Subject: Norton / Midwest Rotary Aero Engine
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/14/2010, 6:56 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

Paul
My Norton Rotary story starts out many  years ago when I first saw the
Norton engine being marketed by a  company that is now defunct.  the engine
looked small, and the  stats (although no aviation engine had been produced
looked  impressive.  (I can only remember the colors of that companies  logo
as being green and the engine being just a purposed minor part  of their
line)

That engine never came to market, and I  put a VW engine in my dragonfly.

After my first flight, many  years after I had seen that engine, because of
oil pressure  problems, and a broken Canard, I removed the engine and
rebuilt it,  to find the bearings totally shot (was a new aircraft
conversion,  built by the converter incorrectly).  After the rebuild, I had
some spinal surgery (not aviation related, from which the recovery  was
extensive and I went out to the airport, sat and just stared at  my project
for what seemed like years.  Ultimately, I realized  that I would, indeed
walk again and decided to once again address  the engine.  About that time,
I read that the Norton engine was  being made available as the AE100R by an
English company called  Midwest and one was available in the US (they had a
rather strange  distributorship system, with sometimes strange people doing
the  distributing.) I felt that because I had indeed survived and was
learning to walk reasonably well, that I deserved that engine which I  had
lusted over, but until now was unavailable.

I was able to  get the two rotor. There was little factory or distributor
backup,  at that time.  The engine had 2 carburetors and the lubricating
oil
lines were plastic.  The engine has a plastic(for want of a  better word)
induction manifold sitting on top, under which was  another manifold for the
cooling air/oil mixture to be expressed out  of the engine.(more about this
later) The intake manifold was quite  substandard and needed a lot of
reinforcement, and the 2 tubes, one  to each rotor were similarly
constructed.  I believe the carbs  were Tillotsens.

The engine was a combination of water and air  cooled. The trochoids were
cooled by the standard H2O antifreeze  method, water pump at the back of the
engine, directly driven off of  the eccentric.  The rotors were cooled
differently.

Oil was injected into the trochoids, for obvious  reasons. It was also
injected into the bearings (probably roller)  for lubrication.  There is no
oil pressure or sump in this  system.  It appears as if the oil, after
lubricating the  bearings, weeps into the center of the engine at which
point it is  picked up by an airstream created by a turbine, belt driven,
and  blown into the innards to cool the rotors.  This, then oil and  heat
laden air is exhausted out of the engine coursing through the  lower
manifold indicated above.  It is then routed to a  separator, basically an
evaporator pad.  Some of the oil (about  1/3 of that used for the bearing
lubrication and cooling) drips to  the bottom of the enclosure and is
returned to the oil storage tank,  and the rest blows overboard..  The
system works well, as long  as proper ducting, etc is used.  You cannot use
premix in the  fuel as the bearings will not be lubricated and your flight
will be  very short.


There are a couple of problems with the above  mentioned system.  1.  The
recommended oil is very  expensive (synthetic "Goldenspectro- Premix" from
what I  remember.  A Mobile Pegasus product is also approved ( I have a  55
gal drum full of the stuff which serves as a table, in my  hanger)

2. The oil laden air, exhausting from the engine (which  can be used for
Carb heat or alternate air) has to go somewhere, and  it coats any aircraft
part downwind from it.  In my case, the  Right wheel pant was always covered
with unburned goo after a  flight.

After I installed the engine and had some flights with it, I  had major
ignition problems with it (the installed system was crap,  and in fact
decided to remove the engine.  The Midwest company  was quite wanky, seemed
always to be on the verge of bankruptcy and  was looking for an angel.
Response from them was, and many that of  the people related to the company,
was less that what I wanted, in  terms of safety and backup.  I did not like
the plastic lines,  the Carbs were difficult or impossible to properly
adjust.  (by  the way, there were 2 of these engines on our field, mine
being one  of them, the other in a beautifully built Kitfox, not flown at
the  time..  I don't know if has flown yet (several years later, although
it
has changed owners).  Because of bad feelings of the future  of Midwest, I
decided to dismount the engine and look for other  avenues of power.




As I was pondering this decision and  after, frankly hugely negative
feelings
that I got from the factory  Rep at OSH, I heard the Diamond company had
come in as the  savior.  Elated, thinking that this would resurrect my
almost  abandoned engine, I found out that they had made many modifications
to it, based on the few that were out in the field.  These  improvements
included a different coating of the combustion chamber  a new EFI and
ignition system, metal lubrication lines and a much  stronger manifold
assembly.  They also modified the cooling  turbine (which had been changed
at least 2X before because, I  believe, they were disintegrating or breaking
in use.

So I packaged my engine, sent it back to England to Midwest (Now  thinking
it was Diamond) to have it rebuilt (after about only 25 to  20 hours, if
that) to their new AE110R.  now rated, by the at  110 or 115 HP.
configuration.  and reinstalled  it.

After about 75 or 80 hours of flight, on approaching a  landing, in dicy
weather conditions, the engine refused to accept  throttle on level off.  It
did not stumble, but continued  idling at 2K until my arrival in a way too
short field, and the  necessary destruction of the aircraft to save my own
bacon.   The engine, in effect was still idling when I stopped, and I shut
it  down normally (of course, the three bladed C/s prop had fractured  it's
Warp drive blades.

