The point of the iron rotors is they run at 500 F.
Aluminum looses half its strength at 500F. Even 398
is 30% down.
The iron rotors are one
of the things that make the rotary so robust. I pointed that
out in my Kitplanes article. The rotors make up half the surface
area of the combustion chamber and are cooled by oil.
The oil cooling is 1/3rd the total cooling on the engine.
The rotor is always in contact with hot combustion
gases on one of its 3 faces. In a piston engine the individual
pistons are cooled at least 25% of the time on the intake stroke
and are only subjected to hot gases 25% of the time.
I would not fly with an aluminum rotor unless it was extensively
tested in endurance car racing like the Le Mans 24 hour race.
It might work but it is going to be very expensive indeed to
test it. Be/Al is another matter entirely.
Paul Lamar
Another issue with alternate rotor materials that Kenichi writes
about in his
RE book is the expansion rate of the rotor material needs to be less
that the
other engine materials to prevent getting tight against the side
housings.
Dale Davies
Ed
I am all for lighter rotors. Not specifically to make more power,
but to make the engine lighter.
If (when) the European engines become available many builders will think
a 120hp unit @ less than
150 lbs complete is a good deal... Even at more than $20,000
How about that sheet metal rotor idea? A stainless face
would transfer even less heat than a cast
rotor, although a stamping die might be pricy.
Dan F
The European 150 pound, 120 HP Aixro has cast iron or steel rotors.
A stainless casting is also possible.
Any new rotor design must take into consideration the wear rate
of the apex seals on the apex seal slots.
Paul Lamar
I can't say that I have a great deal of faith in the 398 material as
a rotor combustion surface, I suppose it's survival depends on the
intended output power for each application. On the other hand, the
398 is the most rigid of all of the hyper alloys used in high temp
applications, and might hold the apex seal just fine without
premature wear. After all, the intended design for this material was
to make it possible to raise the top piston ring up much closer to
the top of the piston to eliminate captured hydrocarbons around the
top of the piston. Doing so exposes the ring seats to higher temps.
The 398 has very low expansion, as do many of the oem hyper alloy
engine materials.
FWIW, I might create a set of rotors without heavier metal apex seal
cast in inserts, and a set with the inserts, just to compare.
The beralcast 310 appears more promising. Even though the melt spec
appears similar to that of alum, it won't surprise me to see it is
substantially higher. It is 60-70% beryllium. The producer claims it
also has a very low heat expansion rate.
I am not inclined to believe that IBC/Beralcast wants to sell their
product in small quantities to private parties. They appear to mostly do
government contracts worldwide. Plus, the Beralcast subsidiary is a
foundry, and may want to do all of the casting procedures in house. I'm
going to pursue them further, it may be a dead end if I want to have a
local SoCal foundry do the work.
This may leave me looking exclusively to titanium. There are local shops
who specialize in investment casting using the vacuum induction furnace
process. Ti. is not the unobtainium it once was.
As far as a stainless combustion surface goes, if expansion
properties are not so different than the base light alloy, it may be a
solution. We could use inconel, titanium, or other,,,for that purpose.
I have some design ideas that may solve some of the basic problems.
Has anyone ever heard of a light alloy rotor fly apart under load? I've
seen lots of pistons that have; rotors never stop rotating, the stresses
are therefore spread out across the whole structure while they spin
around another spinning object that spins around a central axis. Lighten
the rotor, reduce the size of the gears, increase the cooling oil,
propel the oil out of the rotor with improved cast in internal cooling
fins/vanes; and get rid to that massive bunch of steel between the e
shaft rotor bearings.
We'll see what we can do with this stuff, it likely will take months
just to get the casting materials in hand.
Ed Carver
If I were you I would focus on the rotary racing market. That
is where the real incentive is.
Paul Lamar
Ed Carver,
If you can cast RX-8 rotors in beralcast 363, please put me down for two.
Doug in Nebraska
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.