Dale, I wouldn't classify housings that cose $2650.00 apiece for end
housings as cost effective. As a basis for a four rotor I am not
comfortable with the series cooling at continuous 6400 RPM. Using
390 or 398 alloy housings no coatings for wear are needed. This
material (390) is used in lawn mower engines and despite the post
last week that it wasn't successful in the chevrolet vega it was.
The problems with the vega were a result of cost cutting on the
part of GM where they used a much too small radiator and other
cooling system problems. With no maintenance of coolant level there
were overheating issues. During overhaul after overheating it took
a 3 step process to restore the cylinder bores that was ignored by
amatuer mechanics in favor of the methods they used for cast iron
blocks. Imformation on the vega durability and cooling problems are
easy to access in yahoo or google.
To produce a two piece end housing with coolant flow paths
(parallel cooling) as well as increased flow rates and including
mounting provisions is not that difficult. The housings can be
faced off in a large lathe and lapped. The lathe approach allows
boring the stationary gear bore and some "O" ring seats while it is
chucked up for accuracy. "O" ring paths for rotor housing seals can
be done in a CNC router. If I didn't have the machine tools I could
farm out everything with an end cost of $700 for the front or
center housing and $850 for the bellhousing end. I drew mine up
with a front and rear bellhousing which are dowel alligned so that
two sets of RX8 internals can be used for a 4 rotor. As a six rotor
the prop end e-shaft would need modifications. If I farm out the
foundary casting at $140 and buy the "O" rings for $90 which
includes double sealing the water to oil seals at the stationary
gear I can build them for $250 apiece. That would be about $1500
for all the housings of a four rotor.
george grimes
Yea, the retail prices on aftermarket alum housings forces me into
the foundry yard. It really is much cheaper that way. I am too
skilled to pay $6k for something I can produce on my own.
The 390 alum used in the 928/944/968 porsche engines worked great as
a cylinder surface, even great for the 944 turbo. The correct
boring/honing process had to be followed. This is totally different
from the air cooled 911 mahle cylinders.
I'm definitely in the game for producing these light weight parts.
Ed Carver
Hi guys,
I was looking at some speculation on the possible internal
measurements of the
16X engine and why Mazda may be doing things the way it appears they
may be
looking at. The increased radius (R) and offset (e) are easy to
understand.
Like stroking a boing boing engine. The reduced rotor depth or width
and the
explanation of flame travel sounds reasonable; more burned fuel for
better
economy and less emissions. The proposed dimensions for the 16X are
similar to
the 13A engine. Now I know parts for that really rare engine will
not be
readily available or inexpensive.
My thought is that if people on this news letter are going to the
expense in
time and money to build parts dedicated to aircraft use, maybe it
would be an
opportunity to make use of some of the possible design benefits that
Mazda and
others have spent millions on. If the R and e of the 13A were
incorporated
with the 70mm width of the 12A, the apex seals would be readily
available. End
housings would not be very different. Building rotor housngs would
pose a
bigger difficulty. The inner oil seals could pose a small
difficulty with
respect to the diameter around the rotor diameter for the greater
eccentricity. The other problem would be side seals as the greater
length
between apex seals would require custom build. Corner seals could be
used from
what is todays most durable design.
It would not take Jeff a lot to scale the Al rotors to get them
to the
required size and also to make the e-shafts.
Maybe I am leaving yellow snow, but just thinking, and maybe get you
people
thinking also. It could help bsfc and the larger displacement looks
like 305
to 310 HP for a 2 rotor based on the pport numbers. A 3 rotor could
be in the
450 to 475 HP range. This with the same weights as current engines.
Dale Davies
If somebody can show us how to make the steel liner for the rotor
housings, and then make the hard chrome stick permanently to the
liner, We're good to go. No shortage of chrome around, just can't
make it stick.
Ed Carver
You don't need chrome Ed. Just hard steel 4130 sheet and then have
it nitride'ed. I would start with .090 thick. If that does not
work out
you can go thicker later on with the same Al water jackets.
However if you insist on chrome you contact the people that
re chrome cylinder liners as there is a trick to making it porous.
The porosity retains an oil film.
Richard Sohn uses a cast iron liner which has a porosity of it's own.
However Mazda induction hardens the cast iron and then nitride'ed
it. I think Richard is doing the same.
Paul Lamar
Paul, I have been following the postings about useing a steel or iron
liner backed by an aluminum water jacket. The setup by Richard Sohn in
the image where it is assembled on the workbench appears to be Mazda
housings with the back side machined off and replaced with an aluminum
section. IMHO this is a viable solution which addresses my concerns
about sealing the junction of water and oil located around the
stationary gear bore. This arangement also allows reconfiguring the end
housings with engine mounts or parallel cooling. The down side is the
amount of iron that is not replaced and therefore overall weight is
lower but not at the minimum. I seem paranoid about water and oil
separation and eventually used three "O" reings around the stationary
gear for the two piece housing. They are located radially around a
telescopic capable joint line. One for hot oil, one formulated for
glycol and one between for both liquids. I have two benefits for the
twopiece housings. The first is no need for a cored pattern, and the
second is that I can have access to the side ports if I use them for CNC
machining as they end up half in each side of the housing pieces. I
still plan on "O" ring sealing the two parts although a post earlier
this year advocated asembling with adhesive epoxie sounds intreguing.