Then the real fun began. I was  made aware that the ignition system had a
fault log which could be  downloaded and evaluated, however only Diamond had
the software to  do it, and they refused to release it due to proprietary
reasons.  They said that I could ship the engine to them and they  would
send me a report---Ya Right.

Although by this  time, my contact person, at the company was great, I hit a
brick  wall.  Shortly thereafter I got a letter from a Barrister, of  the
company, that Midwest, a company whose stock was wholly owned by  Diamond
had, in fact been closed (bankrupted) and basically was told  to "Pound
sand".  A personal meeting between me and Christian  Dries (Owner of
Diamond) resulted in the same pound sand  philosophy.  The engines did
resurface at Austro  later.


An additional problem with the AE100 is that the  Champion spark plugs
(surface electrode) used are no longer  manufactured.  With the
remanufacturing, they went to a  similar, but not directly retrofittable
Bosch plug, which also is no  longer manufactured.  (I have about 100 of
these plugs, still  in their original boxes if anybody is interested.  They
were  used on the BMW, M1 (I believe that is the model) as the originals
supplied.

Because of my experience with diamond, I personally  would certainly have
great misgivings about dealing with them in any  capacity.  By the way the 2
rotor is not certified, the 1 rotor  was.

I actually loved the engine, despite the oil problems.  Reminds me of the
joke "Other than the third act, Mrs.   Lincoln, how did you like the play?

If you still want one, I  suggest you contact a man by the name of Richard
Nagus, (once  working for Diamond/midwest) he is involved with Nortons in
England,  and he can give you more info on the current status of parts
availability and support.  The fact that you saw parts at Diamond does  not
necessarily mean that you can get them.



My  suggestion, if you want to use this engine, get a 110R, design your  own
electronics and prepare not only for no factory backup, but  because of the
relatively small number of 2 rotors in the field,  practically no support
from users

If you do get the  100R, make sure that the turbine [blower] is the proper
one  as
when it sheds  blades or whatever it does, you may find  yourself in a
world of hurt.

Engine itself ----when  running ---3 canards up (out of 5)

Support  and  recommendations,10 canards down

I have attached a photo of the  installation (early photo)


Rich

What year was  this Rich?

Paul Lamar


Hello Paul/ John/ Brian  and Rich, who wrote quite a comprehensive story
about his  experiences with Norton AE100R:

Yes, there are some experts, who  know a lot of these early Norton rotaries.
You already mentioned Mr.  Richard Negus (retired, but having Norton as a
hobby). Another is  Mr. Martin Ruhe, who also worked at Midwest. Also Mr.
Peter Morris,  who is now working at Andover Norton, knows a lot of Norton
and its  spares. Surely there are some others, who might be helpful?
Midwest/Diamond/Austro people have a lot knowledge and experience,  since
there are more than 500 AE50R engines ("Half Nortons")  flying.

My experiences about Wankels and Norton are only one  year old. We have a
team (3 men) flying a Beaver RX650 ultralight  with Norton Aerotor80 P62
here
in Finland. This plane was built in  1991, but has flown only 112 hours, of
which 18 hours this year, in  our use after some years of silence. The
engine
itself is powerful  and has been running nicely. We only had to rebuild the
fuel lines  and electrical lines, because these were already 20 years old
and
caused some trouble. There is also another Norton Aerotor80 P62 here  in
Finland, which was spoiled long time ago because of poor oil. (In  pieces in
our garage waiting for rebuild?). These 2-rotor Norton  Wankels are not many
in the world, but it would be nice to keep them  running and challenge the
piston engines. Do You have any idea how  to find the owners of these Norton
Aerotor engines?

Thanks to this "Rotary Engine" forum of Mr. Lamar, we have been able  to
receive some good advice from Norton&Wankel experts  concerning the right
oil
type (Silkolene Comp2 Premix) and spark  plugs (NGK CR9EK). Those old oil
types and spark plugs, recommended  by Norton some time early 90's, have not
been available for a long  time. If You Rich still have some old Norton
spare
plugs, I would be  interested (maybe some other Norton lovers, too!).
(Champion UG80PV  or similar? Bosch plugs). Even some other spare parts, if
they are  available?

BTW, I saw an article in Sport Pilot/ Hot kits &  Homebuilts (September
1995). There was a Tiger Moth replica with  this type of a Norton Aerotor
engine. I wonder, if this plane/engine  is still flying or anybody knows
anything about this?

Enclosed: Some photos of these two Norton Aerotor 80 P62 engines, which  we
have here in Finland.

Heikki


Greetings Heikki,

When the Champion plugs stopped production, Midwest went to Bosch UEC/UET2
plugs, which also became discontinued.

As part of the re-manufacture, there was a little machining of the engine to
allow for the slightly larger nut portion and wrench clearance of the  new
plug. Richard Nagus would probably be able to tell you how this was done.
Other than that, the plugs look identical, both surface electrodes.

If you are interested in plugs, let me know. I don't know if there are any
more available.
If your engine has the "flytronic" ignition in it, my guess is that it was
manufactured after the switchover and these are the plugs for you, without
modification of your engine.

Rich



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.