Subject: Prop shaft metal selection Att. Jeff.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 12/1/2010, 6:01 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Paul
 I can purchase round metal to machine my prop shaft and the material
 available by the inch is the 8620 cold roll steel.
 I will machine the shaft myself and have the splines made it by
 outside shop.
 I do have an alternative ,built the shaft with the planet driven by
 outher splines or built the shaft complete with the planet housing
 and it will be in one pce,the price for material difference is $50.00
 but more milling machining for the pinions cages.
 I wondering if Jeff can do the milling parts
 9" long 4.25"dia is $124.00
 8" 3.75"dia is $72.00
 I bought a 9"x 24 lathe from Harbor Freight and i should have it soon

 There is the 8620 specs;

 8620 Cold Roll Steel

 Analysis
 Mechanical Properties
 Applications
 Machineability and Weldability
 Heat Treating
 Tolerances
 Speedy Metals items
 AISI 8620 is an alloy carburizing steel when thermally treated
 develops a hard outer case with a soft ductile core. Carefully
 controlled proportions of chromium, nickel and molybdenum are
 responsible for the extensive use as a carburizing alloy steel,
 with valuable features including extreme surface hardenability
 and good internal strength. Has minimum distortion and growth
 characteristics. 8620 has good machinability and responds well to
 polishing.
 ANALYSIS

 Carbon (C)
 Manganese (Mn)
 Silicon (Si)
 Chromium (Cr)
 Nickel (Ni)
 Molybdenum (Mo)
 Phosphorus (P)
 Max
 Sulfur (S)
 Max

 18-0.23
 0.7-0.9
 0.15-0.35
 0.4-0.6
 0.4-0.7
 0.15-0.25
 0.035
 0.04
 8620 cold roll bars conforms to ASTM A331
 MECHANICAL PROPERTIES

 Condition
 Tensile Strength (PSI)
 Yield Strength (PSI)
 Reduction of Area
 Elongation in 2"
 Brinell Hardness

 Annealed
 100,000
 85,000
 60
 21
 185

 APPLICATIONS
 8620 applications include gears, pinions, cams, cranks,
 clutch shafts, shafting, axles, tie bars, collets, bushings,
 heavy duty pins, bolting, springs, hand tools, die cases,
 and a multitude of machinery parts and components.
 MACHINEABILITY AND WELDABILITY

 8620 has a machinability rating at 66% of B1112. Average cutting
 speed 127 ft/min.
 8620 can be forged at 2200° down to 1800° F prior to hardening or
 carburizing.
 8620 is excellent for welding applications

 HEAT TREATING
 8620 can be hardened to 1500° F followed by water quench. Carburize
 at 1650° - 1700° F in an appropriate carburizing medium and oil
 quench to harden. Tempering of carburized parts is done at 250° - 300° F
 and will result in the alloy having a core strength of approximately
 135,000 psi minimum. Tempering of heat treated and water quenched
 parts (not carburized) is done at 400° - 1300° F, with greater
 hardness the lower the tempering temperature.
 TOLERANCES

 Rounds

 Up to 1-1/2" incl.
 -.002

 Over 1-1/2 to under 2-1/2
 -.003

 Over 2-1/2 to 4" incl.
 -.004

 SPEEDY METALS ITEMS

 3/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 1/2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 5/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 11/16" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 3/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 7/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 1" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 1-1/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 1-1/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 1-3/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 1-1/2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 1-5/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 1-3/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 1-7/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 2-1/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 2-1/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 2-3/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 2-1/2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 2-5/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 2-3/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 2-7/8" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 3" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 3-1/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 3-1/2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 3-3/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 4-1/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 4-1/2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 4-3/4" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620

 5" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 5-1/2" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620
 6" {A} Rd Cold Finished 8620


 Jean Prudhomme

 -----------------------------------------
 Jeff is on here so I think he will answer.

 Paul Lamar


 Jean,

 Good information. Thanks, I was considering chrome moly 4130 for
 the same application but was not happy about the way it machines.
 I am interested in purchasing a chunk of 6 inch round by about 8
 inches long. My thinking, is to have the six inch prop flange on the
 outer size machined down to the outer seal step, and then reduced down
 the 3 inch dia. bearing step and finally machine the inner spline. On
 the Bell PSRU the forged planet gear housing has a female spline plate
 that is bolted to it. Like Mistral's design I will have the Prop
 shaft necked down after the spline and threaded to accommodate a 52mm
 Hex nut. This nut locks the unit together The most inner partt of the
 shaft reduces down to about 20mm and rides in the inner bearing. The
 inside of the bar will be bored out to lighten it up. For maximum
 toughness I would prefer starting with a forged bar though. If you or
 anyone else is thinking the same way I would be willing to go in on a
 group buy of material. Any info on a forged piece?

 Doug in Japan


 Doug

 Just read your request....sounds interesting..I can help if you want,
 let me know.............

 BTW 4130 is not difficult to machine annealed, choose the best material
 for the application.......

 jeff

 Jeff is right, you may wish to use annealed 4140 tubing, HT to Rc 60 or
 so.
 milo

 Jean,


 Please tell me how you would attach the prop flange. Taper or key way?
 Both? I
 assume the inner piece is threaded.

 Doug in Japan

               Doug
 The flange have big splines and will be hold by threaded nuts with large
 flange and tighted with hight torque by bolting the flange on long pce of
 flat metal to hold it at torquing time..
 At the end of splines on prop flange i design a taper who will meet the
one
 one prop shaft.
 An o ring will be located between the propshaft and the flange nut.

