Subject: Aluminum rotors.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/8/2011, 5:45 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


I have a suspicion that an all alloy rotor would have problems
with keeping the fit of the pressed in e-shaft bearing with the
  rotor
expansion and contraction due to temperature. I was considering
  using
what I would call a flanged sleeve made of steel to mount the
  bearing
and stationary gear. The stationary gear fits into the face of the
flange, the bearing in the bore, and the alloy rotor fits over the
outside of the sleeve with dowel pins into the back side of the
flange.
It doesn't appear too difficult to CNC the negative patterns to
  cast

the
wax as a left and right side with the wax sections keyed together.
The
difficult part is machining the side seal grooves which was a major
stumbling block for rotamax. I was thinking of a router motor
swinging
in the proper arc over an indexing table but reading how much
  trouble
others have had with this it is obviously not that easy. Useing 398
for
the rotor doesn't seem to be a problem as far as galling with side
housings of the same material because the side inner and outer oil
seals
keep the parts separated. Temperature control of the rotor might
require
a modified control of an increased oil flow thru the rotor from the
stock Mazda design although a prototype  of the stock type would be
tried first. Alloy parts with different compression depressions
  would
reuse the same flanged sleeve.


george grimes

There is a steel insert in Jeff's design for the rotor bearing.
The side seal grooves are a piece of cake for an NC mill.
Mazda mounts 3 rotors on a pallet and rotates the pallet to cut
three groves at a time with a broach.

Paul Lamar Graduate of a course in NC machining :)


Yes, there needs to be a greatly increased oil spray directly
  on the
inside of the rotor, accompanied with a powerful vacuum to draw it
out.
This should greatly reduce temps. I think a dual oil pump may
  need to
be used.

Does anyone think the Beryllium/alum cast rotor idea can't work?

Ed Carver


I am presently drilling into the issue of obtaining a small
  quantity of
the beralcast 310 and the nasa 398. Starmet is the exclusive
  vendor for
the beralcast, and a salesperson is kicking the ball back and forth
with
me. I have contacted one of the nasa employees about a direct
vendor for
the 398.

Normal alloy vendors sort of give me the blank stare when I ask
  them
about these materials. Never heard of them.

George, have you found a vendor for the 398?

Ed Carver

OK guys some things to think about. First the rotary's problem
  isn't
too much heat in the combustion chamber. Rather the problem is
  that the
long and narrow chamber REMOVES too much heat for best
  efficiency. This
is probably why Mazda hasn't made a aluminum rotor besides the
  cost.
Second the rotor is a nice casting and the side plates are
  probably a
better area to remove weight. Of course there isn't anything
  wrong with
a lighter rotor, but heat transfer through the rotor wouldn't
be a big
plus. The last concern is to be sure that the apex seal slots don't
flex or wear too much. That can result in loss of a seal. The best
material for the light weight rotor might be ceramic, or one of the
cermet materials.
Bill Jepson

I want to point out to the many new guys that this is unnecessary.
These guys just like to push the envelope :)

The stock Mazda engine makes a great aircraft engine as is.

Paul Lamar



Ed Carver, I really haven't tried to source 398 yet. I like it
  for the
mechanical properties and would use it if available. Possibly
  there are
things available as scrap the way that 390-17 can be found at the
  county
land fill. My next question is how to find out if the whole briggs
engine is 390 or just the cylinder block. I can use other alloys
  for the
back side of the housing where there are no wear surfaces and
  use the
rest of the scrap there. If it is all the same alloy it would
  be easier
to just pull off copper and plastic parts then melt the whole
  engine.

george grimes


  I just spoke to a nasa admin about getting some 398, and was
  told they
  have licensed a foundry in the Chicago area to produce and
  distribute
  this material within 3 to 6 months; apparently to the general
  public,
  for purposes such as ours. I would say this is much slower going
  than I
  could imagine. The 398 alloy has barely seen use since it was
  patented
  nearly 10 years ago.

  Still waiting on beralcast corp to reply about availability of
  product.

  Ed Carver

  Ed, most people on here are looking to save money on aircraft
  engines. One gets the price down by using mass produced products.
  Automotive piston engines are not durable enough for aircraft.