As you may resall I am using 390 or if I can get material 398
aluminum for the side housings. Reading the above post you suggest a
steel liner of .090 thickness with a porous chrome plateing. This is
obviously not the plan showing flat socket head screws from the inside
of the housing threaded into the back side of the stationary gear
flange. Personally I was concerned about the screws being inside the
rotor housing and the proximity of the rotor oil seal as well as sealing
water and oil. This current suggestion of .090 thickness is a bit thin
for combustion pressures structurally and there is the possibility of
the flat steel sheat distorting from heating and cooling stresses. No
problem with the cylinder liner chrome process, however this got me
thinking about the idea of a back up plan for the wear surface of
aluminum housings. If the housing is a closed casting or two part CNC
machined part it would have a continuous face to back up the wear
surface plate for structural strength. The plate could cover the full
width of the housing so the tension bolts would also run through it to
clamp the perimiter. Alternatively the housing posted by Jeff with the
joint midway between the rotor housing "O" ring seals seems to be a
reasonable approach as long as the stationary gear is attached to a part
registered on the rotor housing hollow dowels. Personally I like the
full width wear plate because it doesn't require a precision depth cut
into the housing and a wear surface ground to that thickness which seems
to introduce an unnecessary complication.
This new .090 wear plate could be water jet cut out of stainless
steel which should be better at resisting heat distortion and would not
require chrome plating of the wear plate. No matter what material the
wear plate is made from it will need a grinding/lapping of the running
surface. This would leave the oil retaining surface available on the
stock housing.I would also increase the finished thickness of the wear
surface to .187 to make it stiffer.
This brings up a question of heat transfer to the cooling system.
With a dry fit liner in an aluminum cylinder the liner would expand
with temperature to press against the aluminum block both to maintain
shape and provide heat transfer. With the flat wear plate we would
likely need to connect the two mating surfaces for heat transfer. MY
question is how and when. I would preffer having it attached before
lapping the surface for accuracy. Would epoxie be appropriate, or some
type of furnace brazing/silver soldering. Could some type of heat
transfer paste like used on the joint between computer chips and heat
sinks be workable. This would be easier to apply and remove if the wear
plate needs replaced.
The stainless wear plate would be a single part approach useable
on the variety of aluminum housings being proposed. It would fit all the
wear surfaces on single rotor as well as 2,3,and four rotor
configurations. This could possibly be used to salvage a damaged three
rotor wide housing by facing off the damaged side. Early 13B or RX8
rotor housings with the "O" ring grooves in the rotor housing rather
than the end housing seem best to use. The flat sided rotor housings
could of course have the "O" ring grooves CNC cut to use with the flat
sided wear plate. This plate without side port openings would make
sealing up the original side port locations unnecessary for a "P" port
conversion.
Obviously it took less time to think this stuff up than to type
it here, and if I corrected typos, spelling, and grammar it would be
twice the investment. So that makes this a half price idea. Anybody
buying into it.
george grimes
george
I like the SS insert from a heat control standpoint as the best
solution. If 398 is in fact good should we at least try some for
testing? I was excited about the Diamondyze ceramic filler (I hesitate
to call it a coating because of no part growth) where they are making
sparks off a file on a 6061 alum part with NO deterioration of the alum.
Would this filler be as good or better than 398 on a machined end
housing ? If someone will machine the housings and my donor e-shaft I
will do my best to get the housings Diamondyze anodized, then build and
test a single rotor. RIP Bob White who first brought this to our
attention.
Dan F
Dan FPersonally I am inclined to use the 398 aluminum if it is
available to purchase. It is a patented alloy which may make it
unavailable in a quantity of a few hundred pounds. It is desirable due
to the mechanical properties as the first choice. The 390-17 aluminum is
easy to get at a scrap yard from old lawn mower engines and after 26
years in common use likely available as ingots which a foundry would
have access to. I am thinking about running the patterns in MDF on my
gantry router and using them with plaster moulds to make permanent
foundary patterns out of scrap aluminum, The actual parts would be green
sand cast at a foundary.
The concern with after cast coatings is that the cost is more
than the part it is coating. Also there is no guarantee that it will
remain viable and if it fails the rotor housings would be at risk. Bruce
Terentine had a quantity of ceramic coated rotors on his assembly bench
when I visited him a while back and he was comfortable with useing them.
I have not heard of a failed engine that he has built and would conclude
it works on the rotors. Where I think coatings are usefull is when the
end housings are CNC machined out of billet aluminum which limits the
choice of alloys to those rolled into plates that the billets were cut
from. Without the silicon carbide in the aluminum I would choose the
.187 thick stainless wear plate. If a billet could be obtained in 398 it
would likely me slow to CNC machine.
george grimes
I have seen ceramic coated rotors that had the coating come off.
It utterly destroyed the $800 rotor housings. It is not worth
the risk IMHO.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.