Subject: cross counter flow heat exchangers
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 12/14/2010, 1:50 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Dear Sir,

 Can you gentlemen fabricate cross counter flow heat
 exchangers for internal combustion engines?

 Thank you for your time.

 Paul Lamar
 Editor

 Dear Paul

 We have the ability to produce a wide range of coolers to specific size
 and design, do you have a drawing of the cooler you require?

 Please find attached a photograph oh the Mistral engine with our water
 and oil coolers.

 Kind regards Mel Johnson
 Engineering Director
 Docking Engineering.
 mel.johnson@dockingengineering.com


 Paul,

 Wow,!  Did it cool well?  This is  the identical mounting config. I was going to use  but only for the water heat exchanger.   That picture contradicts a lot of assumptions I have had about cooling.  Why warm up the air with the oil cooler before sending it into the water cooler? Notice  both heat exchangers are one pass side to side.

 Doug in Japan

 That picture was taken at Aero in 2009.
 They never got a chance to fly it.

 Here is the last configuration that flew in 2010. It did not cool
 because the air was coming in from the bottom and the back exit side of
 the oil rad was blocked by the oil pan. Page 46 and 47 in my book.

 I was helping them with  a fix when the lights went out.

 On this flight configuration the oil cooler got the hot air from the
 rad. In other words the oil cooler was on the top and not the
 bottom while the Aero non flown configuration was the opposite and
 would have worked better if the air was brought in from the
 top of the cores and allowed to exit straight down through
 the oil cooler.

 The mistake was based on the erroneous assumption that pointy
 cowls are significantly better than blunt cowls.

 Question for you. Why is the oil cooler the same size as the water
 rad?


 Paul Lamar

Paul,

Yes, I see what you are saying about the configurations.  The answer to your question of why  the heat exchanger are the same size is  easy!  Because they are cheaper to make.  Only half kidding:)    Performance wise  it is because of the balanced air flow through it, and  the  low delta T the oil X-changer experiences (if the x-changers are flipped in position) will require more surface area and a lower oil flow velocity to  work satisfactory. Oil pressure within the unit will be lower as well which might be a good thing for an untested design.

If if works, fine.  Me, I would take that same space and divide it up differently.   I would rather pick up a proven oil cooler that has a known track record.  Setrab, Modine, etc.  For instance I'd put a 3 inch thick by 5 inch wide by 20" long standard dual pass oil X-changer  next to your proposed 3 " thick RCF design and have the best of both worlds.  Connection are also in back. Installed both together they would be about 22 inches wide.  Enough to fit in my planned 24 inch wide cowl. I may need a slight turbo bulge  and a shoe horn to fit everything else in though. Intercooler and rammed air scoop on top sticks up a wee bit over the standard front cowl height.

Doug in Japan

See the last message about cooling drag.

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.