Subject: crazy question? 12 vs 24 v alt
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/23/2010, 9:13 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

Suppose one has a supposed 24v alt installed on a 12v system, with an old
Ford type Cessna 12v regulator. The voltmeter in the plane (several of
them)
never indicates over 14 or so volts. Will a regulator limit the voltage
delivered to no more than 12-14v or ? What would supposedly happen if a
REAL
24v alt were installed-I'm thinking all sorts of mayhem-battery, bulbs,
kaput 12v radios, etc? We are talking 60A unit here. Inquiring minds want
to
know....(I think I have a mislabeled OEM unit!)

Marc W


Marc,
one of the more popular small alternators (B&C-20)  for the continental uses
the same alternator for both 14 and 28v and only the regulator is changed.
Larry

Perfect example. That's a wound field alternator.

The regulator will just lower the field current until the output voltage is
in
the right range.

Matt


     There are two versions of the B&C-20, one is wound for 14V  another is
wound for
28V.    Regulator is external.  Different alternators,
different regulators.

One way to check your alternator.  Energize the field, and hook up a bank of
power resistors to handle the load. Spin up the alternator
and see if it can put out 30V @ 10Amp load. If so, that is a 24V unit.
 With
two units side by side you'll see the wiring size difference,
pretty hard for a shop to mix them up during a rebuild.

Regulators are on/off.  Early ones used relays to control the field,  later
semiconductor versions also use the same on/off principle.  Nothing fancy
about it.

Tom W



There is only one version of the SD-20.  Word from B&C and indicated
in their fact sheet.

http://www.bandc.biz/pdfs/quickfacts_sd20.pdf

The output current is the same at high RPM - an indication that you
actually get more power at 28V when turning fast.  At low RPM, the
alternator core doesn't produce enough energy to raise the voltage to
the regulated level, so the output current is behind the 14V unit.


Matt- Long EZ


     The "one alternator fits all" is Marketing, not Engineering driven.   It is a
28V Alternator, but when used for 14V is producing only half the rated output.
Trick is the alternator is only used for 50% of it's rated capacity when sold as
a 14V Alternator.


With an alternator rated at 20A, it is producing 280W when used as a 14V unit,
and  560W on 28V Application.    By selling one alternator for both 14V and 28V
applications, you  gain  more sells per model number...  but it isn't an optimal
solution.  It  does reduce your inventory, which in turns help reduce the
prices.


While my aircraft only needs an 10 pound battery,  admitted I can install a 20
pound battery and it will work fine.  Penalty is a little extra weight, but much
easier on the battery store stocking only one battery rather than two.


B and C puts out great products.   Their Alternators are designed for 28V
applications, but also can be used for 14V applications. I understand why they
sell only one unit, but doesn't make it the best solution for your 14V
Application.


I would double check to make sure all your OVP (over voltage protection) is
functional when using 28V alternators on a 14V system.  Admitted failure is
similar, but there are some additional risk management issues.  Most of the EFI
systems will tolerate a 24V (i.e. tow truck jumping) voltage, but if that
regulator fails, and your battery is cooked, what happens to your engine
management if 35V is being applied to it?  Will it fry, shut down, or run long
enough to clear that powerline on final approach?

Tom W


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.