum bagged female mold. The body was very
 strong and so light the paint shop doubled the weight.
 The car was capable of well over 200 MPH at some tracks like
 LeMans so the body was plenty strong enough.

 Race car bodies and airplanes have at least one unique thing in
 common. The body panels and wing panels are subject to high pressures
 distributed over the surface. The structure must be strong enough
 to resists these kinds of loads. Sandwich panels are ideal.
 At 200 MPH the worst case scenario on a wing is dynamic pressure or
 about 100 pounds per square foot.

 In other words the lift coefficient is one. If the ribs are one
 foot  apart the center of the panel should not deflect excessively
 or fail  with a distributed load of 8.33 pounds every inch. This is easy
 to set up a test panel and check for failure and deflection.
 It may be that rib spacing of two feet or more is acceptable
 depending the core thickness. Thicker foam cores add little weight while
 allowing greater rib spacing. In other words fewer ribs with less
 fabrication work.

 Female compound curve molds are very expensive and time consuming
 but fast airplanes can be built out of flat panels and simple curve
 parts. The Vans RV series are good examples.

 A cured sandwich panel is very strong and stiff but it is
 difficult at  best to curve it to fit the top of a wing for example.

 The question is: how do we build a wing out of pre-curred flat panels?

 I think I have the answer. What we need is foam screws to screw
 the flat panels to the curved wing rib edges until the epoxy sets
 up. Here is a cheap, super light weight foam screw called a dry
 wall anchor obtainable in any hardware store. It is used to hang
 rather heavy objects on a dry wall.

 The next trick to to lay up half the sandwich panel on a flat
 surface so only one side is curred. The other side is raw foam.
 This then can be bent, raw foam up, to cover the top of the ribs
 and screwed to the one inch thick foam ribs with foam screws while
 the epoxy glue cures.

 We then lay up a single layer sheet of glass fiber on a smooth
 flat surface  and let it cure. It will be very flexible when
 it is curred so we can bend it to fit over the raw foam
 already bonded to the ribs shiny side up. Weights placed
 over the rib areas can be used to hold it down while it
 cures. These weights can be made from long skinny sand
 filled cloth bags. In some cases bungee cord can be used
 to make the leading edges conform. In certain  extreme cases
 one could use foam screws.

 The whole idea here is to cut the cost and time needed
 to build an airplane and take advantage of the low cost
 rotary engine.

 What do you guys think of this idea?

 Paul Lamar

  Paul,

  That is the way I did the nose on the Limo EZ.  I made a male buck,
 glassed  one side of the divinicell foam and bent it over the buck
 and held  it in place with screws, then glassed the outside.  Remove
 the  screws and repair the holes.  I also found that the foam goes
 plastic at 240 degrees so I made a female mold out of plywood
 screen  and plaster, place it into a home made oven.  The mold, raw foam
  sheet were inside of a heat resistant vacuum bag. After baking to
  240 switch on the vacuum pump and the foam was pushed down in the
  mold.  after it cools glass it like the plans.  You can get
 compound  curves.  I did this for the fuselage bottom.

  Joe Berki
  Limo EZ

  Paul,

  This concept sounds surprisingly like the Fold-a-plane method that
  has been around for a while. The company used to be called Vision
  Aircraft and their aircraft is the personal cruiser. It appears
 they  have had a funding and expertise infusion and are now called
 Pro-  Composites. Check out the building method on their site:
 http://pro-composites.com/building.htm

  Regards,

  Jack Hilditch

  Not the same wing contruction Jack. This is the old mold less
 construction
  invented
  by Burt Rutan. Glass over hot wire cut solid foam cores. As
 anybody that  has built a LongEZ can tell you there are hundreds of
 not thousands  of hours of sanding needed. Here is a screen capture
 from their web site.  Another draw back is it is heavier as it is
 hard to control the  resin content when glassing the foam. Also the
 wing is solid foam  so anything, such as wing tanks or landing gear,
 placed inside needs  extra work to hollow out the solid foam core.

  The new method described above eliminates the sanding and
  automatically forms a light weight sandwich skin hollow wing.

  The layups are done on a large flat smooth surface so excess resin
  can be squeegeed out. It is a multi step process. First the lower
  skin of the top cover is laid up with the thin foam core
  bonded to it. Then it is attached to the ribs causing it to conform
  to the rib curve. Then the top skin is laid up on a large flat
  surface and turned over. It is then curved and bonded to the now curved
  and thin foam sandwich core.

  The ribs can be made the same way to add strength and seal them
 from  gasoline.