  Light weight rotors are only cost effective if you would like
  to turn the engine at over 11,000 RPM.

  The p-port 2 rotor's excellent power to weight ratio is hardly
  in the
  class of a hunk of lead :)

  The p-port exist because we need an intake  manifold of some sort
  anyway and
  the P-port fits all versions of the Mazda rotary and gives an extra
  50 HP.
  The stock RX8 manifold is too high to fit under a cowl.

  IMHO one should focus on real problems if any. I would say
  high on the priority list is getting some weight out of the PSRU.
  True getting the weight out of a one rotor is also up there.
  Light weight rotors will not help much.

  Probably the last thing a 2 rotor needs for aircraft use is aluminum
  rotors.
  Are you talking one rotor engines. There you might save a little
  weight.


  Paul Lamar

  Ed Carver,  Did yiu get a name or E-maik address of the foundary
  in Chicago,

  george grimes


  No George, the fellow simply stated they had released patent rights
  to a foundry in that area to produce the material. I should call
  them back to get the answer to that question. I intended to chase it
  down again in a few months; but probably better to get the name of
  the shop. Will call again monday. The fellow did seem to be
  forthcoming with willingness to help us get the stuff.

  Paul I can't imagine using a non p port arrangement. RX8 rotors are
  not cheap. You will have to excuse my persistence in wanting to
  lighten everything. I truly loathe this iron stuff. There is just no
  point in it anymore unless there is a real good reason for why the
  parts cannot be made of light alloys. Most of the engines I have
  worked on over the past 20 years have been made from alloys of
  aluminum, or mag.

  It does remain to be seen what the costs will be for the materials.
  I hav'nt gotten a reply from the beralcast/IBC corp yet about
  availability of their beryllium casting alloy. Unless the stuff is
  excessively expensive, I will continue development. So we will see
  how it turns out.

  I have installed hyper alloy pistons in engines, many oems use them.
  The pistons are nearly pressed into the cylinders; only .001in. side
  wall clearance. The stuff does'nt expand much. It is also
  inexpensive to create. Much less than forgings. The preferred
  pistons for racing in most of the porsche atmospheric engines are
  made from one of the hyper alloys, with, or without, a cermet dome
  coating.

  Anyone who thinks it is just a terrible idea to create lightweight
  rotary parts from a design perspective, tell me why it won't/can't
  work. The whole thing just gets hotter. That appears to be the
  biggest hurdle.

  Back to assembling my 993 C4 cab. (including air cooled lawn mower
  engine:)

  Ed

 The point of the iron rotors is they run at 500 F.
 Aluminum looses half its strength at 500F. Even 398
 is 30% down.

 The iron rotors are one
 of the things that make the rotary so robust. I pointed that
 out in my Kitplanes article. The rotors make up half the surface
 area of the combustion chamber and are cooled by oil.
 The oil cooling is 1/3rd the total cooling on the engine.
 The rotor is always in contact with hot combustion
 gases on one of its 3 faces. In a piston engine the individual
 pistons are cooled at least 25% of the time on the intake stroke
 and are only subjected to hot gases 25% of the time.

 I would not fly with an aluminum rotor unless it was extensively
 tested in endurance car racing like the Le Mans 24 hour race.
 It might work but it is going to be very expensive indeed to
 test it. Be/Al is another matter entirely.

 Paul Lamar



 Here's a link related to IBC/Beralcast:
  http://tinyurl.com/38txudc


  Ed Carver


Ed


 I am all for lighter rotors.  Not specifically to make more power,
 but to make the engine lighter.

If (when) the European engines become available many builders will think
a 120hp unit @ less than
150 lbs complete is a good deal... Even at more than $20,000

How about that sheet metal rotor idea?  A stainless face
would transfer even less heat than a cast
rotor, although a stamping die might be pricy.

Dan F

The European 150 pound, 120 HP Aixro has cast iron or steel rotors.

A stainless casting is also possible.

Any new rotor design must take into consideration the wear rate
of the apex seals on the apex seal slots.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.