Subject: 2 to 4 rotor question
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/6/2011, 9:24 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 From past experience of piston cranks, I know they can be welded and
 repaired. Now, the question, could I cut, weld, and heat treat two
 13B  cranks to make a four rotor?

 Regards,
 Norm P.

 Well yes and no. Most 4 rotor e-shafts are three pieces.
 Other wise you can not get the engine together.
 You almost have to have taken apart and put back
 together a 2 rotor to understand why.

 Paul Lamar

 Norm P. There is a lot you can do for drag racing that will not survive
 in airraft use.  The first problem is that a normally aspirated P-Port
 four rotor is 500 HP  at  takeoff RPM and 440 continuous available
 for  cruise. With more gear reduction than 2.85 to 1 the horsepower
 can be  well over 600.  Using the stock components lined up on a custom
 eccentric shaft the cooling  glycol goes from the pump through all
 the  side housings and rotor housings, then crosses across the rear housing
 and back to the front housing outlet . As the water heats up progressing
 through the assorted housings the cooling around the spark plug
 area  becomes inadequate resulting in detonation. The plugs, apex
 seals and  stationarg gears will have problems from the detonation.
 There have been  conversions of intermediate housings to allow
 parallel cooling where the  coolant only passes through a single
 rotor housing. This is possible but  the tension bolts and water
 seal "O" rings limit the size of opening  into the housings.

  Second concern is balancing the e-shaft.  Many people have
 built four or more rotor engines with the eccentrics staggered 180
 degrees to balance the  rotating assembly with counterweights only
 on  the ends of the shaft. Theu use stock counterweights which are
 also used  as mounting flanges and spacers for other parts. If the
 two intermediate  eccentrics don't need counterweights then using
 that same logic the end  counterweights on a two rotor which is an
 180 degree offset wouldn't  have counterweights either.

  The accessory  pumps are also a problem. An oil pump designed
 for a three rotor  would be a stretch on a high output four rotor,
 If  all the oil was for lubrication of eccentric and stationary gear bearings that would be fine. However 1/3 of the heat rejection of
 the  engine is from oil sprayed into the rotors and around the E-
 shaft. As  continuous power increases so does this need for heat
 rejection. The  three rotor water pump is also low on flow rate for
 a four rotor which  needs 50 GPM at full power. The pump has twice
 as many passages to push  the water through and therefore more back
 pressure which will reduce the  flow rateeven further.

 There are several ways to address these issues. You can search
 the Internet for the five rotor Curtis Wright aircraft engine which
 might give some insight.  Also on the Internet is Grannies speed shop
 which close coupled two complete  two rotor engines less one flywheel
 and starter. This was raced in a circle track modofied. The stock
 E-shafts were connected with a home made coupling. After you get
 through Paul Lamars web site you should also go thru
 Craigsrotarypage.com which has a lot of info particularly on the foreign
 engines such as the Russian 3 and 4 rotors aircraft engines.

  The basic Mazda parts are accurately described as robust as
 evidenced by huge two stage turbochargers and NOS systems on drag racing
 cars making 1600 HP. The cooling and lubrication issues of an
 engine  under load for seven seconds  is different than hours at
 near wide open  throttle in an aircraft.

 Personally I went with stacking complete engine rotating
 assemblies with aluminum end housings, The rear or the front
 engine and  front of the rear engine have matching bell housings
 located on dowel  pins for alignment. The center housings are
 modified for parallel  cooling and extra fasteners are added. The
 oil system is a 5  stage  stock car gerotor type and the water pump
 is 426 Chrysler big block. The  designs are frozen, the G-code is
 compiled for my CNC gantry router but  I haven't built a test engine
 yet. I plan on putting a six rotor in a  1965 E-type Jag with turbocharging.

 George grimes

 AA Drag racing engine frequently don't have any cooling what so ever.
 The metal does not get a chance to over heat in 5 seconds.

 One way to cool a four rotor is make all end an intermediate
 housing  two pieces NC furnace brazed together with parallel radial
 cooling by  external plumbing. The secret to making this work is monitoring
 the rotor housing with four thermocouples mounted just below the lower
 spark plugs sending info to four temp gages on the instrument
 panel.  Then tailoring the flow accordingly. Not a bad idea for a 3 rotor
 as well.

 Endurance racing Chev V8'a are frequently modified with parallel
 cooling system using a plethora of external plumbing hoses.

 The Orenda big block based Chev V8 $100,000 aircraft engine had
 external parallel cooling galleries cast into a custom block design.

 Paul Lamar

 Paul,  I am running the water in the center housings just below the
 lower spark plug  to an internal manifold.  From there it divides and
 feeds half through the front rotor housing and half through the
 back. The end housing  internal flow manifold distributes the return
 to the center housing and is used to heat the cool side to reduce temperature
 variations in the housings side to side. The water exits the top on the
 intermediate housing to carry steam away.There is an obvious difference
 in flow passage capacity in the stock housings shown in your
 attachments.

 There is about three  times as much area on the hot side as
 the cold side. As seen in the attachment only two thruholes go directly
 into a rotor housing opening while 9 line up with the hot side
 passages, On the face side which is against the rotor housing there
 are recesses cast in the stock rotor  housing which allow flow
 around the intake port area to additional rotor housing coolant
 passages. I have expanded on the recesses and added more area thru
 the housing to increase flow back through the cool side of the
 housing. This will not change the actual flow through the rotor
 housing but will allow future increases.  Several of the cooling
 passages thru the stock rotor housings have bulkheads with smaller
 thru passages to control flow rates and add turbulence. In future I
 may drill out a percentage of blocked areas until the area is equal
 in both directions. At that point additional end housing flow may be
 useful.

 I am using a balanced piston flow divider on the exit side
 of the water flow where the two engine modules water combines to go
 to the radiator. Any difference in flow pushes the piston towards
 the low pressure side to increase area on the higher pressure side
 until the flow is close to equal. There are no thermostats used.

 I get the idea of the thermocouples to equalize cooling  which
 will be useful on a test stand. Trying to implement something to bias
 the balanced piston flow control  is doable if necessary. An adjustable
 spring on each side of the balanced piston could be added  and set at
 maximum cooling load.

 george grimes



Hi George,

I tried to search for the 5 rotor CW you mentioned and found nothing. I did
find a reference to 5 rotors at Freedom Motors which appears to have some
involvement with Moller. They mention up to 9 rotors but I could find no
specifics. Can  you give a hint as to where to find the CW 5 rotor info?

Thank you,

Dale Davies

They do exist.
If I told you where Dale I would have to kill you :)
Here is a Curtis Wright 5 rotor in a secret location.

Paul Lamar


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.