  Paul Lamar

  Paul,  Core-cell foam sold at boat fiberglass supply houses has a
  nice line  of pre scored PVC foams in a variety of densities. There
  are lengthwise  scored sheats for fitting planar curves and grid
  scored for compound curves.  It is absolutely manditory that there
  is a fully bonded surface  between the wing skin and the foam shear
  web coring. This will require  carefully sanded cores after the
  single surface glassed core is applied to  the ribs. The finished
  top surface can be no smoother than the core if there  is a
  complete  bond, otherwise the epoxie adhesive will be very thick and
  heavy.If  there any areas of air there will be delamination at
  altitude andwith changing temperatures since the air is trapped in a

  closed area  with  the closed cell foam.I would suggest laying the
  cloth out  between two sheats of clear  polyethalene on the flat
  surface and  wetting out/ squeege the surface as  suggested. There
  will be  several layers of S2 glass at different orentations  with
  each layer  1" larger than the one below so that the thickness at
  the  edges is  tapered. Then peel off the plastic from the side you
  need to bondto  the foam and lay it on the freshly microed core

  after squeeging  on a  little additional resin over the micro. Then
  continue to  squeege the top  plastic sheat to remove excess resin
  to the front  and back edges. Using the  plastic gives a smooth
  final surface and  prevents getting the cloth  streached out of
  alignment/orentation.

  The upper plastic is initially  wrapped over the core and marked
  with a sharpie to use as a guide in cutting  the cloth. The bottom
  of the wing would be skinned first so that the upper  skin will lap
  over it at the leading edge to be below the chord line at the
  seam.   Getting the wet out skin in place is like applying a large
  vinylsign.

  Leave both plastic sheats in place and drop it all on the
  core. move  it around to alignon with the dry core. then fold it

  back on it's self and  peel and cutaway the half of the bottom
  sheat  that is up. Do the micro and  roll the glass over the fold
  into  place. Flip the second half over the now  stuck first half, remove
  that lower plastic and micro the second half. Roll  the rest of the
  glass and plastic back over the fold and squeege everything.

  Pro-set has a hardener with more than three hours open time and the
  vacuum infusion hardener is usable and even longer with the
  regular epoxie.  Eatsern burlap.com in norfolk virginia has a good
  price.  Any type of  fiberglass cloth and weave is available in 73"
  wide rools or by the yard  from Thayercraft.com in High Point NC
  and  they have free shipping with very  good pricing.Ask for Steve
  if you  E-mail them. He is building a Cozy in the  warehouse there.

  george grimes

 For a 1/4 inch thick wing top skin you don't need pre scored foam.
 That is primarily for small radius compound or simple curves.

 "The finished top surface can be no smoother than the core if there
 is a complete bond, otherwise the epoxie adhesive will be very
 thick and  heavy."


 I disagree with this statement as the pre curred top skin is as stiff
 as heavy paper so it will be a smooth surface. The epoxy glue is
 mixed with milled fibers which reduces the weight and makes it more
 viscous.  Less likely to get voids. Standard Rutan procedure.

 In any event it is far easier and quicker to sand foam than fiberglass.

 If air bubbles were a problem at altitude we would have long since
 heard about it based on the number or Rutan aircraft out there.

 There is no wet out skin. We are only dealing with pre curred skins
 that have become somewhat stiff. One layer of 4 oz glass cloth
 or carbon is not hard to wet out on a flat surface. You can
 also spray on a gel coat and then the epoxy glue. A Teflon roller
 might be ideal. It is even possible to buy pre curred thin fiberglass
 flexible panels.

 Paul Lamar
 --
  No, apparently there is some confusion.  The Fold-a-plane
  construction technique (used on the Personal Cruiser ans also
  the Vision) uses no hot-wired foam. It results in a lightweight
  sandwich construction.  One side of the foam is glassed, then
  the panel is formed in the desired shape and the other side is
  glassed to lock in the shape.  On very tight radius curves some
  foam is removed to alow a tight bend, but on gentle curves this
  isn't required.  Some folks have vacuum-bagged the outer skin
  during the first layup, placing the epoxy and glass down on a
  very smooth surface and allowing the extra resin to come up
  through holes in the foam and to be captured in a blotter layer.
  The outer surface is very smooth (very little sanding needed)
  and the pressure assures the fiberglass is fully wet out and all
  the extra epoxy is removed.  Light and strong.  Steve Rahm
  published the method, but I don't think he ever claimed to have
  invented it.
  While some folks have trouble bending "naked" foam without
  snapping it, glassing and curing one side makes things a lot
  easier.  One famous quote "Heck, I could bend a cracker in half
  if one side was glassed".

  Mark W.

  Sounds like you are talking about the fuselage.
  The wing is what I am concerned about.

  I got this screen capture right off the ex Vision now
  pro-composites web site.

  http://pro-composites.com/building.htmIt

  clearly states  hot wired foam cores are bonded to the
  spar and then glassed. Scroll down the front page.

  Please log on to the web site above and check it yourself.

  The response to this idea I have had so far from the readers
  of this newsletter speaks to the uniqueness of this type of
  construction :)

  If I did not already have a KISS cruiser 90% done 90% to go
  kit I would build some test panels.

