Subject: Will I be able to install A rotary
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 12/6/2010, 9:48 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Hi Everyone,

Firstly thank you for letting me into your world.

My name is Keith (41) and I live In South Australia.
I was wondering if anyone could help me..

I'm just going through flying school and have appox 22 hours ... I am
looking at
building a kit plane. The plane I'm looking at is a Morgans Aeroworks
Sierra
100. As the build seems very simply...and at AU$24,500 for the
basic
Kit
seems reasonably priced.
http://www.morganaeroworks.com.au/sierra100.html

With a Jabiru 6 cylinder engine 120HP, empty weight is about 313kg
(690
lbs)
With a  M TOW of 544kg (1200lbs) for LSA class.

Details of Jabiru 3300  engine 83.5 kg (178 lbs) complete including
exhaust,carburetor, starter motor, alternator and ignition system....
http://www.jabiru.net.au/

Is it possible to install a rotary to meet this criteria? (Possible a
single
rotor version.....)


Any Ideas or help or comments would be appreciated.

Keith

As I recall the Jabiru 6 cylinder engine 120HP is rated at 3300 RPM
which is not the same thrust as an AC engine rated at 2700 RPM.
Prop efficient is down at 3300 RPM. Now a one rotor 120 HP Mazda would
be geared to run the prop at 2700 RPM. However 178 pounds all up for
the engine alone is hard to beat. You would need aluminum end housings
to get in that ball park with a Mazda. If you can wait awhile the
AIXRO Wankel kart engine manufacturer is coming out with a two
rotor version at around 100 HP that should be near ideal for that
category of light sport air craft.

Since the time to build is not much longer
for something bigger, faster  and more powerful I would go bigger.
Then you can use a much cheaper and more powerful Mazda 2 rotor.

I suspect there would be little difference in the kit price.
In that case you would get a faster airplane which is very
important if we are talking cross country. Australia is a large
country. You need a faster airplane. I know because I have flown
all over the interior.

Paul Lamar


Paul I recognize some of those locations but the stuff next to water
has me
stumped.
I would love to know the locations if near an airfield for future trips.
Cheers.
Nige.

That is Brampton Island in the Coral Sea.
Here are a couple of screen shots. A long way from Adelaide :)

Paul Lamar

Hi Keith,

 If you want to live to a ripe old age, NEVER put a
Jabiru
motor into your air craft. They are crap, they have had many issues
in the
past and they don't seem to have addressed them at all.

A flying school here in NZ bought two Jabiru's, both have had engine
failure, resulting in one of them being written off, the pilot was very
lucky to only sustain minor injuries.

Chris in NZ.

What kind of failures Chris?

Paul Lamar

Hi Chris in NZ

I have to Agree with you, that's why I looking @ a rotary.

I have only 22 hours of flying time and I have had 2 engine failures in
a jabiru
2200 (different planes)

The first was a broken through bolt..
Plane started to vibrate badly, first thought it was a prop, had to
declare Pan
pan and limp back to the strip @ just above idle....
Broken bolt and cracked cylinder..was the problem ( Running on 3
cylinders Plus
the leaking oil went all over distributors cause engine to miss as
well...)

The Second was on startup, Dropped a valve..or a valve seat came
loose. I
think....

regards Keith


Hi Paul,

Sorry it?s taken a while to get back, been getting the gen.
On one of the aircraft the timing belt pulley fell off (sheared the
bolts holding it on to the crank)

The other was piston failure (collapsed skirt)

Two very good reasons to do away with pistons altogether.

Chris in NZ


Paul, Out of curiosity I found a site called "recreationalaviation.com
<http://recreationalaviation.com>" with 172 posts about the Jabiru
2200.  Early failures were the flywheel attach bolts now corrected with
larger bolts and early engines field altered to the new bolts.

Continuing problems with the chrome molly through bolts at the base of
the cut (not rolled) threads. These bolts go through the cylinder base
flange the crankcase halves and the opposing cylinder flange. Failures
occur at approximately  440 hours although some failed at 170 hours up
to over 550 hours. the failure results in a loose cylinder and oil loss.

If not reduced to idle power due to large vibration issues the cylinder
can fail and the crankshaft ends up bowed to where it is noticeable hand
propping the engine. The other common failure is failed cylinders due to
loose head bolts. The re torquing interval is 25 hours and apparently the
bolt near the exhaust is covered by something and has been missed.

According to the factory the loose head to cylinder joint promotes
detonation resulting in cylinder base flange cracking. This sounds like
the result of poor maintenance. The through bolts are to be replaced as
routine maintenance and some failures of engines rebuilt at 600 hours
failed due to the bolts being reinstalled at the rebuild. The early
rebuilds are due to cylinder compression loss thought to be the result
of a factory lean of peak jet replacement for improved fuel economy.

Early engines had some problems with valve head to stem separation
causing catastrophic failure of the cylinder. This problem is currently
rectified in later builds.

Few owners who were happy with their engines answered the
survey so the percentage of engine problems is unknown. Most seemed
satisfied with the factory response to their problems and the quick
shipment of replacement parts.

george grimes

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.