Subject: The buck. Cheap bamboo structures
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/8/2010, 12:05 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


In one of our photos ... is the bamboo scaffolding held together withy
duct-tape?

Robin Bergland

It would not surprise me :) It looks like it.
If the worker falls and breaks his neck so be it.
The survival of the individual is not important as long as the work
gets done.

Paul Lamar

In Asia they introduced steel scaffolding but after many deaths went
back to bamboo, I was in Hong Kong a few years ago and they were fixing
the advertising neon lights above Nathan Road and had bamboo scaffolding
across the the busy road above the traffic with bamboo poles standing up
from the island fence in the middle of the road, the fence was there to
stop people trying to cross the busy road, just would have needed a tap
on the poles and all would have come crashing down, life is cheap in
China, one down another 1.6 billion to go!!
  John.

I wonder why steel scaffolding  did not work in China.
Perhaps they could not figure out how to bolt it together?

http://www.calibamboo.com/whybamboo.html

I am thinking of making a low cost fuselage space frame out of
bamboo since it reputedly  has a higher compressive strength to
weight ratio than carbon fiber.  Lots of hang gliders have
been built from it already.

Because of the strength to weight ratio of bamboo it was used for
some of the first airplane designs. However, due to the difficulty
of joining pieces it lost out to other materials.

The first successful flight of a powered dirigible had a super
structure made of bamboo. It was 82 feet long and 11 feet in diameter.
Its first flight was in 1898.


Total Ave. (E)= 2.27*10^6 psi about as stiff as a fiber glass laminate.
Ave. tensile strength for narrow samples is 11232 psi
Ave. tensile strength  for wide samples is 14196 psi.
Being organic, it would also deteriorate more quickly than steel

Independent testing has shown that bamboo/epoxy also has a much longer
fatigue life than fiberglass/polyester laminates.

Bamboo     300 - 400    kg/cu.m
300 kilogram/cubic meter = 0.010 pounds/cubic inch
400 kilogram/cubic meter = 0.014 pound/cubic inch

Aluminum is .1 pound/cubic inch
Steel is .3 pound/cubic inch
Hand laminated fiber glass laminate 50% resin is
about .06 pound/cubic inch.

The problem is the joints. No duct tape :)

Paul Lamar



Paul

We use bamboo scaffolding and bamboo post to support when casting the slabs in Nepal.  Diameter are 4 inches but the wall thickness is is 5/8."  It takes more load than the 1 1/2" metal pipes.  The joints when  correctly done are fine. Correctly means properly notched and  1/8" wired thick together.  I seriously doubt duct tape would hold anything.

Doug in Japan




-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.