 For bearing lubrication i will machine a passageway on the housing for
 feeding and oil return under the mid sleeve bushing and the mid sleeve
 bearing will be pressure fit before final i.d. size machining
 I know my housing will not fit Jeff plate holes but it will be much
 stronger the fact a constant speed will be driven and the front housing is
 available true Speedway engineering.

 The aluminum housing will be close to tracy weight might be a  1 or 2lbs
at
 the most but i try to get lighter as possible.
 With the 2 parts housing it will be much more accurate  to lock the ring
 gear before final assembly.

 I had a bearing on the sungear shaft at the seal location but it can be
 built without it but i prefer adding a roller or ball bearing at this
 position.
 I did several assembly design to obtain the best configuration and i am at
 the stage to details all parts.
 I do have an estimate for all bearings and it is close to $400 and i still
 searching for better price.


 Jean Prudhomme



 To reduce shaft weight and minimize cost would it be practical to shrink
fit
 an interior sleeve in the prop shaft end(s) (all parts annealed) and then
 bore and thread near the parting line? Will the bolt threads change too
much
 after HT and grinding for bearing ID? Or,  is it more practical to bore
 thicker wall to the ID shape?

 Dan F

 Jean,


 I see your dilemma.  You want to reduce part count and  eliminate having a
bolt on connection to the planetary gear carrier.  Your challenge then is
basically cost and access to the interior boring operations.  Usually, but
not always, more modular construction is cheaper in mass production.  A
flanged bolt on connection to the planetary set carrier would prove to be
the cheapest way to go.  Paul has done an illustration with this concept
before.  Actually that is what the Bell 47 does.  The internal spline plate
in the photo middle far left bolts to the planetary carrier lower center.
 Notice the six bolt holes around the outer side.  Another round plate (not
pictured) bolts to the inner circle of the splined plate to catch the
locking nut on the prop shaft that protrudes through.  The spline connection
plate rests against the main 3" ID outer bearing.  The three inch shaft
makes up for the fact that the unit is rather short coupled.  That is the
distance between the inner bearing and  the outer bearing is less than four
inches.

 With your gear set of choice, I would consider  Dan's above advice, that
is, press in the interior sleeve to carry the bearing after all internal
boring is finished.  Putting a small step in that internal bearing seat area
will insure the sleeve is positioned accurately. Doing it this way the lathe
operations are pretty straight forward and less expensive.

 Cheers

 Doug in Japan

 Here are some illustrations on the subject.

 Paul Lamar

Paul,

Those weren't the illustrations I was thinking about.  I believe you have
one that has an internally flanged prop shaft.  The bolts screw into the
planet carrier housing.

Doug in Japan

You will have to narrow it down more than that. How about a sketch?
Most of my bolt on flange designs rely on the shear strength
of the bolts. Same as the old Power Sport design. That is where
I got the idea. I figure if it worked for them it will work
for me :) Some types of bolts have enormous strength.


Paul Lamar



Doug

I wasn't very clear on what I had in mind.  The insert is intended to
eliminate interior shaft machining - the bolt holes will be partly in the
tube wall (say 1/3 of bolt dia) and 2/3 dia in the insert.  The shrink fit
and threads hold the parts together.  Then machine the tube outside to
attain wall thickness and bearing journal dia.  Will this work?   For a 6.5
B single rotor how about 8 .25-24 bolts with 4 locater bushings at each end?
(larger bolts for a 13 B)   :)

Dan F



Dan, f

Perhaps it wasn't your intention but you did give me an idea on how to make my prop shaft easier.  Thanks for the inspiration.  I will now machine a step into the  inner part of two inch dia. shaft bore and stick the inner bearing there. OD of shaft is about 3". Now if I can find  a thick, forged tube 6" inch OD, with a 2" ID  I will have saved a lot of  boring (literally) work.

Now for your idea.   Can it be done? Sure.  Is it a strong joint?  Sorry  I don't think so.  Bear in mind I am not an expert machinist but through experience I have found a round pipe or round bar that comes from the manufacturer is never round.   Machining is necessary to get a good  fit.  For interference fits, excellent machining holding close tolerances is mandatory.

As I understand your idea,   drilling and tapping holes at  the  insert/ tube joint line and expecting it to hold the insert and rotating parts together is risky.  Even if the insert was welded in you would still have, in effect,  two man-made fracture lines running longitudinally through each  thread.  In effect there would be  a series of short radian threads. The thread loses its integrity and it's holding power diminishes in unpredictable manner over time as the insert micro flexes.  The bolts as you mentioned would also have to absorb torsional forces. Even if the upper bore hole was  counter sunk, the rotating forces would widen the gap in the joint line weakening the thread even more.

As you probably know there are rotating engine parts where a bolt appear to do double duty.  Notice how a clutch plate is attached to the flywheel.  Logic would suggest the bolts are seeing some torsional force  but the  frictional footprint of the mating surfaces is so large the torsional forces are miniscule. And that is one key to good design. Flat accurate interfaces between the mating surfaces .

Doug in Japan.

Doug the secret to handling large bar stock is finding a really
big lathe and large drills. Shops with these tools can drill
a 3 inch hole in just a few minutes. Surely there is a ship
yard in Tokyo bay some place.


Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.