  Paul Lamar


 At AirVenture 2010 I attended several workshops by Scott VanderVeen from
 Pro Composites.  This is a very interesting process that results in a
 fairly
 smooth surface.  Pro Comp has a video for those of us whom are newbies at
 composites.  I like Pauls' idea of vacuum bagging on a flat surface. How
 about hinging two large honeycomb panels on the long side to make the
 buildup, then flip and bag for this flat surface?

 For least weight Scott recommends a glass bead/resin layer squeegeed on
 the
 foam and then peel ply over the glass to soak up excess resin. Would this
 work on 4 oz cloth?


 Could plywood stations (essentially exterior ribs) work to form the wing
 exterior panel and then glass the interior side to hold the shape? I have
 been pondering this method to form our leading edge, which then attaches
 to
 the ribs using adhesives and additional  pull rivets at the spar.

 Dan F

Paul, Air filled voild in wings have been a problem with solid skins over a
foam core. Alan Shaw had a business building wings for Velocity aircraft
after he stopped working for Velocity. He used a closed pressure mold with
precured skins over featherlite cores. There were cases of 30% voids during
production. Some were salvaged by injecting resin through a hole at the end
of a void until it came out a hole at the other end. Several of the
resulting wings delaminated at altitude and were scrapped. The statement
that if this was a problem the many Rutan designed moldless composite wings
would exhibit this failure mode may not be accurate. The Rutan aircraft are
ALL wet layup over the cores with shear webs and spar caps also laid up wet
over the cores. With reasonable workmanship full contact with the microed
cores is relatively easy.There have also been some delamination problems
associated with hardshelling foam cores. This method arguably passes tests
of peel strength, however some delamination has occured  at the junction of
the skin and micro surface.
        One other point is the single layer of 4 Oz glass. At a minimum one
layer of 8 harness satin with spanwise orientation and one at + or - 45
degrees for torsional loads is required. The cloth could be uni directional
if minimum weight is a concern. Of secondary concern is puncture damage from
spectators at airshow parking areas or dropped tools by the builder. Often
this determines the plies necessary more than the tensile strength of the
materials.
    I saw the refrence to "I" beam manufactured spars. If the spar is fit
through the ribs to leave the rib perimiter continuous it might be easier to
use a tubular spar particularly if wing twist has to be built in.The inboard
portion of the spar could have cloth laid up to progressivly increase
thickness and perhaps some phenolic blocks incorporated for the attach pins
to the fusalogue. Just a thought.
Also you might consider tapering off the foam before the inner skin as
applied  on the flat work table so that the inner and outer skin would be
bonded at the leading edge and somewhere at the rear.

george grimes

Hey I am not responsible for some ones lousy workmanship :)
One must be doing bad work indeed to get a 30% void. It is a simple
matter to check the foam for flatness with a straight edge.
Sand the foam with a long straight 2 by 4 with sand paper
on one side.  Deal with the problem instead of throwing the baby
out with the bath water. Just be careful.

Use the coin tap test to detect voids. Robin does that on
air buses. SOP on airliner composites.

The first layup that controls the torsional stiffness can be anything
you want in the way of fiber orientation. The outer skin does nothing
but protect the foam from damage and adds panel stiffness.

The leading edge can be solid foam with a wet layup. That will cut down
enormously on the sanding.

Time is money. This is a way to cut the time and cost needed to build
the airplane. It does not make sense to use a construction technique that
takes a year to sand smooth. Not to mention the mess and several coats
of paint.

Paul Lamar.


A couple of thoughts on the "year to sand smooth"

- Much of that "year to sand smooth" comes from inaccurately formed
cores.  If the core is formed accurately, the finishing process is
obviously much easier to accomplish.  There are readily available CNC
cut cores for many of the Rutan type airplanes.  One of the people
that makes these cores says that if there's adequate intere$t, he
might be willing to make cores for other types.

- Much of that "year to sand smooth" comes from people using
ineffective techniques for applying and forming filler.  And the wrong
materials.  A method similar to what Cory Bird used on his "Symmetry"
is a good one.  He was particularly fastidious in the completion of
that airplane..

- Leading to my final comment about "year to sand smooth".  Some
people think it's terrible if you are able to see any evidence of the
underlying structure of a composite airplane.  The same people think
it's terrible if you can see the grain, tape, or stitching on a fabric
covered airplane, or any of the rivets on a metal structure.  I think
that's only one (inefficient) mentality towards aircraft finish.  When
you look at many of the composite parts of commercial airplanes, there
is obvious print-through on layups, and in many cases, you can see the
transition from one layup schedule to another.  I actually prefer this
as it makes me feel more confident in the structure and workmanship of
a particular piece.  If everything is covered in frosting, I only know
the skill level of the person doing the finishing, not of the builder.
Plus, filler added is weight added.  And in most areas of the
airframe, filler doesn't contribute aerodynamically.

So, as you say, don't throw the baby out with the bath water..  The
construction methods popularized on Rutan designs is quite efficient
when taken in the context of one-off custom built airplanes.


Matt-

I have never built a Rutan type composite airplane but
I wonder why one cannot sand the foam before applying the
wet layup to insure an accurate surface.?

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.